Latest Breaking News

MayReasonRule

(3,560 posts)

39. So why is this a dangerous case for the WSJ? SCOTUS

Sat Jul 19, 2025, 10:40 AM

Saturday

Thank you for your informed analysis!

I'm working on doing the necessary mental gymnastics to convolute the malice standard in such a way as to moot evidentiary proof of truth as an absolute defense.

I am unable.

What twists and turns might SCOTUS pronounce so as to allow such an abhorrent outcome?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

IbogaProject

43 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Trump sues Murdoch, Dow Jones over WSJ story on Epstein birthday letter: court records [View all] BumRushDaShow Friday OP

Hey, Trump! PJMcK Friday #1

Taco. He'll drop it before any discovery needs to happen. Scrivener7 Friday #2

If he drops it, Murdoch could counter-sue for vexacious litigation. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Friday #7

Not successfully onenote Friday #17

Unless the POS in the WH can show they acted with malice, and knowingly made a false statement with lostincalifornia Friday #3

kelleyanne conjob strikes again??? - n/t lapfog_1 Friday #4

What insane lawyer signed that frivolous pleading under FRCP Rule 11? Tarzanrock Friday #5

Found This Thread On reddit r/law That You Might Appreciate... The Court System Is Now His Protection Racket MayReasonRule Saturday #35

He sues for frivolous reasons all the time. ShazzieB Saturday #40

The new f word. twodogsbarking Friday #6

If you listen carefully you can hear the rattling of attorney's swords. twodogsbarking Friday #8

Discovery should be fun Ritabert Friday #9

Why? What do you think the Journal will be seeking to discover that would be relevant to their defense? onenote Saturday #34

Truth Is Generally Considered An Abolute And Complete Defense Against Defamation Claims MayReasonRule Saturday #37

Actually, the burden in this case is on Trump, not WSJ -- and that's why its a dangerous case for the WSJ onenote Saturday #38

So why is this a dangerous case for the WSJ? SCOTUS MayReasonRule Saturday #39

More dangerous to everyone involved with getting the story published IbogaProject Saturday #42

Hey Rupe! Don't forget to demand Attorneys Fees and costs! no_hypocrisy Friday #10

Do I really have to root for Rupert Murdoch now? ificandream Friday #11

Root for Joe Palazzolo...he's a good reporter Prairie Gates Saturday #25

Trump sues Wall Street Journal's publisher and 2 reporters over Epstein article LetMyPeopleVote Friday #12

Maddow Blog-Following Epstein report, Trump files lawsuit against WSJ, Rupert Murdoch and others LetMyPeopleVote Friday #13

If The President has immunity, he shouldn't be able to file lawsuits on his own behalf. ruet Friday #14

Just do it felon, just do it. republianmushroom Friday #15

id love for teh wsj to subpeona the epstein files during discovery.... moonshinegnomie Friday #16

It wouldn't succeed onenote Friday #18

This will get interesting orangecrush Friday #19

20 years ago he was apparently more literate and articulate. Evidence of diminished capacity? Marcuse Friday #20

Murdoch will 'settle' for million$ pfitz59 Friday #21

News Corps BumRushDaShow Saturday #28

Has E. Jean Carroll been paid yet? tonekat Friday #22

I wonder if trump understands choie Friday #23

He'l deny he wrote the card. He admit he was friends with Epstein prior to 2004. onenote Sunday #43

Analysis from MSNBC's Lisa Rubin with Nicole Wallace pat_k Saturday #24

"seize back the narrative"... IthinkThereforeIAM Saturday #29

Souther District of Florida johnnyfins Saturday #26

My first thought when I seen the location of the filing... IthinkThereforeIAM Saturday #30

It's my understanding that there are only two absolute defenses in law and they concern libel and slander. MIButterfly Saturday #27

Good point... IthinkThereforeIAM Saturday #31

A country to run? lonely bird Saturday #36

I'm... myohmy2 Saturday #32

Can't wait for discovery dlk Saturday #33

What is the discovery phase of a libel suit kkmarie Saturday #41