Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

bigtree

(93,936 posts)
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 10:47 PM 13 hrs ago

Trump: 'Attack so successful,' it botched the objective.

Jonathan Karl @jonkarl
Pres Trump told me tonight the US had identified possible candidates to take over Iran, but they were killed in the initial attack.

"The attack was so successful it knocked out most of the candidates," Trump told me. "It's not going to be anybody that we were thinking of because they are all dead. Second or third place is dead."


9:40 PM · Mar 1, 2026

...this is from an interview Jonathan Karl (ABC News) conducted with Trump tonight.

watch:






king of Scottsdale @blackgordongeck 4m
So you took out the leader to handpick a new regime, but you actually killed the regime you picked?

Failed operation. Failed presidency.



Politics Sloth (#1 reply guy) @SockDemFan 12m
“The attack went so well that it ended the only plans we had for regime change”

There is no backup plan…


Alexander Hamilton's Tears @Hamiltonstears
To review the bidding, Trump still has not articulated any plan for how he will accomplish regime change in Iran, but the inklings of the plan he sort of had were to somehow elevate (via airstrikes?) one of a few selected Iranian leaders (but not others) except they were all killed in the strike that killed Iran's leader.

Arthurz @ArthurzKV
So Trump had candidates for Iran's next leader but they all got killed in the strike—is this admitting the regime-change operation was improvised or just world-class timing?
24 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Trump: 'Attack so successful,' it botched the objective. (Original Post) bigtree 13 hrs ago OP
Iran will be another failed state JBTaurus83 13 hrs ago #1
I recently read that Iran's government is actually so 'decentralized' Jack Valentino 13 hrs ago #2
they control the population with small arms and other simple brutality bigtree 13 hrs ago #5
Trump's hopes of 'regime change' seem dependent on the Iranian citizens themselves, Jack Valentino 13 hrs ago #7
in my view bigtree 12 hrs ago #11
Maybe someone should inform him about the history of Russia's invasion of Afghanistan--- Jack Valentino 12 hrs ago #13
It reminds me H2O Man 10 hrs ago #19
good analogy bigtree 3 hrs ago #21
Peculiar definition of "success" unblock 13 hrs ago #3
The Failure of "Success". ForeGoneLegsBirne 10 hrs ago #18
The stupid is strong in that one. Lifeafter70 13 hrs ago #4
How many "sucker and loser" US have thomski64 13 hrs ago #6
This IS the 'Epstein files war'..... nt Jack Valentino 12 hrs ago #9
He is playing second fiddle and fails to realize it. David__77 12 hrs ago #8
Criminal Moron in Charge. OAITW r.2.0 12 hrs ago #10
The plan just seems to be Gaza on a bigger scale Johonny 12 hrs ago #12
yep bigtree 1 hr ago #23
if this was a Dem president the MSM would be SCREAMING about this Skittles 11 hrs ago #14
I think it's objective is being misunderstood questionseverything 11 hrs ago #15
insane to say out loud bigtree 2 hrs ago #22
What a ham-fisted hack BaronChocula 11 hrs ago #16
Mulligan? czarjak 10 hrs ago #17
shell game bigtree 4 min ago #24
99% of those who read this misunderstand it. WarGamer 9 hrs ago #20

Jack Valentino

(4,822 posts)
2. I recently read that Iran's government is actually so 'decentralized'
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 10:58 PM
13 hrs ago

that it is likely impossible to decapitate it through bombing alone,
even if we have in fact now killed off its former leadership---

and of course, there has never been a single instance in world history
of bringing 'regime change' through bombing alone,

without a 'ground invasion'.....


bigtree

(93,936 posts)
5. they control the population with small arms and other simple brutality
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 11:05 PM
13 hrs ago

...mostly unaffected by the bombs.

Guard still intact; some 600k between police and the military in a nation of 90 million.

Iranians haven't persisted because they've outright won every war waged against them. They persist because they're good at oulasting their opponents.

Jack Valentino

(4,822 posts)
7. Trump's hopes of 'regime change' seem dependent on the Iranian citizens themselves,
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 11:18 PM
13 hrs ago

who are mostly unarmed and thus helpless against their repressive government....


