Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(151,125 posts)
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 03:35 PM Apr 16

US senator says El Salvador denied request to meet Kilmar Abrego Garca

Source: The Guardian

Wed 16 Apr 2025 15.17 EDT
Last modified on Wed 16 Apr 2025 15.22 EDT


Maryland’s Democratic senator Chris Van Hollen says the government of El Salvador has denied his request to visit Kilmar Ábrego García, his constituent who was wrongly deported to the Central American country last month. Van Hollen traveled to El Salvador on Wednesday with the intention of meeting Ábrego García at the Terrorism Confinement Center (Cecot), where US authorities have said that the Maryland resident is being held along with others deported at Donald Trump’s orders.

The senator’s visit came days after Trump and El Salvador’s president, Nayib Bukele, refused to take steps to return Ábrego García to the United States, even though the US supreme court last week said the administration must “facilitate” his return. At a press conference in El Salvador, Van Hollen said that he had met with the country’s vice-president, Félix Ulloa, who told him it would not be possible for him to speak with Ábrego García in person or on the phone.

“I asked the vice-president if I could meet with Mr Ábrego García. And he said, well, you need to make earlier provisions to go visit Cecot,” Van Hollen said. “I said, I’m not interested at this moment in taking a tour of Cecot, I just want to meet with Mr Ábrego García. He said he was not able to make that happen.” Van Hollen said he offered to come back next week to meet with Ábrego García, but Ulloa “said he couldn’t promise that either”. The vice-president also said he could not arrange for Ábrego García’s family to speak to him by phone.

When the senator asked if he could do so, Ulloa told him that the US embassy must make that request, Van Hollen said. “We have an unjust situation here. The Trump administration is lying about Ábrego García,” said Van Hollen, who said his constituent had been wrongly named as a member of the MS-13 criminal gang. The Trump administration has admitted that an “administrative error” led to the deportation of Ábrego García to his native country, despite an immigration judge granting him protected status in 2019.

Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/apr/16/kilmar-abrego-garcia-chris-van-hollen

