General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMAGA Melts Down Over Already Sold-Out Summer Blockbuster
The right has landed on its next Hollywood target.
The Odyssey, the forthcoming summer blockbuster from Oscar-winning director Christopher Nolan, which depicts the fictional events of the eponymous Greek epic, was the subject of a long-winded rant by Newsmax host Rob Finnerty on Thursday evening over its rewriting of history.
Though the Trojan War, as described in the epic, really happened, there is no evidence that any of its characters actually existed. Still, Finnerty, 44, complained on his show, The role of Achilles will reportedly be played by Elliot Page. Looks like a guyformerly Ellen Page, meaning the most famous warrior in history, not just Greek historyall of historyAchilles is about to be played by a transgender woman in a brand new movie.
Elliot Pages role in the film has not been confirmed. Other confirmed cast members include Matt Damon, Anne Hathaway, Tom Holland, Zendaya, Lupita Nyongo, Robert Pattinson, and Charlize Theron, among others.
A woman who was definitely white is going to be played by Lupita Nyongo, he added. Ive got nothing against Lupita. But I do have a problem with the complete rewriting of history. Helen of Troy was not Black. Thats not me being mean. Thats me telling the truth. The real actual truth, which we tend to do a lot of here, and Achilles was not a five-foot-one woman, but to the Left, this is all normal.
https://www.thedailybeast.com/obsessed/maga-melts-down-over-already-sold-out-the-odyssey/
***************************************************************************************************
Ummmmm
Helen of Troy was a demigoddess, the daughter of Zeus and a mortal woman.
Who knows what her skin color would have been?
Oh yeah, and she's a fictional character!
chowder66
(12,497 posts)thucythucy
(9,143 posts)depicted Fey's actual life.
That seems a right wing thing--the inability to tell fact from fiction.
Coventina
(29,936 posts)the nelm
(295 posts)It's always a given with these folk. Obsessive-compulsive, neurotic, unhinged - call it what you will.
dem4decades
(14,362 posts)Unrepentant Fenian
(1,142 posts)jmowreader
(53,386 posts)You mean Christopher Nolan, who makes good movies, is going to cast someone as short as Elliot Page to play a larger-than-life character?
eppur_se_muova
(42,459 posts)ornotna
(11,551 posts)But its just a movie.
Theyll be acting.

Cha
(320,480 posts)Last edited Fri May 15, 2026, 07:43 PM - Edit history (1)
ancianita
(43,334 posts)Nolan must want to exert artistic license here, since there's no definitive historical evidence proving Homer's existence. That said, I'm still willing to see his film.
from DeepMind AI ...
Whether the poet Homer existed is unknown, a mystery known as the "Homeric Question." While traditionally regarded as the blind, 8th-century BCE author of the Iliad and Odyssey, most scholars believe the poems are products of a long oral tradition, potentially composed or compiled by multiple people rather than one individual.
Traditional View:
Ancient Greeks believed Homer was a real, blind itinerant poet from Ionia.
Modern Scholarship:
Many experts argue that the extensive, formulaic nature of the poems suggests they evolved over centuries of oral storytelling by many poets, not just one.
The Debate:
There is no definitive historical evidence proving his existence. Some argue "Homer" was a placeholder name for the tradition, while others hold that a single, foundational genius shaped the final narratives.
Alternative Theory:
Some scholars suggest the poems were written down later, possibly by a group of scholars in Athens or Alexandria, rather than by a single poet.
Ultimately, the existence of a single, historical person named Homer remains unproven
niyad
(133,971 posts)swong19104
(662 posts)Played Genghis Khan in the 1956 The Conqueror.
And Mickey Rooney as Mr Yunioshi in Breakfast At Tiffanys.
And so on.
BaronChocula
(4,725 posts)No one really... um... those guys were iconic actors. Uh. I believe Genghis Khan was part white I believe. Ummmmm. You had very iconic... Yeah they were white, but aren't you being racist? Why can't we be inclusive of white men. Jeez. Liberals are so intolerant!"
Seinan Sensei
(1,636 posts)Standing by Jesus, at the foot of the cross, saying
Surely this was the son of God"
One cannot unhear that John Wayne drawl
Aw-haw
displacedvermoter
(4,974 posts)The Year of Living Dangerously, won Best Supporting Actress Award in 1983. Great movie. Only person to win an Oscar for playing someone of the opposite sex. Anyways...
Collimator
(2,137 posts)And The Odyssey features Sirens and a Cyclops and all sorts of other mythical figures which, frankly, I don't remember. Does anyone have any strong feelings about which "race" the Cyclopses (?) were?
BidenRocks
(3,478 posts)Without him, many would never have known of these adventures
Just Jerome
(556 posts)were likely the same race as Stewart Rhodes.
blue-wave
(5,531 posts)It was just maga blood vessels bursting. Now, now. We must watch our blood pressure.
BaronChocula
(4,725 posts)You're erasing my fantasy culture, even though I'm not even Greek or make believe!"
Unfortunately Finnerty is real. A real bagacrap.
Warpy
(114,653 posts)because every Christofascist wngnut in the country is going to be lined up for those. I know the subject matter, and they're all going to be deeply offended by them, but they'll still be lined up.
hlthe2b
(114,626 posts)peppertree
(23,448 posts)"No, Alex - and Patroclus didn't look like Garret Hedlund (nor was he his "nephew" )."

patphil
(9,214 posts)The Odyssey is a fictional account of an historical event.
Helen of Troy didn't exist, no did Achilles, no did Odysseus, let alone all the fictitious creatures that appear in the book. This movie is simply a reboot of the original.
Rob Finnerty doesn't seem to know the difference between fiction and non-fiction.
Please don't tell him that Captain Marvel was originally a man, or that Jesus was probably brown skinned.
And, Santa Claus...well, we won't go into that.
dave99
(255 posts)patphil
(9,214 posts)Homer took liberties with history to support his fictional epic.
LearnedHand
(5,583 posts)And I cant even with the rest of the stupidity. Its fucking FICTION.
yardwork
(69,585 posts)Her parents were a god and a mortal woman (in some versions a goddess) who transformed herself into a swan.
Anybody saying this fictional character is "definitely white" is hilarious.
Initech
(109,237 posts)Your shitty, worthless turd of a president and his ass kissing goons are rewriting our constitution and our rights. Go shove your pity party where it doesn't shine.
SouthernIrish
(540 posts)My very red east Tennessee town is building a new IMAX theater and the first movie to be shown is The Odyssey. This is great.
yellowcanine
(36,826 posts)BlueWaveNeverEnd
(14,935 posts)kairos12
(13,702 posts)the "Brojan" horse crowd. LOL.