If they are actually serious about it, they would need to be planning to make large air-drops of small arms and ammunition to the Iranian civilians, at the very least.... but I've never heard such a thing mentioned, even in theory, by ANYONE....


bigtree

(93,936 posts)
11. in my view
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 11:29 PM
12 hrs ago

....his talk of regime change and having Iranians do it themselves is just his way of disowning the consequences of his destabilizing warring.

But you're absolutely right that he's made no effort to even organize a resistance, much less protect them, and that it would take a ground invasion of hundreds of thousands of troops to control any of that.

It's a canard, and he's very possibly just talking out of his ass here, as is usual for him.

Republicans only know how to break things. They don't know how to fix and build anything other than their own bank accounts.

Jack Valentino

(4,822 posts)
13. Maybe someone should inform him about the history of Russia's invasion of Afghanistan---
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 11:45 PM
12 hrs ago

and how the U.S. responded to it--- arming the Afghans--


but I seriously doubt that most people in his administration have any knowledge about that---
they probably all flunked U.S. history as HE clearly did
(unless his father paid off some teachers to 'pass' him!)

Yeah, he was actually an adult during that time---
but probably paying more attention to whom he could swindle or FUCK,
not paying any attention to current events at the time---

or he's too mentally incapacitated to have retained any memories about it by now....

Google:
During a July 4, 2019 "Salute to America" speech, President Donald Trump incorrectly claimed the Continental Army "took over the airports" during the 18th-century Revolutionary War. The comment, which suggested air travel existed in the 1700's, was attributed to teleprompter failure in heavy rain. The widely mocked, historical error occurred during a speech highlighting Revolutionary war history.





H2O Man

(78,915 posts)
19. It reminds me
Mon Mar 2, 2026, 01:49 AM
10 hrs ago

of the delusion that Cubans would rise up against Castro when rebels showed up at the Bay of Pigs. While some may have bought that, the guys selling it knew it was bullshit.

bigtree

(93,936 posts)
21. good analogy
Mon Mar 2, 2026, 08:52 AM
3 hrs ago

...it should have forever been cemented in U.S. foreign policy when 17 of Bush's intel agencies concluded in their Natl. Security assessment that his Iraq misadventure, with it's night raids and carpet-bombing was creating more terrorists than the military was able to put down.

I do wonder if the folks who have that institutional and operation memory are still around, or have any influence with this administraton's producers and writers.



Several thousand fighters landed at the Bay of Pigs, or Playa Giron, a small beach in south-eastern Cuba. They soon ran out of ammunition and without American back-up, their mission failed.

Gregorio Moreira was a member of the local communist defence militia. He spoke to Witness about the battle for control of Cuba.

https://www.bbc.com/news/av/magazine-36058705

thomski64

(881 posts)
6. How many "sucker and loser" US have
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 11:07 PM
13 hrs ago

perished to deflect from the Trump/Netanyahu EPSTEIN FILES??

Johonny

(25,940 posts)
12. The plan just seems to be Gaza on a bigger scale
Sun Mar 1, 2026, 11:34 PM
12 hrs ago

Kills lots and lots and not really care about what comes next because they don't really want a next.

bigtree

(93,936 posts)
23. yep
Mon Mar 2, 2026, 11:01 AM
1 hr ago
Sen. Bernie Sanders @SenSanders 14h
Israel & Saudi Arabia pushed the U.S. to attack Iran.

Netanyahu killed 72,000 people in Gaza, mostly women & children.

Saudi Arabia is a brutal dictatorship that allows no opposition.

These are the leaders who want to bring “freedom” to Iran?

Does anyone really believe that?

questionseverything

(11,721 posts)
15. I think it's objective is being misunderstood
Mon Mar 2, 2026, 12:56 AM
11 hrs ago

He was happy 😊 we got the head dude and his line of succession

bigtree

(93,936 posts)
22. insane to say out loud
Mon Mar 2, 2026, 09:36 AM
2 hrs ago
Jared Holt @jaredlholt
Insane to say out loud, into a microphone, that you had an idea for what would come next but you accidentally killed too many people


bigtree

(93,936 posts)
24. shell game
Mon Mar 2, 2026, 12:15 PM
4 min ago
Travis Akers @travisakers 3h
Hegseth: This is not a regime change war.

Trump: We already had people in mind to replace the Supreme Leader.

They have absolutely no idea what they’re doing. A complete circus that has already cost Americans their lives.


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump: 'Attack so success...