62 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
US senator says El Salvador denied request to meet Kilmar Abrego Garca (Original Post) BumRushDaShow Apr 16 OP
Makes me wonder if Garcia is still alive rurallib Apr 16 #1
I have had the same thoughts. I hate to even admit it Deuxcents Apr 16 #3
trump is a mob boss - mob bosses get rid of evidence, blame it on others rurallib Apr 16 #7
This is sounding like a coverup Mr.Bee Apr 16 #19
The family is asking for proof of life. This looks worse by the day. Eugene Apr 16 #6
That was my first thought. Nt avebury Apr 16 #8
"El Salvador denies senator visit with mistakenly deported man: Van Hollen" Botany Apr 16 #10
That link goes to a page that says "We can't find the page you're looking for." - EDIT ShazzieB Apr 16 #12
Try LiberalArkie Apr 16 #13
"The markodochartaigh Apr 16 #25
Navalny comes to mind. Sneederbunk Apr 16 #20
What does it mean to YOU that Bondi said... dchill Apr 16 #32
there's a reason NJCher Apr 16 #41
Sigh... that's what I'm afraid of. calimary Thursday #52
At this point, I'd be surprised if he is. Karasu Apr 16 #34
Silenced WmChris Apr 16 #37
Mrs. Garcia homegirl Apr 16 #38
I agree she should use the judicial system somehow rurallib Apr 16 #39
El Salvador is doing whatever trump wants BOSSHOG Apr 16 #2
Yep, 6 million for the immigrants, and bluestarone Apr 16 #21
Ironic choice of numbers there.... The Madcap Apr 16 #35
'Zactly right! Chump was on the phone with Bukele, advising how to answer any pushy Dems FakeNoose Apr 16 #33
Two tough guys telling one and all BOSSHOG Apr 16 #36
Non zero chance that he's dead Prairie Gates Apr 16 #4
Agency. We are paying for this detention. /nt bucolic_frolic Apr 16 #5
Roxane Gay: Is Kilmar Abrego Garcia alive? Getting distinct impression he's either dead or disfigured. Dennis Donovan Apr 16 #9
That has been my fear all along, they don't want Americans to either see or hear from him - assuming he's still alive Rhiannon12866 Apr 16 #48
Me as well. Dennis Donovan Thursday #56
I've never been so grateful to be wrong. Rhiannon12866 Friday #58
Me too. I was nearly certain of a different outcome! Dennis Donovan Friday #59
Same here! I was afraid that they refused to make an effort because he was already gone and they knew it Rhiannon12866 Friday #60
Republicans trafficking people. Isn't this one of the things Republicans say they oppose? travelingthrulife Thursday #55
Sen Van Hollen He was kidnapped under the guise of "policy" and thrown into a foreign prison in violation of a federal c riversedge Apr 16 #11
Dumb question that I honestly do not know the answer to because I've never had to ask it before. hamsterjill Apr 16 #14
Over 80% of elected Republicans are keeping him in power. Festivito Apr 16 #16
"what can be done? " BumRushDaShow Apr 16 #22
I fear that, while El Salvador might love the money, there is likely no Mr. Garcia there. BComplex Apr 16 #23
I may be wrong BumRushDaShow Apr 16 #29
I hope you're right about him being alive. And I hope they will eventually get him back to the US. BComplex Thursday #54
I think the key to this is NJCher Apr 16 #27
What pressure point could make Bukele's life miserable? sop Apr 16 #31
I'm ready for some fucking retribution! FirstLight Apr 16 #44
Schumer Falcon101 Apr 16 #45
There is the Red Cross and Amnesty International. markodochartaigh Apr 16 #28
if nothing else NJCher Apr 16 #42
I think that's a great idea. hamsterjill Apr 16 #46
How much taxpayer dollars are we paying to imprison people in El Salvador? And is Garcia even there? ffr Apr 16 #15
Van Hollen said $15Million in the interview. HeartsCanHope Apr 16 #24
KAFKA-esque. elleng Apr 16 #17
Wishful thinking, but eventually these magas will be out on their butts... C Moon Apr 16 #18
it's not wishful thinking NJCher Apr 16 #43
Trump paid Nayib Bukele millions to take them off his hands..... JohnnyRingo Apr 16 #26
He's dead i think. Figarosmom Apr 16 #30
Not in the least surprised...very disappointing, but not surprised. PortTack Apr 16 #40
It's impossible to speak to a dead person and that poor man is dead. HappyLarge Apr 16 #47
Did Bukele Demand Trump Deport Abrego Garcia To His Custody? DallasNE Apr 16 #49
How is this not Nazism? William Gustafson Apr 16 #50
What is the saying.. Lokee11 Thursday #53
And he reported in on Rachel Maddow tonight: Rhiannon12866 Thursday #51
Yes, AP News is posting photos & story (Friday morning) FakeNoose Friday #61
Wow! if true, i'm so happy!! bluestarone Friday #62
Is the guy still alive? Martin68 Thursday #57

rurallib

(63,636 posts)
7. trump is a mob boss - mob bosses get rid of evidence, blame it on others
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 03:44 PM
Apr 16

He has a fall guy that we basically can't touch. How perfect

Botany

(73,909 posts)
10. "El Salvador denies senator visit with mistakenly deported man: Van Hollen"
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 03:58 PM
Apr 16
https://www.axios.com/2025/04/16/el-salvador-senator-mistakenly-deported-man

Can’t meet with dead people. It is that simple. Pam Bondi’s press conference all but confirmed
Señor Garcia’s fate of either being dead or the victim of torture.


The sad fact that @ least 25% of Americans really have no problem with what happened
Señor Garcia, his family, or the due process of law because they have bought into the right’s
unceasing lies.

ShazzieB

(20,310 posts)
12. That link goes to a page that says "We can't find the page you're looking for." - EDIT
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 04:33 PM
Apr 16

Just thought you should know.

EDIT: I figured it out. There was an extra character at the end of the link:

https://www.axios.com/2025/04/16/el-salvador-senator-mistakenly-deported-man

Hope this helps,

markodochartaigh

(2,695 posts)
25. "The
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:50 PM
Apr 16

sad fact that @ least 25% of Americans really have no problem with what happened
Señor García...". I would say that at least 25% (the hard-core maga) are happy about what is happening. And about another third (the corporate Republicans, and the apathetic third who can't be bothered to vote) don't really care as long as they get their hamberders and sportsball.

