Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

pat_k

(12,532 posts)
Thu Nov 13, 2025, 09:05 PM Nov 13

Even in MAGA country, fiercely standing up against extremism wins!

At least it did in Ohio. School board candidates who had won waging their LGBTQ bathroom wars, lost big.

David Pepper focuses on important state and local happenings that also have lessons for anti-MAGA candidates everywhere.

From his substack, Lesson: People Don't Want Crazy on their School Boards

People may think DC or their state capital is crazy. Lost causes of squabbling and chaos and infighting. And maybe they’ve come to accept that, or think they can’t fix it.

But they’re not ready to have their local schools turn into that.

They know their local school, and they largely value their local school system as a stable anchor of their community. It’s far more personal.

And regardless of party affiliation, if they sense that an extremist risks turning their own school board into chaos—or they’ve seen that happen on their current school board—they act.

They protect.


The article goes on to the case study of Matt Wyatt for Talawanda school board (in Republican stronghold Butler county). It's a great example of how exposing and fighting back fiercely against the ACTUAL consequences of extremism works -- and works amazingly well.

David Pepper shares what Matt Wyatt wrote to him about his campaign. It's a great read. One of the highlights was what Matt did when he found out the crazy MAGA opponent posted pictures of bathroom doors at the school, a clear violation of privacy and policy. He got stills from the school's surveillance video and made a flyer. His opponent, fortuitously named "Tom" (Tom Heisler) became Peeping Tom Heisler.



The bullies, the bathroom obsessed, the book banners get away with it because voters simply don't know how extreme they are.

And candidates pull punches because they don't want "backlash" from voters they mistakenly think endorse the insanity.

But when a fierce opponent powerfully calls out the extremists, voters get how their own schools are being upended. When voters see the actual consequences -- how extreme the extremists are -- they reject it.

The case of Matt Wyatt is covered in the first 9 minutes of David Pepper and Lisa Senecal's Nov 13 discussion. And they cover a lot more ground. Here's a quick summary:

From about 9 to 19 min, David and Lisa have a great discussion of the frustration over the defection of the 5, where our focus needs to be as we move forward, the dynamics at work, points of our strength, and how things could play out.

From about 19:30 to 30 min, the Epstein emails and document drops, and the politics of it all from the perspective of members of the House and Senate who are getting very, very nervous about being branded part of the cover up when things explode -- and the growing belief that there is no way this is not going to explode.

From 30 to the end at 37, Trump is costing Trumpublicans so much, but they keep going back to the well. Vivek's troubles against great candidate, Amy Acton. In Ohio there is a revolt on the right against the party for having embraced him.
1 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Even in MAGA country, fiercely standing up against extremism wins! (Original Post) pat_k Nov 13 OP
Kick BlueWaveNeverEnd Nov 13 #1
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Even in MAGA country, fie...