Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Wiz Imp

(8,284 posts)
39. You're wrong. I don't know why you insist on arguing this.
Wed Nov 12, 2025, 08:36 PM
Nov 12

The resolution (H. Res. 581) is strictly a procedural mechanism to amend and force the vote on HR 185 which will carry the requirements for the files to be released.

The discharge petition is for H.Res. 581 because it is the resolution that provides the procedural mechanism to bring a bill (H.R. 185) to the House floor for a vote, not the bill itself. A discharge petition is used to force a bill from committee to the full House for consideration. In this case, H.R. 185 is the bill being discharged, but H.Res. 581 is the resolution that will be discharged by the petition. HR 185 will be amended by H Res 581

https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-resolution/581

This resolution provides a special rule for consideration of H.R. 185 and amends that bill to direct the Department of Justice (DOJ) to make publicly available certain records related to Jeffrey Epstein or Ghislaine Maxwell.

Under H.R. 185, as amended by the resolution, DOJ must publicly disclose all unclassified records, documents, communications, and investigative materials in its possession that relate to Epstein or Maxwell. The records include unclassified records referring or relating to Epstein's detention and death; flight logs of aircraft owned or used by Epstein; individuals named in connection with Epstein’s criminal activities, civil settlements, or immunity or plea agreements; immunity deals, sealed settlements, or plea bargains of Epstein or his associates; entities with ties to Epstein’s trafficking or financial networks; and internal Department of Justice communications concerning decisions to investigate or charge Epstein or his associates.

However, under the amended bill, DOJ may withhold or redact portions of records with written justification that such portions contain (1) victims' personally identifiable information; (2) child sexual abuse materials; (3) images of death, physical abuse, or injury; (4) information which would jeopardize an active federal investigation or prosecution; or (5) classified information. DOJ may not withhold or redact records on the basis of embarrassment, reputational harm, or political sensitivity.

Further, within 15 days of completing the required disclosures, DOJ must provide Congress with a report listing all categories of records released and withheld, all redactions made and their legal basis, and all government officials and politically exposed persons named or referenced in the released materials.


H.R. 185, titled the "Responsible Legislating Act," was amended by the language of the separate "Epstein Files Transparency Act" via a procedural resolution (H. Res. 581) to force a vote in the House.
This "Epstein Files Transparency Act" , originally introduced as H.R. 4405, mandates that the Department of Justice (DOJ) publicly release all unclassified records, documents, communications, and investigative materials related to the investigation and prosecution of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.

Ultimately the Discharge petition is forcing a vote on HR 185 which will include the language from HR 4405 (the Epstein Transparency Act). Passage simply moves the bill onto the Senate for consideration. It does not force any action. A resolution can't be used to force action by the DOJ - that can only be done by a bill. In this case HR 185, but it needs passed by both the House and Senate to become law. Passing the House by itself forces the DOJ to do absolutely nothing.

If you read the Politico article I linked to you would know that and you would quit trying to argue otherwise. Wherever you got your impression of how all of this will work is 100% wrong. I've laid it out for you 3 times now. Please don't try to argue it again.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

K&R UTUSN Nov 12 #1
Are they negotiating for a bigger bribe? Irish_Dem Nov 12 #2
Its probably because they realize that there is likely no way the files will be released anyway. n/t demmiblue Nov 12 #6
Or the files have all been re-written to make Trump look like Mother Theresa. Irish_Dem Nov 12 #8
I would love to see an AI picture of that... ananda Nov 12 #32
Or how about this? PJMcK Nov 12 #11
Additionally, Mace has built her entire public persona Bettie Nov 12 #12
I keep posting this reminder GusBob Nov 12 #14
Yes, they're horrible people uponit7771 Nov 12 #20
Good Lord. Principles? Now? nolabear Nov 12 #3
More to do with the prospect of Boebert losing her house seat. BannonsLiver Nov 12 #45
Thanks, blue! Leghorn21 Nov 12 #4
25 Minutes BeerBarrelPolka Nov 12 #5
As long as Mr trump keeps throwing fits over this and keeps it in the news Torchlight Nov 12 #7
Well, you were wrong, MarineCombatEngineer Nov 12 #23
I would imagine that Massie is testing a few other Republicans to sign on karynnj Nov 12 #9
There are reports that as many as 100 Republicans (or more!) could vote YES Wiz Imp Nov 12 #15
This message was self-deleted by its author SSJVegeta Nov 12 #18
Nope. It IS legislation. Wiz Imp Nov 12 #22
This message was self-deleted by its author SSJVegeta Nov 12 #37
You're wrong. I don't know why you insist on arguing this. Wiz Imp Nov 12 #39
This message was self-deleted by its author SSJVegeta Nov 12 #38
There is no indication that the House will do a full investigation of this. Wiz Imp Nov 12 #40
This message was self-deleted by its author SSJVegeta Nov 12 #41
OK. This explains why those files got released today. They came from the Epstein estate, NOT the DOJ Wiz Imp Nov 12 #42
West Wing ketchup bottles are considering throwing themselves against a wall to beat the rush. 11 Bravo Nov 12 #10
They know that the orange turd is becoming weaker and is losing support among magaloons also kimbutgar Nov 12 #13
Rat's abandoning a sinking ship... sop Nov 12 #16
I like this one from Family Guy also: MarineCombatEngineer Nov 12 #21
Can't believe I'm saying this, but GOOD ON Lauren Boebert and Nancy Mace! Fil1957 Nov 12 #17
Trump tells Mikey to expel Mace, MTG or Boebert for mental instability and moral turpitude. Marcuse Nov 12 #19
They can't after it reaches 218 votes, which it just did, according to MeidasTouch. highplainsdem Nov 12 #24
Soooooo. .tomorrow? niyad Nov 12 #25
LOL. MarineCombatEngineer Nov 12 #26
I predict Mikey will announce the vote for the 2nd Tues. of the 13th month. nt MarineCombatEngineer Nov 12 #27
They will eventually cave angrychair Nov 12 #28
It could also be that they are a whole lot younger than the orange turdblossom... llmart Nov 12 #29
Crum has outlived his usefullness to them bucolic_frolic Nov 12 #30
I don't quite know what to make of the section slightlv Nov 12 #31
Today. Scrivener7 Nov 12 #33
du rec. AllaN01Bear Nov 12 #34
As noted, once 218 signatures are achieved, the list is "frozen." But the vote isn't immediate. Here the process: onenote Nov 12 #35
According to Politico, the vote is expected to take pllace the first week of December Wiz Imp Nov 12 #43
Sounds right, but now its being reported that Johnson wants to accelerate the process. onenote Nov 12 #44
We only wish that someone popsdenver Nov 12 #36
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Boebert and Mace claim th...»Reply #39