Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

kentuck

(114,945 posts)
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 12:03 PM Sunday

How real is the Trump/MAGA split?

Is it just Marjorie or is there serious division within the Trump MAGA Party?

The latest polls show him at 36-37% favorable. That is not good. That spells disaster in the midterms if that does not change.

Nobody should be jumping for joy that the MAGA base is finally seeing the light. They have done too much damage to simply forget. They were like monkeys climbing the tree - the higher they got, the more they showed their asses.

Forgive and forget? That will not be an easy task for the rest of America.

21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
How real is the Trump/MAGA split? (Original Post) kentuck Sunday OP
It's bullshit. dalton99a Sunday #1
The Epstein files are a big deal to QAnon idiots who believe in a pedophile cult who sex traffic children LetMyPeopleVote Sunday #2
Recommended H2O Man Sunday #3
It's very large right now womanofthehills 14 hrs ago #21
A tool to the politicians, but serious to the base leftstreet Sunday #4
I think there are real cracks Boo1 Sunday #5
Could be more about putting Vance into power. jmbar2 Sunday #6
That's not how the line of succession works Polybius Sunday #9
Thanks for the clarification jmbar2 Sunday #10
Query mr715 Sunday #11
No. The selected VP would advance to be President... Wounded Bear Sunday #13
I understand this, mr715 Sunday #14
Pretty sure they would have to nominate someone else... Wounded Bear Sunday #15
Teddy Roosevelt? eShirl Yesterday #17
Ah yes. My bad. Good catch...nt Wounded Bear Yesterday #18
Yes Polybius Yesterday #16
Not true Shrek Yesterday #19
You misunderstood my response Polybius 15 hrs ago #20
none of these numbers (either in OP or down string) in any way account stopdiggin Sunday #7
Old maga (Trump I) is being displaced by new maga (Trump II) Maru Kitteh Sunday #8
That's a lot of bros! And I think you are right. thought crime Sunday #12

LetMyPeopleVote

(172,762 posts)
2. The Epstein files are a big deal to QAnon idiots who believe in a pedophile cult who sex traffic children
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 12:07 PM
Sunday

A good percentage of trump supporters are QAnon idiots and Epstein is a big deal to these nutcases.



A lot of you may be mystified as to why DOJ’s withholding of the Epstein files so upsets Trump’s base.

It’s very simple.

👉 Roughly a third of MAGA Republicans qualify as QAnon believers.

👉 QAnon teaches that government, media, and financial elites are Satanists who sex-traffic children.



H2O Man

(78,289 posts)
3. Recommended
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 12:10 PM
Sunday

There is a split. And it does not have to be large to effect the outcome of elections.

womanofthehills

(10,616 posts)
21. It's very large right now
Mon Nov 17, 2025, 09:07 PM
14 hrs ago

Conservative Candace Owens podcast was number one in the world this week - she overtook Rogan.

In the past, she wanted Trump to pick her as his VP and now she hates his guts. She told her tens of millions of listeners, she apologizes for telling them to vote for Trump.

The divide is on America First - anti genocide- no tax dollars for foreign wars, plus release Epstein stuff which is getting more interesting with the release of Epstein emails linking him to Israeli intelligence.

Group one - against Trump’s policies

Candace, Tucker, MTG, Gaetz, Alex Jones, Fuentes, Dave Smith, Thomas Massie, Rand Paul, Ian Carroll, etc

Group two - with Trump
Rubio, Josh Hawley, Randy Fine, Ted Cruz, Mark Levin, Laura Loomer, Lindsay Graham, Ron de Santos, etc

Megan Kelley is playing in the middle as is Bannon - although both came out against Israel’s bombings.

Over on X - I see most Republicans liking Group one - saying Trump
has not fulfilled one promise he made. Lots of Republican I’ m sorry I voted for him posts.

Boo1

(43 posts)
5. I think there are real cracks
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 12:14 PM
Sunday

The Epstein file albatross.
Inflation
Affordability
Endless wars




Those are four points where he is failing.

There has been years of hero worship from this group, but there is clear peeling off happening at the margins if you watch. He's a lame duck, and this is going to continue to erode. That's a big part of why he keeps mentioning 2028. He wants to keep his base on the hook as long as he can.

jmbar2

(7,462 posts)
6. Could be more about putting Vance into power.
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 12:27 PM
Sunday

If they can push him out before the next elections and put in Vance, that moves Maga mike into the VP slot. These are the Christian nationalists and they are itching to take over.

