Feminism and Diversity
In reply to the discussion: Intersectionality in Movies: The Help [View all]Catherina
(35,568 posts)and I'm taking you up on your invitation and jumping in but I'm no more qualified than anyone else in this thread.
I haven't seen the movie but I know enough people like Stockett and everything I read up on it only makes me hate it.
Do you guys remember Hogan's Heroes? I hated that as a kid. Later I hated it even more because only Hollywood would be offensive enough to make a comedy pretending it was FUN to be in a German prisoner of war camp during World War II.
This is what I know I'm going to hate about The Help. It romanticizes, and makes funny, a very cruel part of our history and current social fabric. Nothing's changed in places like Mississipi. Black women still slave away raising White women's children and doing all the chores.
She even thinks that up in heaven
Her class lies late and snores
While poor black cherubs rise at seven
To do celestial chores.
I feel the same way about The Help as I did about Hogan's heroes and Gone With The Wind. At least Margaret Mitchell told the story through her eyes so I can't fault her for writing from her perspective. But for a White woman to write from the perspective of her Black maid, really? What the f* do you know about your Black maid? And to romanticize it as if White women overseeing this did all they could to help and domestic servitude and racial exploitation was all one big sisterhood. Omagod, that's simply too much.
I was already infuriated before I knew anything about the uglier aspects of the author and her book. Triple my disgust now.
Abilene Cooper, a maid who used to work for Stocketts brother, has criticized the author for stealing her life story without her knowledge and sued her for $75,000 in damages. Cooper also criticized her for comparing the characters skin color to a cockroach.(12) A Hinds County Mississippi judge threw the case out of court, citing the statute of limitations.
...
you used the womans NAME, and you STILL deny stealing her story?
What a thieving little snot!
Heres another article on that note. A quote:
Its funny. In the book, The Help, Skeeterthe character based on phony anti-racism crusader Stockettgives a significant portion of her book advance to the Black maid named Aibileen (which is pronounced the same way Ablene pronounces hers). In real life, Stockett gave Ablene nothing as she continues to make money off of her.
...
But Kathryn Stockett expressly refused Coopers request and right to privacy, and ripped off her name and destroyed her reputation. The movie is being heavily marketed to the Black community and to liberal White women, none of whom know the real story here about the dissing of Ablene Cooper. The New York Times even referred to The Help as a history lesson. PUH-LEEZE. Some real history is missing, like what Kathryn Stockett did."
http://www.theloosh.com/blog/archives/5725
Abilenes lawyer, Edward Sanders, says: Its not about money for Abilene. Its about hypocrisy. The Helps big appeal is to white people. It makes them feel good because its about a white woman who reaches across the racial divide to help poor black servants.
Well, let me tell you, it hasnt done anything to help Abilene. She feels Stockett is just one more white woman who has exploited an African-American.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2033369/Her-family-hired-maid-12-years-stole-life-Disney-movie.html
This sums it up brilliantly. The whole rant is brilliant. I wish I could post the whole thing. Since we can't, read the rest at the link.
Anybody who told you to read this book, or see this movie they obviously dont know a damn thing about history, and they certainly didnt think critically when they indulged in this shit either.
Question anybody who recommended this like a good thing. Its really offensive, when you consider the implications.
A big, warm girlfriend of a book about female love that transcends race and class. The Times
Are you fucking kidding me? A big warm girlfriend of a book? Oh yeah, because black housemaids were our girlfriends. Right.
What a crock of shit.
http://www.theloosh.com/blog/archives/5725
Yep. Shit pie.
Not Pretty Women.
Shitty Women
I changed my mind. I want to see this now in an angry way.
Keep those comments coming. This is good stuff.
Edit history
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):