Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

dalton99a

(90,444 posts)
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 01:41 AM Sunday

Des Moines school superintendent claimed to be U.S. citizen when applying for the job

https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/education/2025/09/27/dmps-board-meeting-superintendent-ian-roberts-arrested-ice/86377063007/

Des Moines school board votes to put Superintendent Ian Roberts on leave after ICE arrest
Samantha Hernandez and Kate Kealey

Des Moines Public Schools has placed Superintendent Ian Roberts, 54, on administrative leave following his arrest and detention by ICE on Sept. 26 over accusations he is in the country illegally.

The Des Moines School Board voted unanimously to put Roberts on paid leave. Associate Superintendent Matt Smith is serving as interim superintendent.

The board called the special meeting after U.S. Immigration Customs Enforcement arrested Roberts on the morning of Sept. 26, accusing him of being in the United States illegally.

In May 2024, a court issued a "final order of removal" calling for the Guyana native's deportation, a spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security. Roberts was arrested as part of a "targeted enforcement operation, DHS said.

Des Moines school board Chair Jackie Norris said Roberts' arrest came as a shock to board members, who were not aware of any citizenship issues facing Roberts.

"Everything the district has on file indicates that Dr. Roberts affirmed that he was a citizen who was eligible to work in the school district," Norris said.

School officials and the Iowa Department of Education have both said Roberts indicated on forms he was an American citizen and had passed several background checks.

...


23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Des Moines school superintendent claimed to be U.S. citizen when applying for the job (Original Post) dalton99a Sunday OP
Affirmed? iemanja Sunday #1
Who knows what documents he used to pass the background checks dalton99a Sunday #2
Well, I last went through the job application process more than 16 years ago, but I never had to provide a birth Midwestern Democrat Sunday #3
It goes back further than that Retrograde Sunday #5
Did he fill out an I-9, dis they run him through E-verify bottomofthehill Sunday #4
They relied on a third party dalton99a Sunday #7
So much of this just does not add up. bottomofthehill Sunday #14
They missed that what else have they missed with other hires exboyfil Sunday #6
Guyana native's malaise Sunday #8
+1. The big question is the documentation he submitted for his I-9 form dalton99a Sunday #9
He's an arrogant idiot malaise Sunday #15
Who conducted the background check on Des Moines Superintendent Ian Roberts? What we know. MichMan Sunday #10
There's an attorney on X... SickOfTheOnePct Sunday #11
+1. Every allegation has receipts attached: dalton99a Sunday #16
He knew both name and DOB must match to correctly identify someone dalton99a Sunday #17
The question should be "Is he a good superintend? Ping Tung Sunday #12
Someone who lied about their citizenship... SickOfTheOnePct Sunday #13
A weapons charge? Conjuay Sunday #18
Most people don't n/t SickOfTheOnePct Monday #20
Sounds serious Torchlight Monday #23
The state of Iowa just revoked his superintendent certificate... SickOfTheOnePct Monday #19
+1. It was inevitable. He was a prominent public figure and an easy target for ICE dalton99a Monday #21
This story is a great example of the need to get all the facts before commenting or forming an opinion. BannonsLiver Monday #22

dalton99a

(90,444 posts)
2. Who knows what documents he used to pass the background checks
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 01:52 AM
Sunday

It is a fact that he came from Guyana, overstayed his student visa, and repeatedly tried to delay his deportation

His legal fight came to an end last year when an immigration judge under Biden issued the final order of removal

He clearly lied to the Des Moines school district about his status

3. Well, I last went through the job application process more than 16 years ago, but I never had to provide a birth
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 01:56 AM
Sunday

certificate for any job I applied for (just a Social Security Number) and I later found out that while the company led applicants to believe they would be subjected to a background check, they didn't actually do it except for a few positions (they do it now).

Retrograde

(11,289 posts)
5. It goes back further than that
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 04:04 AM
Sunday

when Mr. Retrograde went to work for a large company in the late 1980s he had to produce proof of citizenship - his passport sufficed. I had to do the same in 2000. So unless the school district hired this guy a long time ago he would have been subject to the same process: did he have the legal right to work in the US at the time? Note that that's different than actually being a US citizen, but whoever hired him was supposed to have kept a copy of the proof.

bottomofthehill

(9,267 posts)
4. Did he fill out an I-9, dis they run him through E-verify
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 03:18 AM
Sunday

He is in a school system. They should know who he is and what his employment status is.

dalton99a

(90,444 posts)
7. They relied on a third party
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 09:26 AM
Sunday
https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/education/2025/09/28/des-moines-public-schools-superintendent-background-check-ian-roberts/86375977007/

Did Roberts undergo a background check before hiring?

Yes, the district says.

"Employers, including DMPS, are required to verify employment eligibility for all employees," the district news release stated. "In this case, Dr. Roberts completed the I-9 employment eligibility verification form and submitted the required documentation."

