General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhat you post matters
Last edited Mon May 4, 2026, 02:42 AM - Edit history (6)
Apologies in advance to all those who will write off this post as too "preachy."
Anyway, as I thought about malaise's poignant "Does anyone care?" question about The Guardian's report of an Israeli reservist who shot 14-year-old Aws al-Naasan in the head just outside his school, it struck me that the post could be taken as implying "nobody cares" about these types of atrocities.
I know what a caring soul malaise is, and don't mean to single out that post, but it got me thinking about the number of posts that come right out and make blanket statements like "No one in Congress is doing anything about X" or "People are dying and no one cares" or "They are committing war crimes and no one cares," or other pronouncements like "We're doomed," "It will never change," "The system is rigged and can't be unrigged."
There are two problems with such statements.
1. They are NEVER accurate.
For every single systemic wrong, structural injustice, ongoing atrocity, war crime, abuse of power, or otherwise preventable terrible thing that we want to see stopped, or lack of some good thing we want to see more of, somebody cares; somebody is doing something. Often hundreds, thousands, or even millions of "somebodies" care and have taken some step to DO SOMETHING.
Similarly, pronouncements of doom and hopelessness are disproven by examples of the amazing things people have accomplished across the history of our nation and the history of the world. People-power is a force that can, and has, moved mountains.
2. Such generalizations sap hope and immobilize, potentially creating a defeatist, self-fulfilling prophecy.
If the desire is for more people to do something about X or Y, or care more about X or Y, offering such blanket pessimistic, and demonstrably untrue statements accomplishes the opposite.
Think about it. If your audience believes that no one cares or is doing anything about X or Y, what do you think is the more likely response? (a) Feel anger about the hopeless horrific state of humanity and then shut down, or (b) start a citizen lobbying project to actually do something about X or Y.
YMMV, but for me, the answer is (a)
The thing is, hope is the life's blood of resistance. Action is inspired by the belief that taking action to address some wrong can work. And the impulse to seek out groups or people to join with to right some wrong only manifests if you believe there are groups and people out there worth joining.
If you want to see more people connecting to right the wrongs of the world, think hard before you post. Is this post sapping or boosting hope? Is this post fostering or crushing the belief in people-power? Does this post highlight or ignore the hard work that people are doing?
We can have a clear-eyed view of what we are up against AND serve as beacons of hope that kick off the sort of collective virtuous cycle of hope and action that we MUST HAVE if we are to overcome the obstacles.
So, that's my advice for helping to build a better world: think before you click "Post." Everything you post contributes the the collective "mood" of a platform. And in an infinitely interconnected social media environment, that "mood" spreads far and wide.
What you post matters. A lot.
For example:
If you are pointing out a terrible thing or obstacle to progress, can you balance the message with a pointer to something the reader could do to help address the terrible thing or help overcome the obstacle?
Every once in awhile, ask yourself: Have I posted a "call to action" lately? When was the last time I promoted a group that is organizing citizen lobbyists to push electeds to communicate more effectively or to get behind some reform ? Have I spread the word about a citizen action success story recently? Have I spread the word about an elected's inspiring message or effective action?
If the answer is NO to all the above, perhaps take a little time to boost your own sense of hope and belief in people-power by seeking out things like that to post.
And BTW, FWIW here is my answer to malaise's post: Millions care. Citizen lobbyists have an uphill battle, but they've been working for decades. (List of organizations, both U.S. and Israeli)
multigraincracker
(37,935 posts)Turn off the MSM. 90%. Of it is owned by the oligarchs.
We have to take care of each other here on this site.
Buddyzbuddy
(2,801 posts)When I first signed on to DU following the last Presidential election I got into a passionate discussion with another member here that thought it was their job to throttle down my hope for the future. I understood their feelings of hopelessness and I certainly was not of good cheer.
But I explained that I grew up on hope and encourage that for everybody else. When growing up like I did, hope was what kept me going. I know for a fact that others had it much worse but they too clinged to hope.
Hope doesn't imply that you will do nothing but rather, is a motivator to keep moving forward, to use your struggle to become stronger and more resilient. Hope is aspirational and should be encouraged.
Initech
(109,077 posts)That's pretty fucking low. But my hockey team on the other hand is in the playoffs for the first time in 8 years *AND* made it past the 1st round. If there's hope for them there's hope for us!
