General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Supreme Court will decide if marijuana users may be barred from owning guns
On March 2, the justices will hear their second major Second Amendment case of the Supreme Courts current term. United States v. Hemani asks whether Congress may make it a crime for an unlawful user of marijuana to possess a gun.
If you are a lawyer trying to guess how the Court will rule in this case, good luck with that. The Courts Second Amendment precedents are as unsalvageable as they are confusing. At least in theory, they require judges to ask whether a modern-day gun law is sufficiently similar to gun laws from more than 200 years ago. But the rules appear to shift depending on whether a majority of the justices actually think a particular gun law is a good idea.
That said, there is a sensible way that the Court could resolve the Hemani case without having to wade into this historical morass. Again, the federal law at issue in Hemani bars gun possession by an unlawful user of any controlled substance such as marijuana. But what does it mean to be an unlawful user of marijuana?
If someone takes a bong hit in college, decides that they dont like weed, and never gets high again, are they forever barred from owning a gun? What about a person who shares a joint with her cousins every year on Thanksgiving, but otherwise doesnt smoke? And if this law doesnt permanently bar one-time marijuana users from having a gun, when does the bar end? If someone takes a single puff at a party in February, do they get their gun rights back in March? In November? And what about people who use marijuana more than occasionally? If someone takes a weed gummy a couple times a month to help them sleep, are they barred from owning a gun? What about someone who hits a vape pen on every other Saturday?
https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/supreme-court-decide-marijuana-users-114500181.html
NewHendoLib
(61,754 posts)What a slippery, subjective slope!
ProfessorGAC
(76,348 posts)I've seen way more mean drunks than nean pot users.
My 2nd question is, what about those using it in states where it's legal? There is zero unlawful activity in that case.
bucolic_frolic
(54,721 posts)Why would weed be any different from alcohol, prescription medicines, a high carb diet? There is nothing in 2A that mentions substances.
rampartd
(4,435 posts)unless rfk heroine musks ketamine. snorting coke off toilet seat is ok.
rollin74
(2,285 posts)this should be interesting
John Farmer
(390 posts)maxsolomon
(38,481 posts)Read it and weep:
ATF Form 4473 question f:
Warning: The use or possession of marijuana remains unlawful under Federal law regardless of whether it has been legalized or decriminalized for medicinal or recreational purposes in the state where you reside.
If 50 million Gunners lose their firearms for lying on Question F, I'll just laugh and laugh. And then go smoke a bowl.
Intractable
(1,842 posts)Peace. Love. Forgiveness.
Unless it's video games. Then, I become a vicious killer.
About 40 years ago I was playing a video game wiht a friend. It involved killing alien invaders.
We got seriously stoned. I was so into playing the game, my friend caught me screaming stuff at the TV including, "Die, you alien scum. I'll kill you all!"