Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

RandySF

(86,183 posts)
Mon May 18, 2026, 06:16 AM 11 hrs ago

A Crack in the Polling Floor Puts Trump in New Territory

Over the last decade, it’s often been said that President Trump’s support has a low ceiling but a high floor.

In this morning’s latest New York Times/Siena poll, whether Mr. Trump really has a high floor is starting to be put to the test.

Just 37 percent of Americans approve of his performance as president, a drop of four percentage points from the last Times/Siena poll in January and his lowest approval rating in any Times/Siena survey in either term.

A four-point decline isn’t necessarily huge, but it puts Mr. Trump’s ratings in new political territory. While recent presidencies have often been unpopular and polarizing, no president’s approval rating has been under 38 percent for more than a few days in the last 17 years, according to our average. If there has been a floor during this partisan era of politics, Mr. Trump’s ratings today have fallen to it.





https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/18/upshot/trump-poll-times-siena-analyis.html

19 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A Crack in the Polling Floor Puts Trump in New Territory (Original Post) RandySF 11 hrs ago OP
I'm not a fan of polls, gab13by13 11 hrs ago #1
it's fake news. See Louisiana's vote against Cassidy. They still love Trump. dem4decades 11 hrs ago #2
national vs local pimpbot 10 hrs ago #4
Only 38% of all registered Republican voters in the state of Louisiana voted in their Senate primary. sop 10 hrs ago #5
Thanks - fantastic context FiveFifteen 9 hrs ago #13
Do you know about Louisiana Republican voters? They voted for David Duke back in the day. Wanderlust988 9 hrs ago #11
Even this poll does not contradict the Louisiana poll karynnj 9 hrs ago #12
Seeing this in SEPA... but signs in red PA, too. FiveFifteen 8 hrs ago #15
But What Will Democrats modrepub 6 hrs ago #18
That is a Republican primary edhopper 8 hrs ago #16
A small minority that will deliver a majority vote to a MAGA candidate. dem4decades 7 hrs ago #17
I shudder to think... BH liberal 10 hrs ago #3
Incredible, isn't it? MyOwnPeace 8 hrs ago #14
So a third plus of America are hard core LuvLoogie 10 hrs ago #6
The pollsters don't have any reason to "butter him up" any more FakeNoose 10 hrs ago #7
"no president's approval rating has been under 38 percent for more than a few days" Azathoth1 9 hrs ago #8
I have seen so many articles the past couple months about his poll numbers dropping ToxMarz 9 hrs ago #9
Means nothing Abstractartist 9 hrs ago #10
I've been saying all year that his popularity doesn't get lower than 37% Wicked Blue 4 hrs ago #19

sop

(19,286 posts)
5. Only 38% of all registered Republican voters in the state of Louisiana voted in their Senate primary.
Mon May 18, 2026, 07:58 AM
10 hrs ago

There are 1,023,335 registered Republican voters in Louisiana.

Letlow received 179,876, Fleming 113,428, and Cassidy 99,479 in the Louisiana Republican Senate primary, for a total of 392,783 votes, or 38% of all registered Republican voters in the state.

Taken one step further, only 28.6% (293,304) of registered Republican voters in Louisiana followed Trump's orders and voted against Cassidy, casting their votes for either Letlow or Fleming.

I suspect Trump's approval numbers are closer to 28% than 37%.



FiveFifteen

(114 posts)
13. Thanks - fantastic context
Mon May 18, 2026, 09:11 AM
9 hrs ago

Though difficult to assess due to a change in the primary structure (from jungle to closed party in 2026), the turnout drop-off from the prior-off-year primaries is about half the Republican senate vote volume seen in the comparable 2010 and 2014 off-presidential cycles (the ~27% 2026 R primary turnout was ~51% of 2014 and 2010's turnouts*).

We can't infer much from this, though the potential takeaway is positive since it may indicate a lack of wider, non-MAGAt Republican voter participation.

However, let's keep working hard to unify and make this come true in November instead of giving Trump what he needs (a splintered Dem party across single issues-driven coalitions).



*R votes cast volume (rough estimates)
- 2026: 401,118
- 2014: 779,520
- 2010: 785,660

Wanderlust988

(799 posts)
11. Do you know about Louisiana Republican voters? They voted for David Duke back in the day.
Mon May 18, 2026, 08:47 AM
9 hrs ago

These are the same people. No surprise.

karynnj

(61,092 posts)
12. Even this poll does not contradict the Louisiana poll
Mon May 18, 2026, 08:56 AM
9 hrs ago

Trump is still above water with Republicans. Throw in that this is Louisiana and that primary voters often are the most dedicated.

If his popularity is still this low in November, the composition of primaries now may mean that at a point the Republicans are polling poorly, they might be picking candidates less likely to win the general election.

FiveFifteen

(114 posts)
15. Seeing this in SEPA... but signs in red PA, too.
Mon May 18, 2026, 09:34 AM
8 hrs ago

I can't wait for the results of tomorrow's Primary Day. Ds are on a full-court press statewide, running everywhere. Rs need to spend where they never had to before to defend prior safe seats. The R candidates put forth in our region for the statehouse are abysmally amateurish-to-clownish, with multiple desperate campaigns for Republican candidates to run as write-ins tomorrow against D incumbents.

