Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Wicked Blue

(8,149 posts)
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 09:58 AM Jun 26

Senate Parliamentarian Deals Huge Blow To Critical Part Of GOP's 'Big Beautiful Bill'

Source: HuffPost

WASHINGTON – The Senate parliamentarian said that major Medicaid cuts in the GOP’s massive tax and spending package violate the chamber’s rules — a big setback for President Donald Trump’s legislative agenda.

Republicans already were having big disagreements over the Medicaid provisions of their so-called Big Beautiful Bill, and the parliamentarian’s ruling threatens to blow up the legislation altogether.

The core of the bill is a package of tax cuts costing around $4 trillion financed in part by about $1 trillion in spending cuts to Medicaid and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program. The Senate’s in-house rules expert has now thrown the cuts into doubt, potentially making it even harder for Republicans to claim the legislation is fiscally responsible.

The rulings announced Thursday morning by Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.), who has led Democrats’ challenges to the bill’s provisions in closed-door meetings with the parliamentarian, concern cuts to Medicaid funding for states that cover noncitizens, a ban on gender-affirming care in the Children’s Health Insurance Program and a limit on “provider taxes” states use to finance their portion of Medicaid spending.

Read more: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/parliamentarian-medicaid-cuts-provider-tax_n_685d4229e4b0f78c573833aa

21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Senate Parliamentarian Deals Huge Blow To Critical Part Of GOP's 'Big Beautiful Bill' (Original Post) Wicked Blue Jun 26 OP
THE SENATE PARLIAMENTARIAN has struck a whole bunch of critical health provisions from the reconciliation bill. LetMyPeopleVote Jun 26 #1
Ruh-roh CousinIT Jun 26 #2
This makes my day! NJCher Jun 26 #3
this smells like azureblue Jun 26 #4
That what I thought too. "Gee, Donald, the bad parliamentarian won't let us do it". FadedMullet Jun 26 #8
AKA The Raw Deal. yorkster Jun 26 #5
The Raw Deal is the best name for it. mdbl Jun 26 #6
I call it the Big Bullshit Bill. CaptainTruth Jun 26 #10
Rethugs will override the Parliamentarian at some point, Bayard Jun 26 #7
Thune says he won't overrule Senate referee on Medicaid cuts LetMyPeopleVote Jun 26 #9
He's said that now, but Trump hasn't weighed in yet. Calista241 Jun 26 #20
Perhaps, but Thune probably realizes... regnaD kciN Jun 26 #21
How TF is it fiscally responsible to add FOUR TRILLION $ to the credit card? OMGWTF Jun 26 #11
Hope they don't fire the parliamentarian. It's happened before. Fil1957 Jun 26 #12
Thune has already said they will abide by the Parliamentarian's rulings. Wiz Imp Jun 26 #14
He might actually do that. That way the repubs have an off-ramp by blaming the parliamentarian, which is fine by me. Fil1957 Jun 26 #17
So the Parliamentarian has eliminated many of the worst parts of the bill. This is definite good news. Wiz Imp Jun 26 #13
Parliamentarian? Don't need no stinkin' parliamentarian. Sneederbunk Jun 26 #15
Parliamentarian also blocked sale of national forest lands: Liberty Belle Jun 26 #16
Overlapping problems create uncertainty over the future of the Republican megabill LetMyPeopleVote Jun 26 #18
Will they be fired? Buttoneer Jun 26 #19

LetMyPeopleVote

(166,964 posts)
1. THE SENATE PARLIAMENTARIAN has struck a whole bunch of critical health provisions from the reconciliation bill.
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 10:00 AM
Jun 26

This makes me smile. Here are more provisions that have to be removed from the asshole's big ### bill






trump will need 60 votes in the Senate to get these provision adopted

yorkster

(3,274 posts)
5. AKA The Raw Deal.
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 10:46 AM
Jun 26

Just because that terrible bill has such a ridiculous official name doesn't mean we have to use it.

Bayard

(26,169 posts)
7. Rethugs will override the Parliamentarian at some point,
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 10:59 AM
Jun 26

Because she tells them they are idiots.

LetMyPeopleVote

(166,964 posts)
9. Thune says he won't overrule Senate referee on Medicaid cuts
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 11:25 AM
Jun 26

If Thune over rules the Senate Parliamentarian, then the Byrd rule will effectively be dead.

Thune says he won’t overrule Senate referee on Medicaid cuts
Source: The Hill
share.newsbreak.com/drer38uw

@mterr337 (@mterr337xxx.bsky.social) 2025-06-26T15:14:49.007Z




Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) on Thursday said he will not overrule the parliamentarian after she rejected key Medicaid provisions in the GOP’s tax and spending megabill, dealing a blow to Republicans’ plan to pay for tax cuts in the package.

“No. That would not be a good outcome for getting a bill done,” Thune told reporters at the Capitol.

Senate Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough rejected a plan that would cap states’ ability to collect more federal Medicaid funding via healthcare care provider taxes. The move would have collected hundreds of billions in savings, which Republicans were relying on.

Thune says Republican leaders knew “it was going to be an interesting conversation” with the Senate’s referee about the provision, but believes there are actions members can take to find similar savings.

