Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Old Crank

(7,495 posts)
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 03:46 PM 5 hrs ago

Will Republicans vote Democratic in the fall?

Here is an article that states we shouldn't expect much change from Republican voters who disapprove o Trump.

https://www.gelliottmorris.com/p/2026-07-13-lab-gop-anchors-generic-ballot

You have to scroll past the introduction to get tothe real meat of the article.

Quote.

Laurance wanted me to take the Trump disapprovers who still aren’t voting Democratic and carry at least one Republican “anchor” — a 2024 Trump ballot, Republican party ID or lean, or conservative self-ID — and split them up by which anchors they carry. How does each combination vote on the generic ballot? In other words, don’t just count the anchors — ask which ones actually hold.

I recommend you read the piece linked above to get a better idea of how this works, but basically what we’re doing is looking at the subset of people in our poll who say they disapprove of Trump but aren’t voting Democrat and trying to figure out why — and, importantly, how many of those voters Democrats might actually win.

If you sort voters by Trump approval and generic-ballot vote and then count the GOP anchors in each cell, we find that among disapprovers who are undecided, 40% carry one or more GOP anchors. Among disapprovers who say they’ll vote GOP, 90% have Republican anchors. That’s the group I called “closet Republicans” in my May piece. There are a lot of disapproves who look more like Trump supporters/Republicans than Democratic voters, all else being equal.

Here are the numbers: Voters carrying all three anchors (a Trump ‘24 ballot, Republican in party affiliation, and conservative self-ID) are still voting Republican 76% to 16, so disapproving of Trump barely dents them. Voters who pulled the lever for Trump in ‘24 and call themselves Republicans but not conservatives stay Republican too, at 63% to 26.
End of copy

The basic upshot is that we can't expect a lot of movement from Republican voters to the Democratic side for the midterms. Granted it won't take much to swing quite a few races but it can't be counted on. The best bet is to concentrate more on independents with few 'anchors'

15 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Will Republicans vote Democratic in the fall? (Original Post) Old Crank 5 hrs ago OP
that would require being pro-America Skittles 5 hrs ago #1
No... we need swing voters and independent voters to vote for Democrats. QueerDuck 5 hrs ago #2
30% GOP crossover vote in a deep red TX district (9) Torchlight 5 hrs ago #3
What does that do to Tx republican vote? How much is it lowered? 31j20b3 5 hrs ago #4
Very encouraging.... anciano 5 hrs ago #6
Party ID is the best predictor of how someone will vote Deminpenn 5 hrs ago #5
Not any more Fiendish Thingy 4 hrs ago #14
More people stayed home than voted for either last time and that's got to change mahina 5 hrs ago #7
Among my republican acquaintances voting D cachukis 5 hrs ago #8
I hope we don't waste money and energy on fascists voters, we are going to have a hard enough time ImNotGod 4 hrs ago #9
The key is The Wizard 4 hrs ago #10
They already are Fiendish Thingy 4 hrs ago #11
This is ABSOLUTELY no surprise stopdiggin 4 hrs ago #12
No they won't vote D, but they might stay home. Raftergirl 4 hrs ago #13
Yea Lategame 4 hrs ago #15

QueerDuck

(2,518 posts)
2. No... we need swing voters and independent voters to vote for Democrats.
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 03:51 PM
5 hrs ago

That's how we win.

Torchlight

(7,428 posts)
3. 30% GOP crossover vote in a deep red TX district (9)
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 03:51 PM
5 hrs ago

in a special election about four months ago. 80% Independent vote as well.

31j20b3

(275 posts)
4. What does that do to Tx republican vote? How much is it lowered?
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 03:56 PM
5 hrs ago

I really have no idea about the true numbers/percent distributions of voters in Tx.

Deminpenn

(17,673 posts)
5. Party ID is the best predictor of how someone will vote
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 03:56 PM
5 hrs ago

It's not surprising self-identified Rs are voting for Rs and will continue to do so. But, to win, a candidate needs to hold upwards of 90% of it's party voters. 76% or 63% isn't goint to hack it.

There are also voters who are primarily or only motivated by Trump's name being on the ballot. They'll stay home. We saw this in real time just two months after the 2020 Nov election in GA when Warnock and Ossoff won their special elections. Fewer Rs showed up to vote in Jan than they did in Nov.

Fiendish Thingy

(24,774 posts)
14. Not any more
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 04:44 PM
4 hrs ago

The Trump-induced suffering is so widespread it crosses all racial, regional and partisan boundaries.

Dems have been winning elections over the past 18 months in deep red districts, and some of those victories would be mathematically impossible without a significant number of republicans crossing over to vote for the Dem candidate.

cachukis

(4,232 posts)
8. Among my republican acquaintances voting D
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 04:12 PM
5 hrs ago

would be no different than becoming a Muslim.
They believe that giving up on Jesus is the same as giving up on r's.
Intelligence and curiosity are not issues. Simple emotional connection to belong to a similar world view.

ImNotGod

(1,371 posts)
9. I hope we don't waste money and energy on fascists voters, we are going to have a hard enough time
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 04:31 PM
4 hrs ago

just convincing the 90 million who didn't bother to vote to show up at the polls. I know it should be easy after all the crap the fascists are pulling but we can't take nothing for granted. I know I have seen a determine effort targeting young voters in blue states with RW propaganda blaming their problems on local/ state government. YT, twitter, tic tok is full of influencers doing that. Plus the Rave music scene is pushing a lot of the racist RW agenda for an example.

Fiendish Thingy

(24,774 posts)
11. They already are
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 04:39 PM
4 hrs ago

In actual elections, not polls, over the years past 18 months, Dem candidates have over performed in 2024 Trump +20 districts by 15-30 points.

Some of the victories would have been mathematically impossible without a significant number of republicans crossing over to vote for the Dem candidate.

stopdiggin

(15,889 posts)
12. This is ABSOLUTELY no surprise
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 04:41 PM
4 hrs ago

very, very few are inclined to actually 'cross over' - and it has pretty much always been so.

People are much more prone to take a pass ...
Either on a particular race - or a whole election.

Lategame

(14 posts)
15. Yea
Mon Jul 13, 2026, 04:47 PM
4 hrs ago

My Republican family, neighbors, coworkers I highly doubt. I know a lot of swing voters, that's where the opportunity is.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Will Republicans vote Dem...