I love that all these small regional elections keep flipping. It's definitely a side that the tide is starting to turn from the Rupert Murdoch's red poison. We'll get through the shithead.
angrychair
(12,434 posts)And I am well aware I have a reputation for "doom and gloom" posting for some here but honestly that isn't my objective. I'm really trying to highlight things that not many normal people are aware is happening. I mean the complete lack of awareness of the average American as to what is happening in our country is shocking.
Let's take the Epstein Files as an example. It's pretty much fallen off the radar as far as American MSM is concerned. I find this incredibly disturbing. I also know that if everything were the same and a Democratic president was mentioned over a million times and it was a Democratic appointed AG refusing to release the remaining 3.4 million files, that they would have already been impeached.
Yea, I get it, every bit of that is "doom and gloom" but I didn't create the situation, I'm just talking about it.
Yes, there are people out there trying to bring this all to light and keep attention on it. Literally working day and night to bring these people to justice. As someone that was sexually assaulted by two different people as a child I find this all incredibly triggering so it's hard to be objective about it.
It's so maddening. If it were a Democrat people would be burning down buildings but because it's a Republican it seems like everyone is standing around kicking rocks and mumbling and shrugging their shoulders like there is nothing that can be done.
I'm sorry, I know it's not a positive posting and yes, there is absolutely people working very hard to release the files and genuinely want to hold people accountable for what is in those files.
The lack of urgency or resolve in some is heartbreaking though, especially because I at least have an idea of what those poor people experienced. Hopefully those working to get their release eventually get them released to the public and hopefully we never let something like this ever happen again.
pat_k
(13,759 posts)Heartbreaking and horrifying things are happening so it is impossible not to "doom" post.
For me, though, finding ways to keep hope alive; to keep looking for the wins, to keep finding little things I can actually DO that could make a difference, is both a matter of self-preservation -- at least preservation of my own sanity -- and a matter of saying "f-u" to the trumpublicans; a matter of saying "I WILL NOT ALLOW YOUR FIREHOSE OF HORRORS AND HEARTBREAK CRUSH ME INTO HOPELESS IMMOBILITY!
And if one of my fellow travelers in resistance is despairing, I'm gonna take my shot at injecting hope because I KNOW that if we lose heart in this; if we allow these fucks -- these people who are hellbent on corrupting shared vales and destroying hard won progress -- to sap enough of us of energy with their onslaught, we won't have the collective will, collective energy, and and collective creativity to send them all to the dustbin of history!
So, my personal "keep hope alive" project is a critical part of "doing my little bit of good."
I tried to put suggestions in my OP that help me stay on track-- questions I ask myself, things I try to consider. I hope some of these suggestions help others too (see, there it is again, hope, it's all I've got).
That said, it is impossible to be human and not fall into despair sometimes at what we are up against.
And that is why we need each other. It is impossible to keep hope alive in isolation. It is far from enough, but I make a point of connecting with people who are DOING SOMETHING. Action, and seeing others in action, breeds hope, and hope breeds action. A delightful and essential virtuous cycle. Just making sure I am in a few zoom or in-person meetings with good people every month gives me a real, tangible, sense of the level of shared outrage that is sparking ACTION.
That is one way I make sure there are more examples of people in my "world" who are DOING SOMETHING than people who are "standing around kicking rocks."
Yeah, sure, perhaps there are more people "kicking rocks" than not in the grand scheme of things, and yes, if true, that is heartbreaking. But I know that I can choose to create my personal little piece of the world. As long as I make a conscious effort to keep moving, keep working to inspire others, I know I'm helping to change that balance. And I know how critical it is to do so. And if enough others change that balance a little bit too, I know we will be unstoppable.
When I talk about doing "little bits of good" (as in the Mandela quote) I know how small my "bits" are, and sometimes feel like I'm "doing nothing," but by just going about daily my business, having little conservations, I feel I've accomplished some worthwhile things.
One little story. I'm an old fart who was seriously burnt out with tech consulting so I started a little dog walking business. One of my clients is a millennial -- probably late 20's early 30's but these days everyone under 45 looks like a kid to me. Anyway, when anybody asks "how are you," I usually answer something like "fine," except for the whole world gone mad thing. If the response is puzzlement, I follow up a "you know, insane budget for ICE passed" or "...criminal attack on Iran" or whatever is most salient to me at that moment.) Anyway, I've ended up having great conversations with all my clients at one time or another. I know which ones sort of pull back from "politics talk" and I've felt out the ones that clearly are looking to vent, or are despairing. So, back to my millennial, I ended up getting a meal with her. She was so demoralized with debt, life, and the fact that "everyone" her age was "doing nothing" and that she was "doing nothing" because she was just so damn depressed and heartbroken with it all. We had a great lunch. Ended up talking hours. I felt pretty good because she seemed to walk away with more hope and some practical ideas I thought she might actually follow up on.
