General Discussion

Eko

(9,151 posts)

30. It doesnt.

Tue Apr 22, 2025, 10:07 PM

Apr 22

It increased.
I never said anything saying it did or didnt.

Eko (9,095 posts)
2. You can also be pro-Palestinian and anti-Israel and not be antisemitic.
Reply to Beastly Boy (Original post)
Tue Apr 22, 2025, 04:36 PM

Beastly Boy (11,993 posts)
3. Also true.
Reply to Eko (Reply #2)
Tue Apr 22, 2025, 05:38 PM

What the ADL statistics show, it is increasingly not the case. Alarmingly so.

If you werent saying that it is increasingly not the case. Alarmingly so. in regards to me saying this You can also be pro-Palestinian and anti-Israel and not be antisemitic. Then what was Also true and increasingly not the case and alarmingly so? Did you respond to the wrong post and if so why haven't you said so?
I never said that the incidents were not happening or that the number was wrong or that they weren't going up. All I said was you can be pro-Palestinian and anti-Israel and not be antisemitic. You're reply was Also true, increasingly not the case. Alarmingly so. Its painfully clear what you meant and what you tried to do in your main post and your reply to me.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

AloeVera

63 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

ADL: Antisemitic Incident Data Breaks All Previous Records [View all] Beastly Boy Apr 22 OP

It's rife in our political system ck4829 Apr 22 #1

You can also be pro-Palestinian and anti-Israel and not be antisemitic. Eko Apr 22 #2

Also true. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #3

I dont see how it shows that. Eko Apr 22 #4

Surely you are jesting! Beastly Boy Apr 22 #7

I think you are missing the big picture. Eko Apr 22 #9

I think you are missing the point. The pellucidly obvious one. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #12

Huh. Eko Apr 22 #16

No, this is what you are saying about what I am saying. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #19

That is not what you said at all. Eko Apr 22 #21

Oh goody, tell me more about what I said! Beastly Boy Apr 22 #24

I did, it was pretty easy. Eko Apr 22 #26

Here, Ill make it easier. Eko Apr 22 #23

I will make it even simpler. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #29

It doesnt. Eko Apr 22 #30

They're up because of the genocide HereForTheParty Apr 22 #5

Absolutely right, they count anti-Semitic signs and chants as anti-Semitic incidents, they don't make excuses for them. tritsofme Apr 22 #6

What is interesting is that poster's failure to see what they actually admitted to. Behind the Aegis Apr 22 #14

Anti-semitism IS up due to the genocide (at least according to the IRHA definition used by ADL). AloeVera Apr 24 #59

Anti-Semitism is up to due to anti-Semites. Behind the Aegis Apr 24 #60

Anti-Semitism is... AloeVera Apr 24 #61

Anti-Semitism doesn't need to be 'splained to a Jew. Behind the Aegis Apr 25 #62

Only antisemitic signs and chants. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #8

Exactly. The ADL report is questionable. AloeVera Apr 24 #35

Not surprising that the extreme left Jewish Currents has an issue with the IHRA definition of antisemitism. Beastly Boy Apr 24 #42

Probably lumping in criticism of Israel as automatically antisemitic alarimer Apr 22 #10

Probably not. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #13

Agree Meowmee Apr 22 #11

I don't really consider the ADL to be a credible source like I used to AZProgressive Apr 22 #15

They have the numbers. You have suspicions. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #17

Not sure about their ablilty to see antisemitism. Eko Apr 22 #18

They've been doing it for over 100 years. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #20

The exact amount of time it takes to see someone do a nazi salute and read the ADL said it was a awkward gesture. Eko Apr 22 #22

A couple of seconds and a tweet vs over 100 years. Beastly Boy Apr 22 #25

Do you think their judgement on that was correct? Eko Apr 22 #27

People change. Eko Apr 22 #28

They are doing exactly that. AloeVera Apr 24 #32

According to your opinionated extreme left source Beastly Boy Apr 24 #53

Further... AloeVera Apr 24 #34

In doing what? Accepting the most authoritative definitionof antisemitism? Beastly Boy Apr 24 #55

Anti-Israeli government is NOT anti-Semitic. Just ask some Israelis who live there. Jit423 Apr 22 #31

Not approving of the actions and policies SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #33

It is not, and clearly, it did not figure into ADL report in any way. Beastly Boy Apr 24 #36

Having seen several interviews SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #37

Having seen the ADL report which is the subject of this thread, Beastly Boy Apr 24 #38

You're free to believe SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #40

Ditto. Regardless of the conclusive statistics included in the ADL report. Beastly Boy Apr 24 #41

Again SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #43

Again, my belief or yours has no bearing on the math in the ADL report. Beastly Boy Apr 24 #44

Whatever you say SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #45

I say it doesn't matter what I say. Beastly Boy Apr 24 #46

I'm just saying SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #47

Totally unrelated to this thread then, right? Beastly Boy Apr 24 #48

You don't need anyone's SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #50

I still appreciate it, especially as it has nothing to do with this thread. Beastly Boy Apr 24 #51

No need to appreciate anything SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #52

I understand this, but I can't help it. It's not every day that I am reminded, for no particular reason, Beastly Boy Apr 24 #54

Good SocialDemocrat61 Apr 24 #56

A lot of defending antisemitism in this thread Mountainguy Apr 24 #39

Disappointing but no longer surprising. DavidDvorkin Apr 24 #49

Don't worry- Trump will put an end to anti-semitism Redleg Apr 24 #57

I worry. Beastly Boy Apr 24 #58

Well, there is the historical fact of anti-Semitism Redleg Apr 28 #63