Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The Way Forward

In reply to the discussion: Advice from James Carville [View all]

markpkessinger

(8,809 posts)
23. Carville loves to hear himself talk . . .
Fri May 9, 2025, 07:01 PM
May 9

. . . and yes, he was part of Bill Clinton's successful campaigns 30 years ago. But it isn't 1992 or 1996 anymore, and this is a very different country from what it was back then.

What's more, one could argue -- and indeed I have argued -- that while Carville's strategy may have worked in securing presidency for Bill Clinton, the party paid a huge, long-term price for it. Carville was among those who pushed Clinton to effectively begin dismantling the social safety net (welfare "reform," anyone?), with Clinton proclaiming publicly that "The era of big government is over!" The Clinton presidency was when the party abandoned the working class, and many working class voters never forgot that.

I don't think Carville has anything to offer in the present moment. I wish he'd just get lost in the Louisiana swamps!

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Advice from James Carville [View all] anamnua Apr 2025 OP
Sorry, James, that's bullshit. Ocelot II Apr 2025 #1
No way. Diamond_Dog Apr 2025 #2
Jesus fucking CHRIST!!! That may be one of the stupidest FoxNewsSucks Apr 2025 #3
You were relevant in the last millenium, jimmy. Now just shut up and niyad Apr 2025 #4
His approval's at 43 now and we can't wait much longer. ms liberty Apr 2025 #5
Schumer ILikePie92 Apr 2025 #6
Great minds. CrispyQ May 10 #30
Thank you! ILikePie92 May 10 #31
wrong - on at least a couple different levels stopdiggin Apr 2025 #7
Asinine. Scrivener7 Apr 2025 #8
Proves he is absolutely clueless about where we are Phoenix61 Apr 2025 #9
easy for a person of means to say Skittles Apr 2025 #10
That is a great point Bettie May 10 #32
I know some wealthy folk Skittles May 10 #33
Wholly Disagree MayReasonRule Apr 2025 #11
We don't need your advice, Carville. Paladin Apr 2025 #12
Is he a hard drinker? If so, his brain might be soaked with alcohol so long it's not working right. CTyankee Apr 2025 #13
Of course he would say this. What a coward. AllyCat Apr 2025 #14
I can't say that I have a more politically suitable action plan to counter Carville mdmc Apr 2025 #15
What he is saying imo, is the Democratic Party does not need to stake out a policy platform. Passages Apr 2025 #16
I can see where Carville is coming from. anamnua Apr 2025 #17
Safe on the sidelines, the former player stands... delisen Apr 2025 #18
part of Democracy is sometimes the majority makes a bad move cadoman Apr 2025 #19
i think the gop has a limit as well before they pounce.. samnsara Apr 2025 #20
Approval is already below 45%, 41-43 in the best polls, and disapproval over 55%. lees1975 Apr 2025 #21
It's time for Democrats to embark on the most daring political maneuver in the history of our party... Old Testament Libera Apr 2025 #22
Carville loves to hear himself talk . . . markpkessinger May 9 #23
I stopped listening to Carville some time ago. Paladin May 10 #24
Before people dismiss James Carville anamnua May 10 #25
If you read between the lines of that, he's really saying the best thing would be to Scrivener7 May 10 #26
Carville is a relic from another time. NoMoreRepugs May 10 #27
Carville should take his own advice BoRaGard May 10 #28
Nonsense. mahina May 10 #29
My advice to James Carville milestogo May 23 #34
Anybody else in favor of retiring this old Carville thread? Paladin May 23 #35
Latest Discussions»The Way Forward»Advice from James Carvill...»Reply #23