The next day, she called and asked if she gathered up some of her friends, would I be willing to meet with them. She wanted them to get the injection of hope too. I was incredibly surprised, but told her I would be delighted.
And so she gathered up a few incredibly cynical, stressed, hopeless millennial friends and we had a meet and drinks. I'm not sure how successful I was in raising spirits and inspiring action, but I walked away feeling pretty good about that experience too.
And in subsequent conversations with that client, I've gotten bits of news that confirmed my sense that I'd "done a bit of good." What started as a little "how are you" exchange turned into something. A person who was feeling completely hopeless and immobilized herself -- hopelessness that was compounded by the idea of how hopeless and immobilized "everyone my age is" had found some hope, was finding her way to being more active, and had friends doing the same.
How many people did I possibly effect? I don't know. One for sure, my client, and perhaps four or five of her friends. Not much in the grand scheme of things, but I choose to believe the activating effects of hope spread faster than despair because connecting and doing is rewarding in a very deep way. And it is productive. As my partner Dusty (RIP) used to say, "We don't need a movement, more of us just need to MOVE."
Sorry this is so long, but I wanted to convey a several things. To summarize:
1. "Doom" posting is unavoidable when terrible things are happening, so no need to apologize.
2. Despair saps energy in a way that crushes the will to act to do something about those terrible things.
3. In light of 1 and 2, if we want to change things for the better, it is CRITICAL to develop, and convey, a realistic, clear-eyed view of the terrible things happening while simultaneously finding as many ways as we can possibly come up with to keep hope and action alive in ourselves, and to figure out ways to help others do the same.
4. Against the onslaught of horrors and heartbreaks, it takes serious intention and effort to find ways to keep hope alive in ourselves, and serious intention and effort to develop habits that enable us to sustain a positive feedback loop of hope and action for the long haul. And if we are to successfully send them to the dust bin of history, we MUST stay in this for the LONG HAUL.
5. It takes serious effort intention and effort to find ways to counter despair and inspire hope in others. And in an infinitely interconnected social media environment, that includes recognizing that WHAT WE POST MATTERS. A LOT. I tried to include some of the "tips" that work for me on this front in the OP. For example, avoiding over-generalizations, avoiding pronouncements that trumpublicans are somehow all powerful or unstoppable, avoiding pronouncements that people are powerless against the power of vast wealth (all of which are simply NOT TURE), spreading the word about successes, posting "calls to action" or other concrete steps a person could do RIGHT NOW that can make a difference, asking ourselves questions before we post, and so on.
6. It is critical to understand how essential hope and action are to our collective chances of transforming this nation for the better . I think when someone really "gets" how essential that is, it can motivate them to put in the required effort.
For a little list of my personal "go tos" for keeping my own hope alive and identifying specific acts of resistance I can do or efforts I can support, see this post: Please, DO NOT fall victim to immobilizing hopelessness. If you do, you are doing exactly what their firehose of shit intends.
I'll close with a personal note. My heart breaks to hear you were a victim of abuse. I imagine the deep rage you feel at the failure to hold perpetrators -- perpetrators that ARE NAMED in documents held by law enforcement agencies -- is overwhelming. My mother was a long time victim of abuse as a small child (an uncle who lived with her family for a period and a janitor at her Catholic school). I struggle with incredible shame that is conveyed by some sort of "osmosis" between mother and child, so I think I have an inkling of the kind of pain survivors must well ... survive. It may not help, but my heart goes out to you.
calimary
(90,551 posts)DAYUM thats good!
Sure spells it out. Short n sweet. In plain English.
And best of all, it happens to be true.
Hope is the life's blood of resistance. Im gonna remember this one.
pat_k
(13,759 posts)And yes, It is both memorable and absolutely true!!
https://www.youtube.com/@Tad.Stoermer
Jack Valentino
(5,203 posts)(and Adolf Hitler's, for that matter..)
hopefully that was not ambiguous in any way....
c-rational
(3,220 posts)malaise
(297,502 posts)Rec
pat_k
(13,759 posts)A special thanks since it was your post that sort of kicked off my thought process.
Sometimes I feel a little preachy, but glad to hear that, at least for you, it didn't come off that way.
malaise
(297,502 posts)If anyone cares. The US media ignore the illegality and the war crimes. They are as bad as state owned media.
On the other hand, you are correct - millions of people in the US and elsewhere do are.