General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsScientists invented a fake disease. AI told people it was real
The condition doesnt appear in the standard medical literature because it doesnt exist. Its the invention of a team led by Almira Osmanovic Thunström, a medical researcher at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden, who dreamt up the skin condition and then uploaded two fake studies about it to a preprint server in early 2024. Osmanovic Thunström carried out this unusual experiment to test whether large language models (LLMs) would swallow the misinformation and then spit it out as reputable health advice. I wanted to see if I can create a medical condition that did not exist in the database, she says.
The problem was that the experiment worked too well. Within weeks of her uploading information about the condition, attributed to a fictional author, major artificial-intelligence systems began repeating the invented condition as if it were real.
Even more troublingly, other researchers say, the fake papers were then cited in peer-reviewed literature. Osmanovic Thunström says this suggests that some researchers are relying on AI-generated references without reading the underlying papers.
Bixonimania didnt exist before 15 March 2024, when two blog posts about it appeared on the website Medium. Then, on 26 April and 6 May that year, two preprints about the condition popped up on the academic social network SciProfiles (see https://doi.org/qzm5 and https://doi.org/qzm4). The lead author was a phoney researcher named Lazljiv Izgubljenovic, whose photograph was created with AI.
...
If that wasnt sufficient to raise suspicions, Osmanovic Thunström planted many clues in the preprints to alert readers that the work was fake. Izgubljenovic works at a non-existent university called Asteria Horizon University in the equally fake Nova City, California. One papers acknowledgements thank Professor Maria Bohm at The Starfleet Academy for her kindness and generosity in contributing with her knowledge and her lab onboard the USS Enterprise. Both papers say they were funded by the Professor Sideshow Bob Foundation for its work in advanced trickery. This works is a part of a larger funding initiative from the University of Fellowship of the Ring and the Galactic Triad.
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-01100-y
(via Tom Levenson's Inverse Square substack)
Delphinus
(12,527 posts)This is freaking worrisome.
kerouac2
(1,501 posts)Fake news, Trump already said that Hydroxychloroquine will cure it in less than a week.
RFK Jr. also said you can do coke off a toilet seat. It won't cure Bixonimania, but he said you can still do it just for fun.
OldBaldy1701E
(11,212 posts)Anyone can create anything that looks good on the Internet.
You accept any and all of it with a truckload of salt!
It is just too easy to look professional and intelligent on the internet.
Ask all of those scammers....
WhiskeyGrinder
(26,983 posts)machine.
OC375
(1,019 posts)the power of the tools,
But all the knowledge in the world
is of no use to fools."
--Don Henley, Long Road Out Of Eden
Swede
(39,591 posts)
rpannier
(24,932 posts)rich in vitamins will prevent us from catching this lethal illness
WinstonSmith4740
(3,441 posts)That was literally my first thought, seeing as how fake research seems to be his hot spot. His whole autism thing is based on it. I'm sure he's able to recognize this made up condition in kids he sees in the airport. From behind.
And as a side note...I know our regular family here knows this, but our MAGA lurkers need to hear this...AUTISM IS NOT A DISEASE!!! It does not need to be "cured"! Some of the most brilliant minds in history have been on the spectrum. People need to get over their pre-conceived prejudices.
William Seger
(12,468 posts)The results were completely predictable, including the cites.
Scrivener7
(59,641 posts)hvn_nbr_2
(6,800 posts)"But the AI won't let us sew him back up until we remove his liver."
WestMichRad
(3,284 posts)JohnnyRingo
(20,893 posts)Life will be a "choose your own reality" society. We will believe whatever fits our preconceptions. No one will be right, no one will be wrong.
This is the tech world the Unibomber warned us of.
hvn_nbr_2
(6,800 posts)MAGA epistemology: If they want to believe it, it's true. If they don't want to believe it, it's fake news.
FakeNoose
(41,771 posts)It just seems bizarre, but I'm sure there are Americans who go to their doctors and tell them they NEED THIS DRUG because they have this non-existent malady. What do the doctors do? They can't talk their patients out of it, so they write a scrip for a harmless "sugar pill" that has a big pharma-sounding name.
TheRickles
(3,414 posts)AI Overview
Based on the search results, it appears the query may have contained a typo, and the intended topic is Balanitis Xerotica Obliterans (BXO), a chronic skin condition affecting the genitalia.
So that's at least a tiny bit reassuring, apart from all the other scary sh@t.
Liberal In Texas
(16,290 posts)that any fake just false information might be used to treat actual patients.
Good grief ... From this "scientific paper."
Funding
This study was fully funded by Austeria Horizon University, in particular the Professor Sideshow Bob Foundation for its work in advanced trickery. This works is a part of a larger funding initiative from the University of Fellowship of the Ring and the Galactic Triad with the funding number 99942-666
Acknowledgments
Much thanks to the Department of Machine Evolution and Human Antics at the Austeria Horizon University and in particular Dr Dinesh Chugtai and Dr Bertram Gilfoyle for their excellent work in audience stimulation for their support and influence on this paper.
Ms. Toad
(38,680 posts)With false information.
Given what we know about LLMs, I think they reached the wrong conclusion.
Osmanovic Thunström had reservations while developing her experiment; she worried about the risks of seeding a fake illness into the scientific literature. So she contacted an ethics adviser to assess concerns about the work, and picked a comparatively low-stakes condition to limit the impact. I wanted to make sure that were not creating more harm than good through demonstrating it in this way, she says.
Icanthinkformyself
(394 posts)The pharmaceutical industry has been creating medications for fake illnesses for decades. They have people on staff at the research centers whose job it is to take minor every day symptoms for minor issues, make them appear to be life threatening and the company just so happens to have the 'medication' for it. Just another Vulture Capitalist scam that make the rich richer. Ain't America great! Why, anyone can be rich. The more you ignore the crimes committed by the companies you're invested in and own the more wealth you can amass. The more wealth you amass the more crimes you can get away with. There's not one rich person who is in jail because of the pedophilia they engaged in with Epstein and the Convicted Felon. Not one. Tell me I'm wrong and how.
ColoringFool
(748 posts)And she's very rich.
BeneteauBum
(543 posts)Just like the DU post several days ago where students are using AI to create classroom dialogue. AI is generating a generation of morons who cant think for themselves. Thats frightening
Peace ☮️
ColoringFool
(748 posts)Scientific "reports," too.