Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(151,125 posts)
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 07:17 AM Friday

Conservative NYT Columnist David Brooks Calls for 'National Civic Uprising' to Defeat Trumpism

Source: MEDIAite

Apr 17th, 2025, 8:08 pm


Conservative New York Times columnist David Brooks has called for a mass uprising to oppose President Donald Trump, going so far as to quote The Communist Manifesto.

In a blistering piece published on Thursday, Brooks wrote that modern civilization is buttressed by several pillars, including “Constitutions to restrain power, international alliances to promote peace, legal systems to peacefully settle disputes, scientific institutions to cure disease, news outlets to advance public understanding, charitable organizations to ease suffering, businesses to build wealth and spread prosperity, and universities.”

He went on to say that Trump threatens all of these because the president is only interested in the acquisition of power “for its own sake” and is engaged in “a multifront assault to make the earth a playground for ruthless men.”

Noting that Trump has targeted law firms, government agencies, NATO, and global trade, Brooks said these various efforts are part of a singular mission to reverse the “civilizational order.” His solution is a multi-pronged response that is nonetheless united by a common goal:

It’s time for a comprehensive national civic uprising. It’s time for Americans in universities, law, business, nonprofits and the scientific community, and civil servants and beyond to form one coordinated mass movement. Trump is about power. The only way he’s going to be stopped is if he’s confronted by some movement that possesses rival power.


Read more: https://www.mediaite.com/trump/conservative-nyt-columnist-david-brooks-calls-for-national-civic-uprising-to-defeat-trumpism-complete-with-mass-rallies-strikes/



Full headline: Conservative NYT Columnist David Brooks Calls for ‘National Civic Uprising’ to Defeat Trumpism – Complete With ‘Mass Rallies, Strikes’

27 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Conservative NYT Columnist David Brooks Calls for 'National Civic Uprising' to Defeat Trumpism (Original Post) BumRushDaShow Friday OP
Peaceful protests across the country............... Lovie777 Friday #1
There is. Bohunk68 Friday #9
It's a great column, a must read. sop Friday #2
Next week he will be praising the moron for something he did. Raftergirl Friday #10
It wouldn't surprise me one bit. Paladin Friday #13
David Brooks has long been a never-Trumper. From a 2016 column of his: femmedem Friday #22
you know times are changing when Brooks calls for this. nt Javaman Friday #3
That's the truth! 2naSalit Friday #5
Looks like Brooks has been onto him for nearly 10 years (look at date of article). CTyankee Saturday #25
Maybe more people should have voted for the black lady Ray Bruns Friday #4
Uber conservative Rich Lowry has been voicing similar concerns. JohnnyRingo Friday #6
Yup - they are considered "the Establishment" BumRushDaShow Friday #7
The RW loons should take note that a combination of the "RINOS" and the left maks the RW nut jobs a distinct minority. wnylib Friday #23
So big that it scares the sh-t out of his diaper. Historic NY Friday #8
I'm not sure what Brooks means by a 'National Civic Uprising,' but I welcome the suggestion, whatever form it takes. Martin68 Friday #11
Brooks' portfolio must have really taken a hit Fiendish Thingy Friday #12
"He is the hackiest of hacks in journalism" BumRushDaShow Friday #14
Brooks is the Chuck Todd of print media. Nt Fiendish Thingy Friday #16
.... BumRushDaShow Friday #17
Anyone remember the National Security debacle? SayItLoud Friday #15
Adam Kinzinger: "As David Brooks has said, we're approaching civil disobedience and national strikes phase of defending Native Friday #18
This doesn't sound like the David Brooks we all know and hate FakeNoose Friday #19
Brooks being Brooks... relogic Friday #20
Trump's national conservatism is not the traditional American conservatism of Brooks, William Buckley and the past GOP andym Friday #21
I agree with what he says, BUT... AntiFascist Friday #24
Brooks quotes Marx dweller Saturday #26
Did hell just freeze over? thought crime Saturday #27

Bohunk68

(1,378 posts)
9. There is.
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 09:13 AM
Friday

