Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Music Appreciation
In reply to the discussion: Rave review from The Times (UK) about the first concert of the Oasis reunion tour, tonight + VIDEOS of all 23 songs [View all]highplainsdem
(57,479 posts)24. The Independent: In Cardiff, Oasis deliver the rock reunion to end them all *****
https://www.the-independent.com/arts-entertainment/music/reviews/oasis-review-cardiff-liam-noel-gallagher-setlist-songs-b2781709.html
And the review concludes, "To a reviewer who saw Oasis both at Knebworth and on many a post-Nineties slogathon, this is the best theyve been since 96. Some might say better."
-snip-
And so, after much fan frenzy and media frothing, finally begins the rock reunion to end them all. And thats no overstatement. Its tough to imagine another non-pop comeback on such a momentous scale that might keep the reunion industry ticking over in years to come. Could The Smiths fill seven Wembley Stadiums overnight? A reunited Pink Floyd? Led Zeppelin, even? And what are the chances of those ever happening?
To fully conceive the significance of the Oasis reunion we must finally crystalise their place in rocknroll history. Throughout the Nineties they cockily aspired to be the biggest British band since The Beatles, and by some measures they were. The Stones, Queen, Zep, U2 and Floyd all had their triumphal eras and several shifted more units, but consider this if all 2 million people who applied for tickets to see Oasis at Knebworth in 1996 had got one, the band would have played 16 nights there.
That was the mark of a true phenomenon; in comparison, punk was but a (extraordinarily influential) flash in the pan. And uniquely its a phenomenon that the bucket hat-wearing hordes of Cardiffs Principality Stadium get to relive authentically on Friday night. Unlike the recent Blur and Pulp reunions, the euphoria involved in watching the Gallagher brothers together onstage after 16 years of virulent animosity is little to do with hearing these songs played live again. Although, over two hours of Oasis hits uninterrupted by solo material is a massive fan rush that has much of this mixed and surprisingly unladdish crowd roaring along like Britpop warriors throughout. Theres not much of the setlist that you couldnt have heard any time in the past 10 years or so performed by one Gallagher or the other. Yes, there is a life-affirming Hollywood ending to the sight of warring brothers united after such a long, vicious and tawdry online soap opera, described by one hysterical backstage newscaster as Shakespearean. But that too is only a third of the Morning Glory story.
The real underlying thrill is of a historical moment fully revived. For all the laddish boorishness that Oasis undoubtedly encapsulated, the Britpop era, for Millennials and Gen Zers alike, is as halcyon as Beatlemania or the summer of love a time of vivid colour, jubilant melody, political stability and affordable flats. And to be a part of this second wind of torrid Oasismania, hyped by effusive press coverage and leading to historic shows such as this one, is as close to actually being there as its possible to get. For this multi-generational crowd, both nostalgia heads and those whove waited a whole lifetime to spend a day in the Gallagherss reflected sunshine, Oasis in Cardiff is their bona fide Shea Stadium 1965. Two million wanted Knebworth 96 tickets; 14 million wanted tickets to this tour. This generations Oasis moment is now.
-snip-
And so, after much fan frenzy and media frothing, finally begins the rock reunion to end them all. And thats no overstatement. Its tough to imagine another non-pop comeback on such a momentous scale that might keep the reunion industry ticking over in years to come. Could The Smiths fill seven Wembley Stadiums overnight? A reunited Pink Floyd? Led Zeppelin, even? And what are the chances of those ever happening?
To fully conceive the significance of the Oasis reunion we must finally crystalise their place in rocknroll history. Throughout the Nineties they cockily aspired to be the biggest British band since The Beatles, and by some measures they were. The Stones, Queen, Zep, U2 and Floyd all had their triumphal eras and several shifted more units, but consider this if all 2 million people who applied for tickets to see Oasis at Knebworth in 1996 had got one, the band would have played 16 nights there.
That was the mark of a true phenomenon; in comparison, punk was but a (extraordinarily influential) flash in the pan. And uniquely its a phenomenon that the bucket hat-wearing hordes of Cardiffs Principality Stadium get to relive authentically on Friday night. Unlike the recent Blur and Pulp reunions, the euphoria involved in watching the Gallagher brothers together onstage after 16 years of virulent animosity is little to do with hearing these songs played live again. Although, over two hours of Oasis hits uninterrupted by solo material is a massive fan rush that has much of this mixed and surprisingly unladdish crowd roaring along like Britpop warriors throughout. Theres not much of the setlist that you couldnt have heard any time in the past 10 years or so performed by one Gallagher or the other. Yes, there is a life-affirming Hollywood ending to the sight of warring brothers united after such a long, vicious and tawdry online soap opera, described by one hysterical backstage newscaster as Shakespearean. But that too is only a third of the Morning Glory story.
The real underlying thrill is of a historical moment fully revived. For all the laddish boorishness that Oasis undoubtedly encapsulated, the Britpop era, for Millennials and Gen Zers alike, is as halcyon as Beatlemania or the summer of love a time of vivid colour, jubilant melody, political stability and affordable flats. And to be a part of this second wind of torrid Oasismania, hyped by effusive press coverage and leading to historic shows such as this one, is as close to actually being there as its possible to get. For this multi-generational crowd, both nostalgia heads and those whove waited a whole lifetime to spend a day in the Gallagherss reflected sunshine, Oasis in Cardiff is their bona fide Shea Stadium 1965. Two million wanted Knebworth 96 tickets; 14 million wanted tickets to this tour. This generations Oasis moment is now.
-snip-
And the review concludes, "To a reviewer who saw Oasis both at Knebworth and on many a post-Nineties slogathon, this is the best theyve been since 96. Some might say better."
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
38 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations

Rave review from The Times (UK) about the first concert of the Oasis reunion tour, tonight + VIDEOS of all 23 songs [View all]
highplainsdem
Jul 4
OP
Live Forever - and at the end showing Liverpool football player Diogo Jota, who died in a car accident yesterday.
highplainsdem
Jul 4
#6
Thanks for the video! And you're very welcome - posting all the songs from the first concert the
highplainsdem
Jul 6
#33
Whew. That's all 23 songs. Out of order, but here's the setlist from The Guardian:
highplainsdem
Jul 4
#23
The Independent: In Cardiff, Oasis deliver the rock reunion to end them all *****
highplainsdem
Jul 4
#24
Well, the political stability was Tories in power for a long time, 1979-1997 (John Major succeeding
highplainsdem
Jul 6
#35
Glad you enjoyed this thread! Yes, we do all need breaks from the political nightmare.
highplainsdem
Jul 5
#27
You're very welcome! I posted all the messages in this thread before yours, sorting through lots of
highplainsdem
Jul 5
#29
Full tour, and they're also recording, so there should be a double album and DVD, and both should be
highplainsdem
Jul 6
#37
Btw, I noticed while looking at the full tour schedule, which you can find here
highplainsdem
Jul 7
#38