Gun Control & RKBA

Lokilooney

(322 posts)

48. The legal right to possess is the only issue

Reply to PoindexterOglethorpe (Reply #45)

Thu Jun 8, 2017, 04:33 AM

Jun 2017

Let me quote a what you said "and the dad should be charged as an accessory" This assumes you recognize US law, as citizens can be charged for breaking it, I agree. In the quote you focused on the gifter stating that they should be legally culpable under US law, except under current US law he was fully compliant in gifting a legal item to one who is legally allowed to be gifted said legal to posess item, under US law he is not culpable.

Cannot edit, recommend, or reply in locked discussions

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

53 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

This message was self-deleted by its author [View all] left-of-center2012 Jun 2017 OP

No charges? Cracklin Charlie Jun 2017 #1

Imagine if they had cannabis on them SHRED Jun 2017 #8

Is "playing" listed on the police report Lokilooney Jun 2017 #39

I grew up in rural PA left-of-center2012 Jun 2017 #2

Um Lokilooney Jun 2017 #41

Wow...the perfect graduation gift, right? Freedomofspeech Jun 2017 #3

Thanks, NRA! You just destroyed some more lives. 50 Shades Of Blue Jun 2017 #4

To be fair... ADX Jun 2017 #6

No, the NRA has fetishized guns. sfwriter Jun 2017 #11

Do tell. Straw Man Jun 2017 #18

"(Y)ou feel that this is the NRA's fault." 'NRA' is a magical incantation for certain people... friendly_iconoclast Jun 2017 #22

One of my favorite historians. sfwriter Jun 2017 #27

I did. sfwriter Jun 2017 #26

And? Straw Man Jun 2017 #33

Brilliant. This is the kind of "logic" that put 45 in the WH. pablo_marmol Jun 2017 #35

The teen violated all 3 safety rules the NRA teaches. Kaleva Jun 2017 #31

He absolutely should be charged. PoindexterOglethorpe Jun 2017 #5

As far as the dad being charged as an accessory Lokilooney Jun 2017 #42

Trying to equate a bottle of Scotch with a gun just doesn't work. PoindexterOglethorpe Jun 2017 #43

If Lokilooney Jun 2017 #44

No. Your equivalence is not perfect. PoindexterOglethorpe Jun 2017 #45

The legal right to possess is the only issue Lokilooney Jun 2017 #48

"Guns are intended to kill...Alcohol is not intended to kill. " EX500rider Jun 2017 #50

of course he shouldnt be charged..hes just a kid who's girlfriend just died... samnsara Jun 2017 #7

If it can be proven that he was actually playing with the gun when it discharged... ADX Jun 2017 #9

Bingo. PoindexterOglethorpe Jun 2017 #46

If he was the captain of a boat and he was "playing" before it crashed, should he be charged? Doodley Jun 2017 #10

This Comatose Sphagetti Jun 2017 #16

He showed complete disregard for the life and safety of another Kaleva Jun 2017 #32

I think it depends on the circumstances (just as with child-in-a-hot-car, and other petronius Jun 2017 #17

Bull SoCalMusicLover Jun 2017 #29

Sad story. So much fail. LOL Lib Jun 2017 #12

Shall we compare this to the cops who deliberately shoot people? PoindexterOglethorpe Jun 2017 #47

I don't know where to begin. LOL Lib Jun 2017 #49

Cops ... left-of-center2012 Jun 2017 #13

No mention of "playing with gun" in this local news account. LOL Lib Jun 2017 #14

Did you read the headline of your link? left-of-center2012 Jun 2017 #15

That description does not bear out in the actual account. LOL Lib Jun 2017 #19

Some reports say he was playing with the gun, some omit it left-of-center2012 Jun 2017 #20

Sarah Brady was a 'straw-man purchaser' by your standards: friendly_iconoclast Jun 2017 #21

Sorry I think I bungled the terminology too. LOL Lib Jun 2017 #23

I recieved my first real firearm. a 22cal RF Remington bolt action rifle oneshooter Jun 2017 #24

I totally understand. LOL Lib Jun 2017 #25

I'd say that is true of an heirloom, not a gun. sfwriter Jun 2017 #28

My dad bought me a bolt action Remington rifle as well. (1st gun) pablo_marmol Jun 2017 #30

I use this rifle as a first "real gun". oneshooter Jun 2017 #36

Sweetness! pablo_marmol Jun 2017 #37

The bolt action and lever action were built oneshooter Jun 2017 #38

Nice......thanks again. NT pablo_marmol Jun 2017 #40

Teen NEGLIGENTLY Kills 19-Yr.-Old Girlfriend............. pablo_marmol Jun 2017 #34

This part: Ilsa Jun 2017 #51

Was It Really An Accident? erpowers Jun 2017 #52

How does that happen we had a similar incident.... Historic NY Jun 2017 #53