General Discussion

The Butler

(35 posts)

66. Stinky is wrong

Reply to Stinky The Clown (Original post)

Tue May 13, 2025, 09:46 PM

Tuesday

Pete was a HOF'er before he made a bet. Let it go! Baseball now embraces gambling.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

99 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Fuck Pete Rose [View all] Stinky The Clown Tuesday OP

He's dead... so not sure it matters much any more... hlthe2b Tuesday #1

and that exactly why he might get in.....HE'S DEAD. a kennedy Tuesday #16

And now we have gambling advertisements on every game CanonRay Tuesday #2

Rules are rules. Consequences are consequences. He broke the rules. Oopsie Daisy Tuesday #6

Before it became popular... JPK Tuesday #53

The Commish changed the rules. BidenRocks Tuesday #61

LOL! Oopsie Daisy Tuesday #63

He Was Doping ProfessorGAC Yesterday #84

and was reading how young men are losing lotsa money, and getting into extensive debt because of sports a kennedy Tuesday #17

And we have a felon in the White House ... krkaufman Tuesday #20

Yup. It's wall-to-wall. GoCubsGo Tuesday #34

Morally and ethically bankrupt. Wuddles440 Tuesday #55

Agree. Rose deserves to be in the Hall of Fame - one of the greatest ever. n/t iluvtennis Tuesday #60

The HOF already has enough Rose stuff on display. LudwigPastorius Yesterday #80

Can't Agree ProfessorGAC Yesterday #85

I couldn't agree more. MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #62

Judge in context. Stinky The Clown Yesterday #75

Do you mean Reggie Jackson? Sugarcoated Yesterday #81

Shoeless Joe Jackson CanonRay Yesterday #89

NO!! Absolutely not! Mistake! This cheapens and denigrates the MLBHOF. Oopsie Daisy Tuesday #3

Agreed Cirsium Tuesday #23

So Stipulated. Ray Fosse. Tarzanrock Tuesday #4

Signed baseball krkaufman Tuesday #21

Rose spent the last 30 years of his life Mountainguy Yesterday #78

OK, the guy was an asshole. So was Ty Cobb. CanonRay Tuesday #64

Placed bets on his own team as player and manager. Irish_Dem Tuesday #5

The bookies KNEW when he WASN'T betting Captain Zero Tuesday #7

Yes he was not betting against his own team. Irish_Dem Tuesday #9

Very good point. Littlered Tuesday #24

Shohei Ohtani is still allowed to play because he found a fall guy. Cuthbert Allgood Tuesday #8

Enshittification Ponietz Tuesday #10

If he gets voted in, that's baseball. cachukis Tuesday #11

Just because the commissioner says he's eligible doesn't mean he's inducted jmowreader Tuesday #12

He also raped at least one kid, so. WhiskeyGrinder Tuesday #13

He did? MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #15

. WhiskeyGrinder Tuesday #19

You're correct AZProgressive Tuesday #43

No question Cirsium Tuesday #22

But was he convicted in a court of law of statutory rape? MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #25

"Maybe or maybe not it happened" lmaooooo c'mon man WhiskeyGrinder Tuesday #26

He says it happened Cirsium Tuesday #32

Ok, if that's true, then provide the link proving he said that. MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #42

Not Surprised Gimpyknee Tuesday #50

Thank you for your service, and I have the highest respect for Navy Corpsman, MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #56

Can't we all just get along? Redleg Yesterday #83

I did Cirsium Tuesday #51

That is a unreliable standard AZProgressive Tuesday #47

IT absolutely happened. Rose admitted to it. Wiz Imp Tuesday #48

Has *rump? MorbidButterflyTat Yesterday #76

We don't think he deserves praise/awards either still-prayin4rain Yesterday #95

I admit I had no idea dsc 21 hrs ago #99

Who fucking cares? MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #14

It obviously does matter Cirsium Tuesday #33

And you would be wrong, I commented because I felt like commenting. MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #39

What if I told you the Mierda47 forced MLB to reinstate him? n/t aggiesal Tuesday #44

Again, I MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #45

But that's what happened. Mierda47 put pressure on MLB ... aggiesal Tuesday #49

One more time in case you didn't get it, MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #52

OK Cirsium Tuesday #54

Good, we understand each other. MarineCombatEngineer Tuesday #57

Did hear tRump is gonna be ecstatic.......he's been pushing for this for, for ever. a kennedy Tuesday #18

Agreed LetMyPeopleVote Tuesday #27

I'll be surprised if he doesn't go in on the next vote. BlueTsunami2018 Tuesday #29

He wasn't well-respected by players and writers, so they may not vote him in. TheRickles Tuesday #35

Its the Baseball Writers' Association that votes. maxsolomon Tuesday #31

He's not eligible for induction through the regular voting process Wiz Imp Tuesday #38

Agreed. I always despised him. BlueTsunami2018 Tuesday #28

Total anus, Ty Cobb class. Marcuse Tuesday #65

I don't have much of an opinion about him personally he probably was an asshole Walleye Tuesday #30

Seems to me, some crimes and criminals are B.See Tuesday #36

This is in response to Trump AverageOldGuy Tuesday #37

I care very little about professional baseball. TNNurse Tuesday #40

This is my 10,000 posting. Being an avid baseball fan (see my avatar), I'm responding to a baseball posting ... aggiesal Tuesday #41

I don't think Pete Rose Mountainguy Yesterday #79

I'm pretty sure stress can causes it. ... aggiesal Yesterday #82

Is Paul here? Mountainguy Yesterday #97

I watch my Tampa Rays on the FanDuel channel. flvegan Tuesday #46

Just a guess.... Gimpyknee Tuesday #58

He's not exactly going to appear at the ceremony if elected to HoF lol... WarGamer Tuesday #59

Stinky is wrong The Butler Tuesday #66

He broke the cardinal rule of baseball and lied about it. Gimpyknee Tuesday #68

Stinky's right. Fuck Pete Rose Stinky The Clown 21 hrs ago #98

K & R. Xavier Breath Tuesday #67

As Jesus said, 'May the first man here without sin throw the first stone.' Jacson6 Tuesday #69

And... Gimpyknee Tuesday #70

No, we settled our dispute a couple of days later. Jacson6 Tuesday #71

I'm just here to say I find baseball.... Xolodno Tuesday #72

About as exciting as watching golf Emile Yesterday #87

This message was self-deleted by its author Tribetime Tuesday #73

Is this the sign of the End Times? valleyrogue Tuesday #74

It's pretty interesting how the Holy Spirit comes to Republican Bible Thumpers ... Tarzanrock Yesterday #77

Since when has baseball been a clean sport? Emile Yesterday #86

Should George Brett be removed from the Hall of Fame? Emile Yesterday #88

Pine tar wasn't in their rules as a death penalty offense Renew Deal Yesterday #90

Rule was broken. Remove him too. Emile Yesterday #91

That's not the way they wrote their rules Renew Deal Yesterday #92

Death penalty rules. Do you have the list of death penalty rules? Emile Yesterday #93

Found them Renew Deal Yesterday #96

... BannonsLiver Yesterday #94