Labor News & Commentary April 10 unions sue to block Trump executive order targeting collective bargaining agreements

https://onlabor.org/april-10-2025/

By Luke Hinrichs

Luke Hinrichs is a student at Harvard Law School.

In today’s news and commentaries, Chief Justice Roberts pauses reinstatement of NLRB Chairwoman Gwynne Wilcox and MSBP Chairwoman Cathy Harris, former EEOC Commissioner Jocelyn Samuels sues Trump alleging unlawful firing, and unions sue to block Trump executive order targeting collective bargaining agreements at federal agencies that have national security missions.

Chief Justice John Roberts issued an administrative stay to temporarily pause en banc D.C. Circuit’s order that would have reinstated National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) Chairwoman Gwynne A. Wilcox and Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) Chairwoman Cathy A. Harris while a panel of the D.C. Circuit court determines the legality of Trump’s firings. The case tests the applicability of longstanding precedent in Humphrey’s Executor v. U.S., and the president’s authority to discharge top officials at certain independent agencies without cause. Trump’s emergency application for the stay also requested that the Supreme Court treat the filing as a petition for certiorari to consider the matter on the merits instead of waiting for an appeal of the D.C. Circuit forthcoming decision. The fired officials are asked to respond to the request by April 15. The administrative stay leaves both the MSPB and the NLRB without a quorum to function.

Former Equal Employment Opportunity Commissioner Jocelyn Samuels sued the Trump administration in D.C. federal court, claiming that her firing in January was unlawful and in violation Title VII of the Civil Rights Act since she was removed without just cause prior to her Senate-confirmed term expiration. Samuels was removed from her position the same day that Trump fired EEOC Chair Charlotte Burrows and General Counsel Karla Gilbride. The firings left the Commission with no quorum to act.

Six unions filed for a temporary restraining order with a federal district court of California to block Trump’s “Exclusions from Federal Labor-Management Programs” Executive Order pending further litigation. The executive order would eliminate the collective bargaining rights for hundreds of thousands of federal employees at more than a dozen federal agencies by expanding an existing exception from collective bargaining for workers with duties affecting national security. According to the unions’ filing, the order affects about 75% of federal workers currently represented by unions. The unions involved include the American Federation of Government Employees, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the National Nurses Organizing Committee/National Nurses United, the Service Employees International Union, the National Association of Government Employees, and the National Federation of Federal Employees.