Democrats Didn't Cave. They Saved People from Needless Suffering.
Robert S. McElvaine
What, WE worry about the people suffering?
My initial reaction to the reports that a sufficient number of Democratic senators had caved to the Republicans to bring an end to the government shutdown was, Not again! What the fuck is wrong with them?
Upon further reflection, I see it a little differently. The fact that the Trump Administration has made it clear that it has no problem with starving Americans, causing them to be unable to have health insurance, and preventing them from joining their families for Thanksgiving, while King Donald I parties like its 1928, builds his own Versailles on the grounds of the Peoples House, has goons attacking Americans on our own streets, seeks to prevent millions from voting, and collects tribute from billionaires and foreign leaders, made what to do at this point a tough decision.
Whichever side of this Democratic decision you think was right, the first imperative is to assure that we do not blame the other group on the Democratic side for what is a wholly-owned Republican catastrophe. Every minute spent attacking other Democrats is, at best, a wasted opportunity and, at worst, shields Republicans from the blame they deserve.
I do, though, strongly (as Trump likes to say to hide his weakness) agree with Jay Kuo that if a group of Democrats was going to move to end the shutdown, they needed to lead with messaging, not explain themselves after the fact. The public needed to hear much more about how the Republicans refused to deal.
https://www.lincolnsquare.media/p/democrats-didnt-cave-they-saved-people
Fiendish Thingy
(21,558 posts)Even though SNAP is funded through September, new regulations in the OBBB will require most folks to reapply for eligibility, and then have to meet onerous proof-of-employment requirements in order to sustain benefits.
But the cowardly eight enabled another kind of suffering, the loss of healthcare/skyrocketing premiums, that will begin in January, with no end in sight.
The lesser of two evils is still evil.
We should stand against evil.
SaydiTom
(6 posts)did not stop that from happening. (e.g. "Everyone must re-apply for SNAP benefits"; "the SNAP program is full of fraud and we're going to root it out"; "there will be no vote on ACA extension without concessions on abortion rights".)
But I agree the media was fully focused on the Democrats' role in the shutdown, and trying every spin to blame them, instead of holding Republicans or Trump responsible in any way. We need to learn the media will never carry our water. It's our turn to "catapult the "propaganda (our messaging)" over the heads of the media and directly to the people. And that's something Dems should relish doing, because we are on the right side of any argument involving trump.