We are even gathering here in our small Upstate NY red neck town. And it will be in Veteran's Park, and many of us veterans will be there. Oooo, I can think of another use of Anchors Aweigh. hmmm.

sop

(13,796 posts)
2. It's a great column, a must read.
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 07:23 AM
Friday

(We cannot afford to attack people like David Brooks for their past political views.)

femmedem

(8,506 posts)
22. David Brooks has long been a never-Trumper. From a 2016 column of his:
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 05:12 PM
Friday

"...Donald Trump is epically unprepared to be president. He has no realistic policies, no advisers, no capacity to learn. His vast narcissism makes him a closed fortress. He doesn’t know what he doesn’t know and he’s uninterested in finding out. He insults the office Abraham Lincoln once occupied by running for it with less preparation than most of us would undertake to buy a sofa.

Trump is perhaps the most dishonest person to run for high office in our lifetimes. All politicians stretch the truth, but Trump has a steady obliviousness to accuracy.

This week, the Politico reporters Daniel Lippman, Darren Samuelsohn and Isaac Arnsdorf fact-checked 4.6 hours of Trump speeches and press conferences. They found more than five dozen untrue statements, or one every five minutes."

Gifted article, no payroll: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/18/opinion/no-not-trump-not-ever.html

JohnnyRingo

(19,851 posts)
6. Uber conservative Rich Lowry has been voicing similar concerns.
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 08:55 AM
Friday

He's the Editor In Chief of The National Review, a major conservative outlet.
For a couple months now he's been pounding the drum of dissent of Trumpism. It's gotten much more direct lately.

This can't be good for Dear Leader, but these columnists are the republican elite. The rednecks with Trump flags on their trucks and billboards in their front yard don't care what they think.

wnylib

(25,238 posts)
23. The RW loons should take note that a combination of the "RINOS" and the left maks the RW nut jobs a distinct minority.
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 05:43 PM
Friday

Historic NY

(38,867 posts)
8. So big that it scares the sh-t out of his diaper.
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 09:10 AM
Friday

too bad a missed opportunity was his big golf event. Imagine if 10000 + people showed up around Doral

Martin68

(25,509 posts)
11. I'm not sure what Brooks means by a 'National Civic Uprising,' but I welcome the suggestion, whatever form it takes.
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 09:47 AM
Friday

This is an excellent list: In a blistering piece published on Thursday, Brooks wrote that modern civilization is buttressed by several pillars, including “Constitutions to restrain power, international alliances to promote peace, legal systems to peacefully settle disputes, scientific institutions to cure disease, news outlets to advance public understanding, charitable organizations to ease suffering, businesses to build wealth and spread prosperity, and universities.”

Fiendish Thingy

(19,098 posts)
12. Brooks' portfolio must have really taken a hit
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 09:56 AM
Friday

For decades, he has been a bland apologist for Republicans and an arrogant scold for Democrats.

He is the hackiest of hacks in journalism.

Now, suddenly, he displays a modicum of pro-democracy passion?

I guess that makes him a broken clock…

BumRushDaShow

(151,125 posts)
14. "He is the hackiest of hacks in journalism"
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 10:18 AM
Friday

... behind Charles Krauthammer, who is no longer here.

Maybe he is changing direction the way Bill Kristol has.

SayItLoud

(1,757 posts)
15. Anyone remember the National Security debacle?
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 10:21 AM
Friday

Just another "headline" that faded away with NO consequences to any of the senior officials involved. The media is only alive for 24-72 hours then on to the next "scandal" , and no one has a solution. We keep thinking "oh he will never get away with that"...and yet he does. Bit by bit eroding everything and profiting by it all.

Native

(7,064 posts)
18. Adam Kinzinger: "As David Brooks has said, we're approaching civil disobedience and national strikes phase of defending
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 10:46 AM
Friday

our nation." Yup, even Kinzinger is in agreement.

