Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A sneaking suspicion (Original Post) orangecrush 12 hrs ago OP
And the Klan never died. sheshe2 12 hrs ago #1
And now they're wearing black robes and no hood. Buddyzbuddy 9 hrs ago #10
The rebel leaders should have been tried and executed. dalton99a 11 hrs ago #2
Exactly. Open rebellion is the very definition of treason. TomSlick 9 hrs ago #14
Well said! (n/t) OldBaldy1701E 36 min ago #17
Indeed. yellow dahlia 11 hrs ago #3
Please don't isolate me! 😊 BeneteauBum 10 hrs ago #6
Good point. There are good people below the M-D line. yellow dahlia 10 hrs ago #7
That Confederacy relogic 11 hrs ago #4
I've said for years the confederacy didn't lose Dave Id 10 hrs ago #5
Ya think?!?!?! Exp 10 hrs ago #8
We should never have let them back into the union dflprincess 10 hrs ago #9
Now I am hoping for a secession IzzaNuDay 9 hrs ago #11
Let's boil it down to its essence... GiqueCee 9 hrs ago #12
Well said, GiqueCee.. Permanut 9 hrs ago #13
Compromise of 1877 moondust 7 hrs ago #15
If only I could rec more than once. returnee 45 min ago #16
After the war Robert E. Lee petitioned to have his citizenship restored, but he was not pardoned nor had his Rhiannon12866 22 min ago #19
They lost the war but lonely bird 24 min ago #18
That's not a sneaking suspicion. Susan Calvin 58 sec ago #20

Buddyzbuddy

(2,820 posts)
10. And now they're wearing black robes and no hood.
Thu May 7, 2026, 10:22 PM
9 hrs ago

Oh yeah, and they've opened membership to a minority.

TomSlick

(13,075 posts)
14. Exactly. Open rebellion is the very definition of treason.
Thu May 7, 2026, 10:59 PM
9 hrs ago

Instead of trying the rebel leaders for treason, they were lionized and allowed to sow the seeds Jim Crow and today's white nationalism.

The US was too quick to "bind up the nation's wounds." Real reconstruction of the rebellious states was made impossible by failing to punish the leaders of the rebellion. The US won the war and lost the peace.

yellow dahlia

(6,384 posts)
3. Indeed.
Thu May 7, 2026, 08:55 PM
11 hrs ago

With what's going on with gerrymandering - maybe we would be better off w/out the South.

yellow dahlia

(6,384 posts)
7. Good point. There are good people below the M-D line.
Thu May 7, 2026, 09:32 PM
10 hrs ago

I am glad to see so many voices standing up in Tennessee and elsewhere.

relogic

(215 posts)
4. That Confederacy
Thu May 7, 2026, 09:17 PM
11 hrs ago

rose out of the white, European entitlement spawned from colonialism. The founders and our grand experiment was blemished, rotten and riddled with racism, not so easily detected or unveiled fully in those 60 -70 years since that founding. Then, the same ugliness we see now of white entitlement came to a head. A civil war, indeed.

We must punish ourselves today as we must the well-meaning carpenters of independence, though their horror at what they’ve seen created must be enough.

Dave Id

(318 posts)
5. I've said for years the confederacy didn't lose
Thu May 7, 2026, 09:24 PM
10 hrs ago

they just retreated, then spread their toxic racism throughout the country.

dflprincess

(29,405 posts)
9. We should never have let them back into the union
Thu May 7, 2026, 09:55 PM
10 hrs ago

Should have just treated them as territories like Guam or Puerto Rico.

GiqueCee

(4,611 posts)
12. Let's boil it down to its essence...
Thu May 7, 2026, 10:33 PM
9 hrs ago

... Confederates were traitors. Celebrating them in any way, shape, or form, can no longer be condoned. It should never have been condoned at all. Ever. But too many slaveholders and their sympathizers in the North let lowlifes lead the way for far, far too long.
My surname is very common in the South. And I've known People of Color that share that name because their ancestors were the property of some of my ancestors. I can never make amends for that obscene travesty; I can only try to live my life better, and give what little I can to make the lives of others a little better.
I'm old. Hell, I don't even buy green bananas, and folks younger than me drop like flies every day, so I harbor no illusions that I'll live long enough to help make the world a better place. I'm just a drop in that bucket, but they say a single drop counts. I will keep trying to count.

Permanut

(8,534 posts)
13. Well said, GiqueCee..
Thu May 7, 2026, 10:55 PM
9 hrs ago

I was born and raised in the Northwest, which was not squeaky clean of the stench. The KKK was very active in Oregon in the 20's.

moondust

(21,337 posts)
15. Compromise of 1877
Fri May 8, 2026, 01:06 AM
7 hrs ago
~
During the Reconstruction era of the 1860s and 1870s, the Southern United States fell under federal military oversight. The compromise (of 1877) entailed that Democrats ended both a filibuster of the certified (1876) election results as well as threats of political violence in exchange for the Republicans' ending military oversight. When (Rutherford B.) Hayes took office, he withdrew the last federal troops from the South, which historians largely regard as the end of Reconstruction.
~
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compromise_of_1877

returnee

(971 posts)
16. If only I could rec more than once.
Fri May 8, 2026, 07:36 AM
45 min ago

Playing off the inherent flaws in our Constitution, the Lincoln and Johnson administrations failed to adequately punish the remnants of the confederacy thus allowing the inherent sociopathy therein to fester. We now have a situation not unlike leaving an infection in the human body insufficiently treated, leading to resistance to increasingly potent antibiotics. We now appear to have a democracy-resistant fascist infection.

Rhiannon12866

(258,091 posts)
19. After the war Robert E. Lee petitioned to have his citizenship restored, but he was not pardoned nor had his
Fri May 8, 2026, 07:59 AM
22 min ago

Citizenship restored in his lifetime. But Senator Harry Byrd conducted a 5-year campaign to pardon him, since Lee had signed an oath of allegiance, and it passed, so President Ford signed the bill in 1975.

lonely bird

(3,008 posts)
18. They lost the war but
Fri May 8, 2026, 07:58 AM
24 min ago

They won the peace.

The “Party of Lincoln™️” abandoned the Black people with the machinations of the election in 1876. Conservatives wanted to do business with the South and that was deemed more important than what happened to the former slaves.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»A sneaking suspicion