Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ancianita

(41,458 posts)
22. The felon's legions can't legally get Stone & Parker for one damn thing. First Amendment.
Fri Jul 25, 2025, 01:13 PM
Jul 25

The SCOTUS hasn't overruled first amendment precedents, especially its own preceding unanimous ruling in Hustler v Falwell.

When Flynt published a satirical parody ad in which Jerry Falwell tells of a drunken sexual encounter with his mother, Falwell sues Flynt for libel and emotional distress. Flynt countersues for copyright infringement, because Falwell copied his ad and used it to raise funds for his legal bills.
This case centered on a parody advertisement published in Hustler.
The Court ruled unanimously that public figures cannot recover damages for emotional distress from publications that contain false statements of fact unless those statements are made with "actual malice" (knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth). The decision affirmed the importance of satire and parody as forms of free expression protected by the First Amendment,

And because
a) Matt Stone, creator of the felon's parody scenes, said live in person in front of millions of witnesses: "I'm terribly sorry" without a hint of laughter or smirk, "malice" won''t be provable against THEM in the creative process; and
b) Parker & Stone and producers went over the animated naked scenes for weeks before the episode aired, so no malice provable against their company, either.
If the felon sues, he won't even get certiorari from this SCOTUS.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Smile SuzyandPuffpuff Jul 25 #1
Only a tRump WH would even respond to parody and satire. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Jul 25 #2
Nothing to see here. Move on. usonian Jul 25 #3
Believe that is what Stormy insinuated. republianmushroom Jul 25 #15
Or maybe "very little to see here." calimary Jul 25 #21
😆 Deuxcents Jul 25 #4
Why are bdamomma Jul 25 #5
Trey Parker is joking. The Associated Press uses a clearer headline. Eugene Jul 25 #6
Oops bdamomma Jul 25 #11
I'm sure they said it with big grins on their faces Warpy Jul 25 #7
Magat heads are exploding all over the country. rubbersole Jul 25 #13
It isn't an apology relayerbob Jul 25 #8
Yes bdamomma Jul 25 #44
It keeps it in the public's awareness and news headlines IronLionZion Jul 25 #18
So sorry orangecrush Jul 25 #9
I'm 76, and it made me blush, scream, and laugh so hard we had to rewind is several times!!! Greybnk48 Jul 25 #10
I recorded it to my DVR and then moved it to an external drive kimbutgar Jul 25 #12
Which is absolutely what he is! tonekat Jul 25 #14
Gotta luv these guys! PortTack Jul 25 #16
You know what they say.. Mblaze Jul 25 #17
I can only think popsdenver Jul 25 #19
The People Versus Larry Flynt GardenGnome Jul 25 #20
Bingo popsdenver Jul 25 #24
Synchronicity GardenGnome Jul 25 #29
I remember as a young kid popsdenver Jul 25 #30
I don't know that one GardenGnome Jul 25 #35
That's the one popsdenver Jul 25 #37
No, that's not the same one GardenGnome Jul 25 #40
Well, the Eloi v Morloc part of the story seems to be a group of wealthy idiots view of the world. haele Jul 25 #39
I thought Woody Harrelson deserved an Oscar for his performance in that film. 11 Bravo Jul 25 #27
Definitely popsdenver Jul 25 #31
Odd GardenGnome Jul 25 #36
The felon's legions can't legally get Stone & Parker for one damn thing. First Amendment. ancianita Jul 25 #22
Great synopsis Anc popsdenver Jul 25 #28
Thanks for the history. ancianita Jul 25 #32
My ex wife popsdenver Jul 25 #34
Yeah, he suffers from Diminutive Johnson Trauma BlueSpot Jul 25 #46
Catch is with liable is that it has to be known to be untrue when disseminated IbogaProject Jul 25 #45
You may be misremembering things Jose Garcia Jul 25 #41
The craziest thing about Flint vs Falwell is that they eventually became friends Jose Garcia Jul 25 #38
Reruns are already odins folly Jul 25 #23
...and tonight (Friday) at 11 PM EST, oddly enough. Buns_of_Fire Jul 25 #43
I detect an emperor-no-clothes reference. UTUSN Jul 25 #25
Hey, not everybody can be Conjuay Jul 25 #26
When it seems like nearly everybody has caved EnergizedLib Jul 25 #33
I just watched it! THE BEST EVER!!! some_of_us_are_sane Jul 25 #42
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»'We're terribly sorry': S...»Reply #22