The Des Moines School Board hired JG Consulting to conduct a search for the new DMPS superintendent, the same release states.

"The firm identified Dr. Roberts as a candidate," and a third party, Baker-Eubanks, conducted a "comprehensive background check," the release said.

What is an I-9?

An I-9 employment eligibility verification is used to "verify the identity and employment authorization of individuals hired for employment in the United States," according to the U.S. Citenzenship and Immigration Services website.

exboyfil

(18,300 posts)
6. They missed that what else have they missed with other hires
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 06:53 AM
Sunday

Wouldn't give me a.warm fuzzy if I was the parent of the student in the district.

malaise

(289,588 posts)
8. Guyana native's
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 09:30 AM
Sunday

Guyanese native or native of Guyana. Who writes these articles?
He lived in the US for decades and is yet another arrogant idiot who failed to regularize his status. Indeed he lied about his status.

dalton99a

(90,444 posts)
9. +1. The big question is the documentation he submitted for his I-9 form
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 09:58 AM
Sunday

not just in Iowa but in Pennsylvania and other states

(The school district knows - because they are required by law to keep it on file)

Employers must have a completed Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification, on file for each person on their payroll (or otherwise receiving remuneration) who is required to complete the form. Employers must also keep completed Forms I-9 for a certain amount of time after their employees stop working for them. Never mail Forms I-9 to USCIS or U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
https://www.uscis.gov/i-9-central/completing-form-i-9/retention-and-storage


malaise

(289,588 posts)
15. He's an arrogant idiot
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 11:34 AM
Sunday

He thought being an Olympian was enough - should have studied some history re American olympians let alone foreign ones. Get your effin papers in order.

MichMan

(16,012 posts)
10. Who conducted the background check on Des Moines Superintendent Ian Roberts? What we know.
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 10:44 AM
Sunday
Questions continue to emerge about how much Des Moines Public Schools officials did or didn't know about Superintendent Ian Roberts' background and immigration status.

"Employers, including DMPS, are required to verify employment eligibility for all employees," the district news release stated. "In this case, Dr. Roberts completed the I-9 employment eligibility verification form and submitted the required documentation."

The Des Moines School Board hired JG Consulting to conduct a search for the new DMPS superintendent, the same release states. "The firm identified Dr. Roberts as a candidate," and a third party, Baker-Eubanks, conducted a "comprehensive background check," the release said.

"We do not render an opinion on whether someone should be hired," said Cockerham in an interview with the Des Moines Register. "We give the report as we're hired to do. We reveal any criminal records that we find." The criminal background check does not include confirming whether someone can legally work in the United States. "That's not even a service that we offer," Cockerham said.


https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/general/who-conducted-the-background-check-on-des-moines-superintendent-ian-roberts-what-to-know/ar-AA1NsM1X?ocid=BingNewsSerp



SickOfTheOnePct

(8,673 posts)
11. There's an attorney on X...
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 11:10 AM
Sunday

...someone named Laura Powell, who apparently is making it her purpose in life to dig into Ian Roberts, and she is posting all sorts of documents (or people replying to her are) about the discrepancies in different stuff about him. One of the things is that different online resources show different years of birth...always the same month and day, but different years.

Someone posted a speeding ticket from last year that appears to belong to him, with a Maryland address, and then someone else posted a voter registration record showing that he is registered to vote in Maryland.

If all of this stuff is actually true, he'd probably be better off in Guyana than staying here and going to prison.

dalton99a

(90,444 posts)
16. +1. Every allegation has receipts attached:
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 12:39 PM
Sunday

From Laura Powell's X account:

Court records show Roberts’s birthdate as December 18, 1970. But his original Wikipedia entry, created by an account that nearly matches a handle Roberts uses, says he was born December 18, 1978. And records from athletic competitions list his DOB at December 18, 1973.

...

Roberts is quoted in 2020 referring to Guyana as his birthplace and saying that his father immigrated to the United States in the 1980s and his mother in the 2000s. But in a 2024 local news story, he claims he was born in Brooklyn and raised by a single mother. His Facebook lists two secondary schools in Guyana as alma maters.

...

Roberts’s LinkedIn lists a lot of universities, though notably, the degrees are absent. Elsewhere, he claims two master’s degrees and two doctorates, in addition to a bachelor’s. (I found some sources that claim he has a PhD, but I will presume these were honest errors.) It appears he does have a EdD from an online university. He also claims he did a postdoc at Harvard.

...

During the years that Roberts supposedly was earning numerous graduate degrees, he also claims to have been continuously employed, as a teacher for a few years, then as a school administrator for almost two decades. His LinkedIn indicates that he was moonlighting as an “Executive Leadership Coach/Chief Thought Partner” for a private company since 2020, while he was a superintendent for two difference school districts. (I am not going to bother to share all the bios that inflate his job titles to the point of lying.)