Sneederbunk

(16,059 posts)
20. Navalny comes to mind.
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:30 PM
Apr 16

Last edited Wed Apr 16, 2025, 07:59 PM - Edit history (1)

Garcia's existence is inconvenient.

dchill

(42,080 posts)
32. What does it mean to YOU that Bondi said...
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 06:16 PM
Apr 16

... he's NEVER coming back to this country? My feeling is that he's been dead since the beginning of his illegal incarceration.

WmChris

(305 posts)
37. Silenced
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 06:35 PM
Apr 16

They certainly don't want him comming back and describing what is going in those concentration camps.

homegirl

(1,707 posts)
38. Mrs. Garcia
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 06:35 PM
Apr 16

should charge Donald Trump with the murder of her husband. Trump loses either way- he must produce a live husband or his corpse!

BOSSHOG

(42,130 posts)
2. El Salvador is doing whatever trump wants
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 03:38 PM
Apr 16

Lock the innocent away in a hellhole and throw away the key. I’m sure Christian Mike Johnson is fine with that.

FakeNoose

(37,192 posts)
33. 'Zactly right! Chump was on the phone with Bukele, advising how to answer any pushy Dems
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 06:17 PM
Apr 16

BOSSHOG

(42,130 posts)
36. Two tough guys telling one and all
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 06:27 PM
Apr 16

That there’s nothing we can do. We’re helpless, we’d like to help out but our hands are tied and we can’t do anything. Wo is us.

Dennis Donovan

(30,424 posts)
9. Roxane Gay: Is Kilmar Abrego Garcia alive? Getting distinct impression he's either dead or disfigured.
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 03:56 PM
Apr 16
Roxane Gay
‪@roxanegay.bsky.social‬
Is Kilmar Abrego Garcia alive? Because the amount of resistance to addressing his being trafficked gives the distinct impression that either he is dead or what they have done to him is so unspeakable that they cannot afford for him to be freed, seen, or spoken with.
April 16, 2025 at 3:20 PM


https://bsky.app/profile/roxanegay.bsky.social/post/3lmxcrpkkdc2y

Rhiannon12866

(232,701 posts)
48. That has been my fear all along, they don't want Americans to either see or hear from him - assuming he's still alive
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 09:45 PM
Apr 16

Dennis Donovan

(30,424 posts)
56. Me as well.
Thu Apr 17, 2025, 10:09 AM
Thursday

Their deep recalcitrance over ANY contact with him really makes one think they don't want to have to say he died in custody.

Rhiannon12866

(232,701 posts)
60. Same here! I was afraid that they refused to make an effort because he was already gone and they knew it
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 09:48 AM
Friday

From the photos he looks fine, I hope they're now pressured to bring him (and the others) back if only to put an end to the controversy. And the president of El Salvador is as big an authoritarian jerk with no human feelings as TFG.

travelingthrulife

(2,099 posts)
55. Republicans trafficking people. Isn't this one of the things Republicans say they oppose?
Thu Apr 17, 2025, 10:02 AM
Thursday

These people are the embodiment of evil.

riversedge

(75,145 posts)
11. Sen Van Hollen He was kidnapped under the guise of "policy" and thrown into a foreign prison in violation of a federal c
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 04:17 PM
Apr 16




Senator Van Hollen just landed in El Salvador to do what the Trump administration refuses to: bring Kilmar Abrego Garcia home.

He was kidnapped under the guise of “policy” and thrown into a foreign prison in violation of a federal court order.


hamsterjill

(15,764 posts)
14. Dumb question that I honestly do not know the answer to because I've never had to ask it before.
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 04:44 PM
Apr 16

I can't believe I'm having to ask it now!!!! But we live in treacherous and unusual times.

What is the next step beyond the United States? Can the family appeal to any other (world) organizations to step in and help?

I mean, if El Salvador is doing what Trump wants, and Trump won't let anyone see Garcia - what can be done?

