Editorials & Other Articles
Showing Original Post only (View all)David Brooks: "Can We Please Stop Calling These People Populists?" [View all]
I've never been a fan of David Brooks, and he still gets most things wrong. For example, he starts from the premise that our division is between the "educated class" and the "working class" (as if no educated people are in the "working class" ). He then claims cause-effect with education (rather than correlation with poverty) for a range of issues, including health and single parenting. He goes back to the 1960s to 'explain' how "Bobos" or "the creative class" took over the country, with a "stifling progressive orthodoxy!" (You know, the one that stifled the 'conservative' ability to oppress other people and deny civil rights based on their own bigotry.)
Next he says that rare, brave conservative students like himself made it through liberal colleges to save the day! (This was the generation that HATED the Clintons, as the first "1960s" college-grads in Washington.)
However, like a lifelong jerk sitting by his fireside smoking his pipe yet suddenly smelling his farts, Brooks wrote the four paragraphs I chose to quote.
Heres the essence of Trumpism: Its to be blithely unconcerned that people without a college degree die about eight years sooner or that hundreds of thousands of Africans might now die of AIDS but to go into paroxysms of moral panic because of who competes in a high school girls swim meet.
Sure, the upper reaches of the federal work force are generally left or center left, as youd expect from a group that possesses a plenitude of advanced degrees. But they are also mostly nonpolitical patriots who often work 60-hour weeks to keep us safe, to save lives, to make America work. This is a complexity the Trumpists seem incapable of contemplating. They are people who would destroy your home because they dont like your lawn sign.
Im not a fan of populism, but real populism would be better than the right-wing elite nihilists who are running the country now.
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/13/opinion/trump-populism-elites.html