They know that Trump is done.

Folks like Frank Schaeffer think that a Vance regime will make us all wish Trump were still around.

Polybius

(21,185 posts)
9. That's not how the line of succession works
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 09:37 PM
Sunday

If Trump is impeached and convicted, it's true that Vance becomes President. However, Mike Johnson doesn't automatically become VP. Vance selects someone (could be anyone, so long as they are 35 and natural born), and that person has to be confirmed by the House and Senate.

mr715

(2,295 posts)
11. Query
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 09:56 PM
Sunday

What would happen if an elevated VP, who had appointed a new VP were to die. Would the Speaker then be elevated to President?

Wounded Bear

(63,526 posts)
13. No. The selected VP would advance to be President...
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 10:16 PM
Sunday

See: Gerald Ford, the only president who was not elected.

Nixon's VP, Spiro Agnew resigned due to scandal. Ford was nominated by Nixon and approved by Congress and became the VP. When Nixon resigned because of Watergate, Ford became President.

I believe that no VP who rose to be President because the Pres was forced out or assasinated has been re-elected to be Pres. The only VP who stepped up after gaining the Presidency was Truman, who became Pres in 45 when FDR died, and then was elected to another term in 48.

mr715

(2,295 posts)
14. I understand this,
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 10:34 PM
Sunday

I am saying if the elevated VP (Pres) selected a VP, but that VP were not confirmed by Congress.

Wounded Bear

(63,526 posts)
15. Pretty sure they would have to nominate someone else...
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 10:55 PM
Sunday

The Speaker would only become president if both the Pres and the VP were killed/disabled at the same time.

eShirl

(19,948 posts)
17. Teddy Roosevelt?
Mon Nov 17, 2025, 05:35 AM
Yesterday
I believe that no VP who rose to be President because the Pres was forced out or assasinated has been re-elected to be Pres.

Polybius

(21,185 posts)
16. Yes
Mon Nov 17, 2025, 05:27 AM
Yesterday

In that case, Johnson becomes President. Next in line is the President Pro Tempore, which is Chuck Grassley.

Shrek

(4,373 posts)
19. Not true
Mon Nov 17, 2025, 10:48 AM
Yesterday

When Nixon resigned it was VP Gerald Ford, not the Speaker of the House, who became President.

Polybius

(21,185 posts)
20. You misunderstood my response
Mon Nov 17, 2025, 08:34 PM
15 hrs ago

The poster asked what would happen if both Trump and Vance were unable to serve. In that case, it's Johnson.

stopdiggin

(14,723 posts)
7. none of these numbers (either in OP or down string) in any way account
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 12:35 PM
Sunday

for the 24 election. Further Trump's 'favorability' ratings have never been significantly higher than the 37% the OP lists. How real is the Trump/MAGA split - is almost entirely dependent on how one defines MAGA. The actual 'cult' numbers have always been fairly low. The number of people that went out and voted for Trump on the other hand ... And those two are quite obviously NOT the same thing.

(and nor is Q-Anon)

Maru Kitteh

(31,026 posts)
8. Old maga (Trump I) is being displaced by new maga (Trump II)
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 08:40 PM
Sunday

There is overlap to be sure, but I look for Trump himself and other new maga to start painting the old coalition as a bunch of slightly simple to outright nutz group of cranks, women, and others suspected of being a little soft in the head.

Old maga is Q-anon, low-information, poorly educated. Some were veterans of the Tea Party, some were dittohead types but mostly they were the great unwashed masses. They can name Kardashians and quarterbacks and ™Real Housewives but not a single Speaker of the House or the three branches of government.

New maga is basically the coalition of bros. Tech bros, manosphere bros, crypto bros, incel bros, etc. If you are part of a group that is nearly exclusively white and male (younger is better but rich will do) new maga is here to help you swing your dick like the boss you were entitled to be at your birth.

thought crime

(1,014 posts)
12. That's a lot of bros! And I think you are right.
Sun Nov 16, 2025, 10:11 PM
Sunday

Old maga is still being dragged along though.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»How real is the Trump/MAG...