Festivito

(13,693 posts)
16. Over 80% of elected Republicans are keeping him in power.
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:17 PM
Apr 16

The next steps to overthrow a possible dictator are dangerous to even speak.

I'm betting Putin has Kompromat on each of them, pays for the re-election, and it is not only their jobs they fear losing. They fear losing their families and their life and their family's lives.

It gets ugly. Do we fight like it is 1930's Germany or 1790's France?

BumRushDaShow

(151,125 posts)
22. "what can be done? "
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:39 PM
Apr 16

I figured that since we PAID to have him and the others sent there, then it will have to be like a "hostage/ransom" situation and we PAY MORE to get him out. All of that would end up going on "behind the scenes".

BComplex

(9,384 posts)
23. I fear that, while El Salvador might love the money, there is likely no Mr. Garcia there.
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:45 PM
Apr 16

I have no doubt that they didn't want him to ever tell what has gone on in that prison. I'm sure he would have been permanently silenced.

BumRushDaShow

(151,125 posts)
29. I may be wrong
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 06:02 PM
Apr 16

but given how many are apparently in there who they like to "show off", who are probably real criminals, I don't think he is dead.

I think this is more a "for show/tee vee power play" for both 45 and Bukele. It's like a sick game and they'll string it out for maximum effect, until they finally show how "benevolent" they are.

Hell - you have the epitome of a killer - Putin - who although psychologically damaged our "wrongly detained" citizens, didn't kill them outright. I.e, they still want to engage in trade with the rest of the world and something like is being suggested, would definitely make El Salvador an even worse pariah.

As a note - I did a quick search on Bukele and his father's side of the family is... wait for it... Palestinian (originally Christian and his father eventually converted to Islam and became an Imam). His mother's family is Catholic (apparently Hispanic).

BComplex

(9,384 posts)
54. I hope you're right about him being alive. And I hope they will eventually get him back to the US.
Thu Apr 17, 2025, 08:58 AM
Thursday

Good catch on his dad being Palestinian, AND an Islamic Imam, no less! El Salvador is primarily Catholic. I wonder if that has something to do with why trump doesn't care about bringing him home.

NJCher

(39,842 posts)
27. I think the key to this is
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:51 PM
Apr 16

Good thinking.

What is the next step beyond the United States? Can the family appeal to any other (world) organizations to step in and help?

What are the pressure points for this country? For example, we found out real fast what the pressure point is for the automotive industry when trump put the Chinese tariffs on.

What pressure point could make Bukele's life miserable?

sop

(13,796 posts)
31. What pressure point could make Bukele's life miserable?
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 06:09 PM
Apr 16

A group of Democratic Senators and Congressmen should go before the cameras and tell Mr. Bukele in no uncertain terms he will pay for his crimes against humanity. Let him know when Democrats come back to power - and they will be back in power at some point - punishing Bukele, and all those involved with CECOT in El Salvador, will be their number one priority. Call it a threat, call it a promise, but make sure Bukele understands he's not going to escape justice for his many crimes.

Republicans do all kinds of shit with impunity, knowing full well Democrats never respond in kind when they're back in power. Democrats always take the high road. That has to change. Next time it has to be different. Democrats have to stop fucking around. Retribution and punishment are the only things these thugs understand.

FirstLight

(14,977 posts)
44. I'm ready for some fucking retribution!
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 09:10 PM
Apr 16

We need our Democrats to fucking toughen up and decide that we're going to spank some people

markodochartaigh

(2,695 posts)
28. There is the Red Cross and Amnesty International.
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:57 PM
Apr 16

Personally I think that an appeal should be made to Pope Francis. Put the US bishops who supported Trump on the spot.

NJCher

(39,842 posts)
42. if nothing else
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 08:24 PM
Apr 16

It throws them in the lot of sorry assholes who have been castigated by a pope.

ffr

(23,177 posts)
15. How much taxpayer dollars are we paying to imprison people in El Salvador? And is Garcia even there?
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 04:48 PM
Apr 16

WTF? Something very fishy going on here.

