Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
2016 Postmortem
Showing Original Post only (View all)media narrative that Dems lost 'working class whites' is BS. the split was the ol' rural vs urban [View all]
I kept hearing M$M talking heads saying that the Dems lost the working class whites - Hillary's fault - but the split was the same old rural vs urban voters. It's the same old story we've seen for decades. Rural people swallow GOP Bullshit, Hillary demonization and xenophobia, while urban voters are sophisticated enough to laugh at GOP propaganda. IT's been this way for decades .. as long as I can remember.
How the Election Revealed the Divide Between City and Country
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/11/clinton-trump-city-country-divide/507902/
Trumps victory was an empire-strikes-back moment for all the places and voters that feel left behind in an increasingly diverse, post-industrial, and urbanized America. Squeezing bigger margins from smaller places, Trump overcame a tide of resistance in the largest metropolitan areas that allowed Clinton to carry the national popular vote, but not the decisive Electoral College.
This election thus carved a divide between cities and non-metropolitan areas as stark as American politics has produced since the years just before and after 1920. That year marked a turning point: It was the first time the Census recorded that more people lived in urban than non-urban areas. That tangible sense of shifting influence triggered a series of political and social conflicts between big cities teeming with immigrants, many of them Catholic, and small towns and rural communities that remained far more homogeneously, white, native-born, and Protestant.
This year, Hillary Clinton pushed that model just past the breaking point. Pending final results, she now leads in 88 of the nations 100 largest counties (including D.C.). Suffering a slight decline in African American support, Clinton did not quite match Obamas vote margins in some crucial metropolitan areas, particularly Detroit, Milwaukee, and Philadelphia.
But overall, she delivered a dominant performance in most urban centers and many affluent white-collar suburbs. She held Trump to less than one-fourth of the vote in such mega-counties as Manhattan, Cook (Chicago), and Los Angeles; expanded on Obamas margins in growing Sunbelt cities such as Miami, Charlotte, and Houston; and utterly routed Trump in thriving new economy centers like Austin, Silicon Valley, and Seattle. At latest tally, Clinton won the nations 100 largest counties by fully 12.6 million votesan historic lead certain to widen with many more West Coast ballots yet to count.
Of the Country's 100 Largest Counties, These 25 Provided the Greatest Democratic Margin of Victory (please go to link to see chart of largest counties vote split between Clinton and Putin's Pet (it's a In-line frame which references some proprietary software that builds a chart using data from a proprietary data-base) not a picture.]-Bill USA)
(more)
18 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

media narrative that Dems lost 'working class whites' is BS. the split was the ol' rural vs urban [View all]
Bill USA
Dec 2016
OP
my freinds & relatives who live in rural areas would be offended by your characterization of rural
Bill USA
Dec 2016
#3
your implying that my comnt 3 was NOT honest is typical RW argument by invective & implied moral
Bill USA
Dec 2016
#8
Go ahead and completely ignore the point since it's always a suffering competition
NoGoodNamesLeft
Dec 2016
#6
I couldn't find an email for Brownstein but he has a twitter account..url provided
Bill USA
Dec 2016
#14
I never saw your self deleted and probably amusingly adolescent remark. So Sorrrrrryyyy...LOL
Bill USA
Jan 2017
#18
Lots of black folk live in rural areas, too - where do they fit in to this scenario?
EffieBlack
Dec 2016
#10