Deadline Legal Blog-McIver's vindictive prosecution motion loss shows how Comey and James could win theirs [View all]
The claims raised by James Comey and Letitia James are stronger than the ones rejected in the New Jersey congresswomans case on Thursday.
McIverâs vindictive prosecution motion loss shows how Comey and James could win theirs
— Jess (@jessflight12.bsky.social) 2025-11-13T20:01:41Z
https://www.msnbc.com/deadline-white-house/deadline-legal-blog/mciver-vindictive-prosecution-motion-comey-james-trump-rcna243713
Rep. LaMonica McIver, D-N.J., lost her bid to dismiss her criminal charges on the grounds that theyre unconstitutionally vindictive. The ruling against her on Thursday highlights how difficult these motions are for defendants to win, while also showing how James Comey and Letitia James could still win their vindictive prosecution claims in Virginia.
In June, McIver was charged with assaulting federal officers at an immigration facility in Newark, New Jersey, while she was conducting oversight with other Democratic politicians amid the Trump administrations immigration crackdown.
Rejecting McIvers claim of vindictive prosecution, U.S. District Judge Jamel Semper ruled that the congresswoman hadnt shown personal animus by the prosecution, despite statements from interim U.S. Attorney Alina Habba that we could turn New Jersey red and from President Donald Trump that the days of woke are over.
The Biden-appointed judge reasoned that none of those statements are particularized to Defendant herself, and further that they are not specific to this Defendant or responsive to her policy positions on immigration, and are therefore not personalized in a way that the requested relief contemplates.
If we apply that reasoning to Comeys and James cases, we see that the presidents barrage of statements against those defendants has been quite particularized to them. The pending motions to dismiss on vindictive prosecution grounds from both the former FBI director and the New York attorney general lay out Trumps animus toward them in great detail.