'Uh, no, we can't allow you to visit him at this time for XYZ excuses. Try back in a week, but then we won't be able to guarantee that you or anyone will be able to see him then either.'

Really, why would this be? It's total stonewalling to cover something else up.

C Moon

(12,803 posts)
18. Wishful thinking, but eventually these magas will be out on their butts...
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:25 PM
Apr 16

and El Salvador will have some questions to answer from the real United States.

NJCher

(39,842 posts)
43. it's not wishful thinking
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 08:30 PM
Apr 16

it's inevitable when you have the kind of turnout you saw on April 5.
And April 19 is coming up shortly. If the turnout rivals or exceeds, it is major turning point. If legislators know we have their backs, they are more likely to take bolder moves.
I personally thought it very interesting that Bukele says he's going to open another detention center "for immigrants" from the U.S.
Wouldn't you know how tenuous dealing with the U.S. is from our history?

JohnnyRingo

(19,851 posts)
26. Trump paid Nayib Bukele millions to take them off his hands.....
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 05:51 PM
Apr 16

Does anyone thing Bukele is going to spend that money feeding and housing prisoners for years?
First stop was probably the showers.

DallasNE

(7,759 posts)
49. Did Bukele Demand Trump Deport Abrego Garcia To His Custody?
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 10:52 PM
Apr 16

I think this angle needs to be investigated. Why else would both Trump and Bukele have such a strong interest in this random-seeming man? Something smells rotten in this whole affair.

I am further speculating that Abrego Garcia has already been waterboarded and that is why nobody is being allowed to visit him.

William Gustafson

(444 posts)
50. How is this not Nazism?
Wed Apr 16, 2025, 11:43 PM
Apr 16

Hitler did the same thing... Accuse LGBTQ, and Jews of the cause of their WWI problems. To "Make Germany Great Again" they "cleansed" the population of these people and sent them to concentration camps in Poland and eventually, death camps. Then he went after the Court system. Attacked Education. Then the Speech police started arresting anyone that said anything against the government. We all know the horrors of Hitlers rise...
What we are witnessing is a redo of 1938 - 1945 rise of Hitler, in real time....
Sending anyone they deemed a criminal, out of the country, into a maximum-security prison, without any due process is right out of Hitlers play book....

So, I ask again... How is this not Nazism?...

Lokee11

(329 posts)
53. What is the saying..
Thu Apr 17, 2025, 08:24 AM
Thursday

Last edited Thu Apr 17, 2025, 11:30 AM - Edit history (1)

If you do not learn from history, you are bound to repeat it - or something like that.

Overall I guess collectively "we" did not learn, but one thing I guess these REPUGs did not learn - is how it ended for Hitler and his Nazi's. I pray that - that part of history does repeat itself and we rid ourselves of these Nazi's part 2 completely this time not just seemingly.

I hope this post makes sense - I am so enraged while at he same time battling the feeling of defeat these days - These idiots may only care about their pick'em up trucks and hamberders, but it truly baffles me that they do not understand the concept that without due process, truth does not matter, and though they might be as lily white as brand new fallen snow, if the Orange Fuck decides they are Garcia - then they are Garcia! I do not believe that is such a hard concept to understand, and I would think as deplorable as even these Trumpers are, just basic self-preservation instincts would force them to understand - IDFK

✊FDT!

Rhiannon12866

(232,701 posts)
51. And he reported in on Rachel Maddow tonight:
Thu Apr 17, 2025, 12:05 AM
Thursday
Exclusive: Senator Chris Van Hollen talks with Rachel Maddow live from El Salvador - Rachel Maddow - MSNBC
https://democraticunderground.com/132146559


FakeNoose

(37,192 posts)
61. Yes, AP News is posting photos & story (Friday morning)
Fri Apr 18, 2025, 10:03 AM
Friday


Link: https://apnews.com/article/abrego-garcia-el-salvador-trump-deportation-van-hollen-senator-81cca0ac24a9a312be97c730679f8dd1

Headline: Maryland Sen. Van Hollen meets with Abrego Garcia in El Salvador amid court fight over US return

I consider this as "proof of life," am I right?

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»US senator says El Salvad...