General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAI slop tops Billboard and Spotify charts as synthetic music spreads
Three songs generated by artificial intelligence topped music charts this week, reaching the highest spots on Spotify and Billboard charts.
Walk My Walk and Livin on Borrowed Time by the outfit Breaking Rust topped Spotifys Viral 50 songs in the US, which documents the most viral tracks right now on a daily basis, according to the streaming service. A Dutch song, We Say No, No, No to an Asylum Center, an anti-migrant anthem by JW Broken Veteran that protests against the creation of new asylum centers, took the top position in Spotifys global version of the viral chart around the same time. Breaking Rust also appeared in the top five on the global chart.
You can kick rocks if you dont like how I talk, reads a lyric from Walk My Walk, a seeming double entendre challenging those opposed to AI-generated music.
Days after its ascent up the charts, the Dutch song disappeared from Spotify and YouTube, as did Broken Veterans other music. Spotify told the Dutch outlet NU.nl that the company had not removed the music, the owners of the song rights had. Broken Veteran told the outlet that he did not know why his music had disappeared and that he was investigating, hoping to return it soon.
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/nov/13/ai-music-spotify-billboard-charts
*******************************************************************************************
I have no words, just despair.
hlthe2b
(112,222 posts)Unless it is a live symphony or similar, I'm done with new releases. If it isn't damned AI, it is autotune or digital mixes of digital audio from performers who have never or will never interact with each other. That isn't music, IMO.
Coventina
(28,964 posts)I just saw Sombr on SNL and was really impressed.
He's only 20, but seems really talented.
hlthe2b
(112,222 posts)I saw his performance and was not unimpressed, but I'd bet money he uses autotune. If he does not and you can validate that, I will absolutely stand corrected. That said, I will never support an artist who does unless it is for mockery purposes. Yes, really. Today's performers have so many crutches that I don't apologize for not supporting them unless they manage to learn their instruments and/or write and/or sing their own compositions. At least learn some basics, and not rely on the teams of producers to make their music (voice) sound passable.
flvegan
(65,510 posts)my local news was talking about this and played a clip (of Walk My Walk). I wasn't paying attention and this horrific thing came on.
Now you damn clouds best get outta here!
Coventina
(28,964 posts)hlthe2b
(112,222 posts)(if any don't know the problem with that, well, just call the rest of us old and be done with it.
flvegan
(65,510 posts)highplainsdem
(59,089 posts)Fiendish Thingy
(21,603 posts)Theres already investigations into actual human artists (and their record companies) using bots to rack up plays and generate royalties and chart momentum.
TheBlackAdder
(29,870 posts)After about ten songs this AI crap starts to play. Youre vibing along and then realize Spotify is pulling a switcheroo.
You cant stop the shit, only slow it a little.
Scrivener7
(57,897 posts)for a podcast I love as it would cost me to get the podcast plus everything else on Spotify. Turns out, for my monthly $10 Spotify would pay the podcasters about .003 cents per listen, whereas Patreon gives the creators $8.50 from my $10.
I feel like I'm out of step with everyone bc I don't use Amazon, Facebook or Twitter, but I'm adding Spotify to the list.
Sadly, I listened to Walk the Walk on Youtube. I hate to say, I liked it. Won't listen again, though.
highplainsdem
(59,089 posts)have that fake country song appear popular and get headlines for free publicity.
Torchlight
(6,152 posts)by the end of the decade.
It's tough for me to think otherwise-- it's a very subtle but damnably broad, convenient and accessible tool which can be applied to just about any creative entertainment endeavor. I'm certainly not celebrating that in any way, but at this point I just don't see any practical alternatives in denying its use, whether in the open or behind the curtains.
Given today's musical climate, with a billion different subgenres and garage bands evolving into 'just me on my laptop', I'd guessed this industry would be the first to cave and welcome the exploitation.
bluesbassman
(20,354 posts)Not soon after we wont be the audience, itll be robots listening to robots.
Pat MacDonald of Timbuk 3 was wrong, I dont wear shades because the futures so bright, I wear them to hide my tears from whats happening.
Initech
(106,969 posts)LudwigPastorius
(13,843 posts)There is no "outfit", for fuck's sake.
There is just some guy feeding prompts to an AI.
KT2000
(21,833 posts)for the AI duets. This cannot be OK with them.
Oneironaut
(6,160 posts)This isnt art. Its a monstrosity of stolen music that takes a massive shit on artists.
hunter
(40,212 posts)It doesn't seem to exist in my universe.
Okay, I'm just messing around. I know what Spotify is and I deleted it from my internet a long time ago.
Most of my music is purchased on CDs from artists I know are real, some of it directly from artists I've seen live, in person.
I have a collection of LPs and cassettes from my youth too
These CDs get ripped to the music library on my computer for my own personal use. You can store quite a bit of music on a modern SD card to bring with you wherever you go.
AI generated music makes me sad. If AI is someone's only means of expressing themselves, how can they ever be certain it's their own expression, that they're not being led down the garden path by the AI?
The voices in my own head are a lot more real than anything AI might produce.
A truer expression of one's own self might be to simply publish the prompts that generated an AI song, story, image, or movie, and keep whatever slop the AI generates to yourself.
I've played with AI a bit and it has never taken me where I want to go.
Coventina
(28,964 posts)I buy almost all physical media myself.
I can count my digital downloads on my fingers.
ProfessorGAC
(75,298 posts)...it hit #1 on the digital purchases charts. 3,000 units sold at 99 cents each was all it took to reach #1 on that chart. $2,970 of sales. Kind of like winning a race with nobody else in it.
It didn't even list on any other Billboard chart.
I heard it on the Rick Beato video. Yikes, is it horrible!
The lyrics are terrible, the voice sounds fake, the mix is mushy.
Btw: Spotify shows 2.2 million people listened to it, but only 3,000 people bought it.
So, it reached "#1", but nobody really cares about it.