Calista241

(5,631 posts)
20. He's said that now, but Trump hasn't weighed in yet.
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 06:07 PM
Jun 26

I suspect Trump doesn't give 2 shits what the Senate Parliamentarian says.

regnaD kciN

(27,199 posts)
21. Perhaps, but Thune probably realizes...
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 08:56 PM
Jun 26

…that, if they eliminate the Byrd rule, should Democrats ever gain control of Congress and the White House again, they could ram through all sorts of things (a legislative restoration of Roe, expanding SCOTUS, mandating LGBTQ rights in every state, statehood for D.C., Puerto Rico and Guam) in their own BBB, and only need fifty votes to pass it.

OMGWTF

(4,859 posts)
11. How TF is it fiscally responsible to add FOUR TRILLION $ to the credit card?
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 11:46 AM
Jun 26

I loathe these soulless, greedy mofos more than mere words can express.

Wiz Imp

(6,279 posts)
14. Thune has already said they will abide by the Parliamentarian's rulings.
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 12:02 PM
Jun 26

He's smart enough to know that overruling her or firing her would have significant negative consequences for them in the future. And it's obvious that 90% of the goal of this bill is to cut taxes on the rich, so as long as the bill does that, most will be satisfied.

Fil1957

(153 posts)
17. He might actually do that. That way the repubs have an off-ramp by blaming the parliamentarian, which is fine by me.
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 03:38 PM
Jun 26

Wiz Imp

(6,279 posts)
13. So the Parliamentarian has eliminated many of the worst parts of the bill. This is definite good news.
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 11:57 AM
Jun 26

That actually lets many Republicans off the hook as many of the things various Senators objected to have been eliminated by the Parliamentarian so it makes it easier for them to vote for it. This makes it more likely to pass. Make no mistake, it will be still be a terrible bill but not nearly as awful as they tried to make it.

It still will need to be passed by the house, and I wouldn't count on that happening if they don't restore the increase in the SALT deduction to the levels from the original House bill.

LetMyPeopleVote

(166,964 posts)
18. Overlapping problems create uncertainty over the future of the Republican megabill
Thu Jun 26, 2025, 05:00 PM
Jun 26

Donald Trump has said the GOP is united behind the inaptly named One Big Beautiful Bill Act. The truth for Republicans isn't nearly that simple.

Overlapping problems create uncertainty over the future of the Republican megabill www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddo... via @msnbc

Slapshot1955 (@slapshot19551.bsky.social) 2025-06-26T20:41:04.730Z



https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/overlapping-problems-create-uncertainty-future-republican-megabill-rcna214977

As things stand, Republicans are basically confronting five problems:

1. GOP numbers aren’t adding up: The Congressional Budget Office concluded last week that the House version of the package would add $3.4 trillion to the national debt, and this week, the nonpartisan Joint Committee on Taxation found that proposed Senate changes would add an additional $400 billion to the price tag.

2. The Byrd bath: Because Republicans are relying on the budget reconciliation process, which prevents Democrats from derailing the bill with a filibuster, GOP lawmakers are having to subject the legislation to a complex process — which includes having the Senate parliamentarian remove provisions that run afoul of certain budgetary rules. This process is known as the “Byrd bath,” named after the late Democratic Sen. Bob Byrd of West Virginia.

In recent days, several key measures have already been stricken from the bill, including elements the party was counting on to help GOP numbers add up. This has caused a behind-the-scenes scramble that has not yet been resolved.

On Thursday, the developments for the party managed to get even worse. NBC News reported, "Republicans suffered a blow Thursday after the Senate referee ruled that a series of health care cuts and savings in their sweeping domestic policy bill are ineligible for the party-line path they're using to get around the chamber's 60-vote threshold."

The result leaves GOP leaders with limited choices: They can (a) look for other solutions; (b) try to tweak the legislation and ask the parliamentarian to take another look; or (c) vote to override the parliamentarian, which would be a radical and dramatic move that would risk altering how the institution functions going forward.

3. Far-right House Republicans think the Senate’s approach isn’t conservative enough: As The New York Times reported, “Some conservatives in the House only grudgingly voted for the legislation the first time, arguing that it did not go far enough in cutting spending, including on Medicaid. They agreed to support the package only after securing what they characterized as commitments from their Senate colleagues to enact deeper cuts and fix the measure. Now, those House Republicans regard the bill taking shape in the Senate, which party leaders hope to push through within days, as even worse.”

4. House Republicans from competitive districts think the Senate’s approach is too conservative: As NBC News reported, “On Tuesday, 16 House Republicans — almost all representing competitive districts — sent a letter rebelling against the Senate’s Medicaid cuts. They fretted that those policies would ‘place additional burdens on hospitals,’ among other things.”

5. The entire effort is unpopular. I mean, really unpopular. Republican officials have been working on this for roughly eight months, and talking up how great their plan is, but at least for now, the American mainstream isn't buying what the GOP is selling, which puts added pressure on members worried about their re-election prospects.

Given the scope of the intraparty disagreements, it’s not yet clear how, when or whether Republicans will work out their differences, and given the narrow margins in both chambers, the margin of error for party leaders is small. That said, if recent history is any guide, most, if not all, of the GOP members expressing skepticism about the legislation can be expected to cave after a couple of angry phone calls and tweets from the president.

We are headed to a debt ceiling issue soon which is why trump wants this bill done by July 4. I doubt that this will happen and we may see an emergency extension of the debt ceiling.
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Senate Parliamentarian De...