FakeNoose

(37,192 posts)
19. This doesn't sound like the David Brooks we all know and hate
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 10:47 AM
Friday

Wow! Did someone hack his computer?

relogic

(164 posts)
20. Brooks being Brooks...
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 11:47 AM
Friday

…the obvious omission of government's practical role in ameliorating some of the US population’s disease and poverty are not supported by his conservative brand. Notice: …” charitable organizations to ease suffering, businesses to build wealth and spread prosperity, and universities.” Sometimes such an inadequate list of “uprising” justifications can be very revealing by what is not offered as viable solutions, Mr. Brooks. Still the predictable defender of predatory, corporate capitalism at its best, eh?

andym

(5,944 posts)
21. Trump's national conservatism is not the traditional American conservatism of Brooks, William Buckley and the past GOP
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 12:15 PM
Friday

Following the Project 2025 roadmap and Trump's own authoritarian streak is leading the US to national conservatism with authoritarian conservatism on the roadmap.

"National conservatism is a nationalist variant of conservatism that concentrates on upholding national and cultural identity, communitarianism and the public role of religion. It shares aspects of traditionalist conservatism and social conservatism, while departing from economic liberalism and libertarianism, as well as taking a more pragmatic approach to regulatory economics and protectionism. It opposes the basic precepts of enlightenment liberalism such as individualism and the universality of human rights, and in America and Europe is majoritarian populist.[ National conservatives usually combine conservatism with nationalist stances, emphasizing cultural conservatism, family values and opposition to illegal immigration or opposition to immigration per se. National conservative parties often have roots in environments with a rural, traditionalist or peripheral basis, contrasting with the more urban support base of liberal conservative parties."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_conservatism

There are many elements of Authoritarian conservatism in Trump's behavior as well.
"Authoritarian conservatism refers to autocratic regimes that portray authority as absolute and unquestionable. Authoritarian conservative movements show strong devotion towards religion, tradition, and culture while also expressing fervent nationalism akin to other far-right nationalist movements."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authoritarian_conservatism

Interesting contrast with fascism which actually opposes authoritarian conservatism from Edmund Fawcett:
"Fascism, to schematize, is a form of totalitarianism. It imposes control on every aspect of the state, society, economy, and cultural life. It works through a single party with an all-embracing ideology commonly under a charismatic leader claiming to speak for the people. Its enemies are pluralism and diversity. Fascism stifles opposition by violence and fear and stabilizes itself by mobilizing popular engagement. Authoritarianism, by contrast, allows independent economic and social bodies, forms of limited representation, and a degree of freedom of religion. Its enemy is democratic participation. It also stifles opposition by violence and fear but stabilizes itself by relying on passive acquiescence in a trade-off of social quiet for loss of political role. The fascist is a nonconservative who takes anti-liberalism to extremes. The right-wing authoritarian is a conservative who takes fear of democracy to extremes."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authoritarian_conservatism

Trump's conservatism has never before achieved major power in the USA and stands against the libertarian strains of conservatism-- with its overarching emphasis on freedom that was previously the focus of the GOP. Much of what is happening is the handiwork of the Heritage Foundation's Project 2025. The MAGA faithful have little understanding that their conservative values have been hijacked-- possibly because the unifying aspect of conservatism is deep respect for traditional authority.

AntiFascist

(13,234 posts)
24. I agree with what he says, BUT...
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 09:09 PM
Friday

directly quoting the Communist Manifesto could only give more fuel to Trump's anti-Communist, pro-Fascist following. Historically, fascism has risen up to counter rising popular support of Marxism and Socialism. This is why titans of industry (the earliest Libertarians) initially supported Hitler.

dweller

(26,437 posts)
26. Brooks quotes Marx
Sat Apr 19, 2025, 01:22 AM
Saturday

… “We have nothing to lose but our chains”.
David Brooks …

say wut?


✌🏻

thought crime

(160 posts)
27. Did hell just freeze over?
Sat Apr 19, 2025, 01:34 AM
Saturday

“We have nothing to lose but our chains”.

Couldn't quite get himself to say "The Workers (or Proletariat) have nothing to lose but their chains".
But close enough. Brooks. You've come a long way, baby!

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Conservative NYT Columnis...