Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

malthaussen

(18,398 posts)
42. Hard to say. Most blockbuster WW2 movies are crap, especially if they're American
Fri Jan 2, 2026, 11:20 AM
Friday

Last edited Fri Jan 2, 2026, 01:01 PM - Edit history (1)

Possibilities include:

"A Time to Love and a Time to Die," based on Erich Marie Remarque's novel and featuring a cameo by Remarque
"Western Approaches," a British wartime flick that is a virtual forerunner of Reality TV, as it employs no actors, but just working sailors
"The Way Forward," one of David Niven's propaganda pieces
"The North Star" (aka "Armored Attack" ) because of its chequered propaganda history: it is the story of plucky Ukrainian partisans fighting off the Blitzkrieg in 1941, but after 1945 was edited for Cold War purposes to remind the viewer that those plucky Ukrainians were Commies and thus the evil bad guys after all
"Kelly's Heroes," because it is one of the better anti-war films I've seen
"The Fighting Lady," a docudrama about USS Yorktown (CV-10)
"Stalag 17," because it is just a good POW movie without the kind of bullshit in "The Great Escape."
"In Which We Serve," another British wartime flick about the RN. It juxstaposes scenes aboard ship with scenes on the home front, depicting the challenges faced by the sailors and their families
"Mr Roberts," because it features some great acting by Henry Fonda and Jack Lemmon, to say nothing of Jimmy Cagney and William Powell
"Operation Mad Ball," because it stars Jack Lemmon and is actually hilarious
"Red Ball Express," because it deals with a vital part of the war virtually ignored by film

Honorable mention to "Teahouse of the August Moon," because while it deals with the Occupation of Okinawa and not directly with WW2, it features Marlon Brando playing an Okinawan houseboy, and you can't get funnier than that.

Others may come to mind. I tend towards the relatively obscure and older films, made either during or immediately after the war when memory was still fresh. There are a number already recommended that I am not including in this list.

-- Mal

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Casa Blanca ret5hd Thursday #1
The Great Escape. Easterncedar Thursday #2
Mine too. LoisB Thursday #17
Here are mine: Paladin Thursday #3
I'll play. justaprogressive Thursday #4
don't forget "Das Boot" Shellback Squid Thursday #5
Battle of Britain 4K on the way Omaha Steve Thursday #25
"Das Boot" was the first one that I thought of. Big expensive production of a great story. FadedMullet Friday #36
pink submarines lapfog_1 Thursday #6
;-{) Enemy at the Gates Goonch Thursday #7
I was listening to a hockey game on the radio, maybe a couple years back... Harker Thursday #16
Here: Chasstev365 Thursday #8
Bridge Over the River Kwai. From Here to Eternity. The Great Escape. Stalag 13. Casablanca debm55 Thursday #9
Bridge Over the River Kwai, Casablanca, Stalag 17 we have in common, Deb! Coventina Thursday #33
Uhhhh...Full Metal Jacket is Vietnam Zorro Thursday #10
Full Metal Jacket is Vietnam Shambala Thursday #11
2 dweller Thursday #12
The Great Raid LogDog75 Thursday #13
Great movie! red dog 1 Thursday #23
To Be or Not to Be both versions mucifer Thursday #14
Sound of Music GreatGazoo Thursday #15
In no order, and subject to revision... Harker Thursday #18
No order: Aristus Thursday #19
Add to the others mentioned GP6971 Thursday #20
Dirty Dozen is my favorite Skittles Thursday #21
Five favorites displacedvermoter Thursday #22
Allowing for artistic license, I found The Monuments Men... 3catwoman3 Thursday #24
I just re-watched it the other night red dog 1 Friday #47
12 o'clock high Historic NY Thursday #26
A lot of great movies mentioned. I would add The Thin Red Line. Borogove Thursday #27
My Fav Is Stalag 17. BBbats Thursday #28
I would add Mrs. Miniver Lulu KC Thursday #29
"Mrs. Miniver" was "worth a hundred battleships." Paladin Friday #40
Casablanca. greatauntoftriplets Thursday #30
Let's say the ones i saw with my WWIi vet dad. dem4decades Thursday #31
I got an in person autograph from PT 109 Omaha Steve Thursday #32
Very cool! displacedvermoter Friday #46
Squadron 303 - of course 303squadron Thursday #34
I like all the movies you listed, but Charlie Chapulin Thursday #35
Your two suggestions are great. I almost posted "The Thin Blue Line" so thanks for saving me the embarassment. FadedMullet Friday #37
Thanks for the correction, Charlie, I'll fix that right now. red dog 1 Friday #44
Red Dog - Do you believe all the great suggestions that folks are coming up with? FadedMullet Friday #38
Yeah, most of them are movies I've seen & liked. red dog 1 Friday #43
Cross of Iron Sewa Friday #39
I have always thought PCB66 Friday #41
Hard to say. Most blockbuster WW2 movies are crap, especially if they're American malthaussen Friday #42
12 O'Clock High VGNonly Friday #45
Thinking hard on this one: discntnt_irny_srcsm Yesterday #48
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What are your five favori...»Reply #42