General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDemocratic Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice leaves party over antisemitism.
Link to tweet
?s=20
Inbox: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice David Wecht, first elected as a Democrat in 2015 and retained last year, says in a statement he is "no longer registered within any political party," because "acquiescence to Jew-hatred is now disturbingly common" in the Democratic Party.
Johonny
(26,540 posts)And many can't separate Israel the country from the Jewish religion...
markpkessinger
(8,932 posts)From my observation, there are three prevalent attitudes among American voters about all of this.
(1) The Israel-Can-Do-No-Wrong Lobby. These are the folks who will justify anything and everything Israel does in response to October 7. This group will brook no criticism of Israel or its current government, or, in some cases, they will pay lip service to some very mild criticism of the Israeli government's actions, They ignore the long and very troubled history that surrounds the creation of modern Israel and its history of mistreatment of the Palestinians;
(2) Those believe Israel has a right to exist and to defend itself (including responding to the October 7 attacks), but nevertheless believe there must be limits on the kind of response Israel undertakes; and
(3) The Israel-Can-Do-Nothing-Good-or-Right lobby. This group is the inverse of group (1), and will find reason to take issue with anything Israel does in response to Oct. 7.
Among Jewish friends of mine, they seem to be found across groups (1) and (2). There are both religious and secular Jews in both groups.
In addition to pro-Israeli hardliners, Group (1) consists also of some less religious and more secular Jews who are deeply emotionally invested in the very idea of Israel. For these folks, it is very difficult for them to consider even the possibility that Israel, which they've long held up in their minds as a kind of utopia, could possibly ever do anything that is morally or ethically questionable. If you try to confront them with evidence of Israeli wrongdoing, they either just shut down, or they respond that all of the evidence is "anti-Israel propaganda."
And among both groups (1) and (3), there are elements trying to force those in group (2) to one side or the other. Those like this in group (1) will, as I said above, dismiss almost any evidence of things Israel as done as anti-Semitic propaganda, and will reject out of hand the possibility that one can be critical of the current Israeli government without being Anti-Semitic. And those of this ilk in Group (3) want to reduce everything about the conflict to a question of Israeli oppression and Palestinian victimhood. And BOTH sides want to consider the conflict very selectively, and will insist that any evidence contrary to their respective narratives must be discounted or dismissed.
Ars Longa
(563 posts)The Gaza & Lebanon bombings by Netanyahu, and the Israeli Far-Right-Likud/IDF
over these last 2 years (with our bombs and $) is creating a LOT of Anti-Semitic
sentiment right here in America!! Especially among young people!
I am quite able to separate the Jewish Faith and regular Jewish
citizens, here and in Israel -from the Netanyahu/IDF Regime.
Increasingly, A lot of Americans now, are NOT making that distinction!!
JohnQFunk
(498 posts)there's your antisemitism, sport, yet not one blessed word out of you about them. Go Vance yourself.
RandySF
(85,869 posts)And there's rising antisemitism on the left that I've spoken out on.
Cha
(320,392 posts)Is not registered to any party. It's in the OP.
pcdb
(132 posts)Cha
(320,392 posts)are Not Anti-Semitic.
Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice David Wecht obviously feels it at a strong level
We here on DU read reports of Anti-Semitism from all over the world.
Mad_Machine76
(25,002 posts)For the umpteenth time: Opposition to the Israeli occupation of the West Bank, expansion of illegal settlements, killing of innocent Palestinians or support of the Palestinian people (who are NOT Hamas) is NOT "antisemitism." There are some fringe elements on the left that take this to the extreme, of course, however, the Democratic Party does not support the extremists and condemns them (i.e. Hasan Piker). Of course, there are plenty in the Republican Party who *are* openly antisemitic AND platformed by the Republican Party. I don't understand where people like Fetterman and this Judge are getting the idea that it's the Democratic Party that has become a hotbed of antisemitism????
RandySF
(85,869 posts)when candidates hang out with an influencer who calls Orthodox Jews inbred.
Whiskeytide
(4,661 posts)candidates have hung out with him?
RandySF
(85,869 posts)Cori Bush, Graham Platner, Abdul El-Sayaad, Saikat Chakrabarti, Ro Khanna, Zohran Mamdani, Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib and Chris Rabb.
Whiskeytide
(4,661 posts)Mad_Machine76
(25,002 posts)Is this a widespread Party issue? I feel like maybe he is grossly exaggerating the issue.
RandySF
(85,869 posts)Cori Bush, Graham Platner, Abdul El-Sayaad, Saikat Chakrabarti, Ro Khanna, Zohran Mamdani, Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib and Chris Rabb.
JBTaurus83
(1,660 posts)Not sure what he wants the Democratic Party to do about this exactly. Id love to hear some specific policy requests from him. My guess is hes an AIPAC type and hes butt hurt that a lot of Dems dont like what Israel is doing.
Response to RandySF (Original post)
BannonsLiver This message was self-deleted by its author.
Jklopmant
(1 post)He should be ashamed for sticking to an apartheid regime that murders the indigenous Palestinians in cold blood. Zionism is a great evil that needs to perished off the face of the earth. Israel needs to be dismantle and replaced with a one secular state that gives equal rights to Christians, Jews, Muslims and other faiths/no faith.
Many great Jews have speaker out against Zionism. Look at the great work being done by Katie Halper and Max Blumenthal on the crimes of Israel. We need more Jews to come out and speak out against the evil of Zionism.
Initech
(109,193 posts)Netanyahu is one evil POS.
RandySF
(85,869 posts)when business are vandalized, synagogues are picketed and candidates campaign with someone who says he doesn't care about rapes on Oct 7.