This doesn't mean that the seats are flipping easily from red to blue. But just to hold onto their white-knuckle state senate majority and to keep their house minority margin close enough to have any leverage at all, Rs must empty their coffers for a defense as opposed to pushing valuable dollars to expanding their seats in the General Assembly.

The special elections of the past year are positive indicators for Dems. From flipping a historically R senate seat in 2025 to the surprisingly strong coalition formed over just seven weeks for HD-79 (Blair County) to make Rs earn their 15-point victory in a district with a 55-29 R-to-D advantage. And burning billionaire's cash in statewide elections is becoming a hobby for PA Dems, who rallied voters to crush R candidates in the high-stakes 2025 State Supreme Court race.

This isn't meant to paint a rosy picture, there is hard work, bumps and bruises along the way.

It is validation and a boost of energy to efforts when more is needed to finish this leg of the decades-long marathon ahead to rid ourselves of MAGAtism.

November is not the finish line, it is the start.



modrepub

(4,189 posts)
18. But What Will Democrats
Mon May 18, 2026, 11:39 AM
6 hrs ago

Do with their majority? Try and appease areas of the state that are hostile to them?

As a PA resident, I appalled at how much state money goes into the deep red parts of this state. Why do folks who support their local fire and police departments have to pay to keep state police in other sections of the state who don’t have local forces? Why is Turnpike money builing new toll roads in Pittsburgh no locals want to use? Why are we finishing the 322 project in Centre County so people can shave off 5 minutes to get to a college football game?

The roads I travel to work haven’t been touched in decades. Potholes damage cars. Street lights stay on all day. My public transit is operating with equipment from the Nixon era. And on and on.

I would love it if Dems played hardball and kept taxes and PA Turnpike money in the communities that generated it. Let the rurals figure out their own spending on their own

edhopper

(37,517 posts)
16. That is a Republican primary
Mon May 18, 2026, 09:39 AM
8 hrs ago

a poll of only registered Republicans, who are pro Trump. But registered Republicans, which is about 30% of registered voters. And the winner in that didn't even get 50%.
So it shows a small minority still love Trump.

dem4decades

(14,377 posts)
17. A small minority that will deliver a majority vote to a MAGA candidate.
Mon May 18, 2026, 10:23 AM
7 hrs ago

What's the difference what the perceived % of MAGA voters is if they keep voting in numbers to deliver MAGA candidates to public office?

MyOwnPeace

(17,609 posts)
14. Incredible, isn't it?
Mon May 18, 2026, 09:19 AM
8 hrs ago

You have to wonder how ANY sane person can think he is r only capable of running a lemonade stand, let alone our country!

LuvLoogie

(8,907 posts)
6. So a third plus of America are hard core
Mon May 18, 2026, 08:06 AM
10 hrs ago

racists or have bought into their narrative. While the squishy middle doesn't see white supremacy as a deal breaker as long as there's peace at the pumpkin farm.

FakeNoose

(42,391 posts)
7. The pollsters don't have any reason to "butter him up" any more
Mon May 18, 2026, 08:11 AM
10 hrs ago

... so now they're giving him the real poll numbers. Maybe they should have done this all along?

Chump is the WORST President of all time, now and forever. His main competition was the first term of Donald Chump. By the time he's done, it will be clear to everyone - including the MAGAs - that he never should have been allowed to run a 2nd time.


Azathoth1

(5 posts)
8. "no president's approval rating has been under 38 percent for more than a few days"
Mon May 18, 2026, 08:19 AM
9 hrs ago

So not only has another president fallen to a 37 point approval, but it happened to either Biden or Trump himself during his first term.

What a clickbait headline.

Nothing has changed.

ToxMarz

(3,063 posts)
9. I have seen so many articles the past couple months about his poll numbers dropping
Mon May 18, 2026, 08:27 AM
9 hrs ago

and reaching new unprecedented lows. They are always still right around 37 percent. Not seeing where the big drop is. If they had dropped as much and as often as I've seen reported seems they would be in the teens by now.

Abstractartist

(449 posts)
10. Means nothing
Mon May 18, 2026, 08:47 AM
9 hrs ago

Means nothing, nada, zip, means shit…… unless we actually win the house and hopefully make inroads in the Senate.

Wicked Blue

(9,016 posts)
19. I've been saying all year that his popularity doesn't get lower than 37%
Mon May 18, 2026, 02:00 PM
4 hrs ago

But all the poll people get excited about 37% and claim its the biggest drop ever.

Bullcrap. I'll get excited when I see a poll claiming 33% or lower.

Kick in to the DU tip jar?

This week we're running a special pop-up mini fund drive. From Monday through Friday we're going ad-free for all registered members, and we're asking you to kick in to the DU tip jar to support the site and keep us financially healthy.

As a bonus, making a contribution will allow you to leave kudos for another DU member, and at the end of the week we'll recognize the DUers who you think make this community great.

Tell me more...

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»A Crack in the Polling Fl...