...

Roberts’s official bio from his current employer, Des Moines Public Schools, states, “While in the nation’s capital he was named the George Washington University’s 2013 Washington D.C. Principal of the Year.” I have searched and search and cannot find any record of this award. Nor can I find a record of George Washington University giving out a “Principal of the Year” award to anyone, ever. Roberts was a principal at Anacostia High at the time, if any sleuths want to look into it.

...

One of Roberts’s more interesting claims, from his bio in his 2009 self-published book, is that he was a “Commissioned Military Officer” and a “Police Officer/Detective.” He dropped this service from his resume until 2022, when a run-in with law enforcement became public. After pleading guilty to violating Pennsylvania gun laws, he released a statement that insinuated the officer was motivated by racism and mentioned that he was “a trained Commissioned Military Officer with a wealth of experience in firearms training and safety.” I found some indications that he was in the Guyanese military, and this would explain the gap he had before entering college in the US in 1995. (Depending on which birth year is accurate, he was either 17, 22, or 25 in 1995.)

...

More on Roberts’s military service in a self-published book he wrote. He says he graduated from officer candidate school when he was 22 and then worked at security detail for Queen Elizabeth. Her visit was in 1994. (It was her first visit in 28 years, not 50 as he says.) If true, he was born prior to 1973.

...

Here is Roberts’s marriage certificate from his 2017 marriage. (I removed a couple of identifying details of other parties, and SSNs were redacted by the county.)

He married a woman who lived in Arkansas, and who now lives in Texas, according to her online bios. Although Roberts has worked in many different places, there is no sign of a connection to either locale. They both worked for Lighthouse Academies at the same time, which is likely how they met.

His date of birth on the marriage certificate is 1970, and his place of birth is Guyana. He was previously married and divorced in 2006. It appears he put a Social Security Number on the form.

...

Some of these court cases from Maryland are not Ian Andre Roberts, the Des Moines superintendent, but most of them appear to be. The records show he had children with a previous wife, who he divorced in 2006, and it appears he had at least one child out of wedlock with another woman. Roberts has continued to have his wages garnished due to one of these lawsuits, which still has not been closed.

...

This is a new one for me! For his 2017 wedding, Roberts essentially had his resume written on a cake. It’s hard to make out, but it appears that he claims degrees from St. John’s (2000), Morgan State (2007), and Georgetown (2014).

Sadly, his children’s birth do not get a mention in his life chronology.

...

Ian Roberts was offered the position of superintendent at Millcreek Township School District in Erie, Pennsylvania in May 2020. School board minutes from July show that they were struggling to ratify the contract because Roberts could not produce the documents necessary to obtain a letter of eligibility. In particular, he had not provided the necessary proof of his doctorate and had not completed the FBI check. An attorney advised them that they could use an “alternate route” to confirm his eligibility for the position. The plan was to employ him, and “hopefully” the FBI clearance would come through within 90 days. Roberts became superintendent in August 2020, and I cannot anything in the board’s records that indicates whether they revisited the matter.

...

Roberts was superintendent for Millcreek Township for three years. Each year the board gave him a rating of “meets expectations”—the equivalent of a grade of C on their 5-point scale. His replacement has received a rating of “outstanding”—their top mark—each year.

These poor ratings for Roberts came before the board even knew that he would make personnel decisions that would cost the district significant sums in legal settlements.

...

etc. etc.




Ping Tung

(3,757 posts)
12. The question should be "Is he a good superintend?
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 11:11 AM
Sunday

If he's not a proper citizen but doing a good job, make his a citizen and let him get back to work.

SickOfTheOnePct

(8,673 posts)
13. Someone who lied about their citizenship...
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 11:16 AM
Sunday

...under penalty of perjury and who has an outstanding weapons charge should just be made a citizen and keep rolling?

The only way this guy should be allowed to stay is if he was naturalized (meaning he didn't lie about his citizenship) and somehow that didn't show up and resulted in the deportation order. And in that case, he should sue the federal government for every penny he can get.

IMO, the fact that his attorney is basically saying "no comment at this time" indicates that there is something fishy with the citizenship claim...attorneys in high profile cases like this would normally start off with "my client is unjustly imprisoned, he's a US citizen, and this outrageous".

Happy to be proven wrong if that's not the case.

Conjuay

(2,712 posts)
18. A weapons charge?
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 12:54 PM
Sunday

This is the United States - who DOESN'T have a weapons charge?


(We need an emoji for cynicism)

SickOfTheOnePct

(8,673 posts)
19. The state of Iowa just revoked his superintendent certificate...
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 10:47 AM
Monday
https://www.kcci.com/article/ian-roberts-dmps-superintendent-state-education-officials-revoke-license/68113564

In a letter to Roberts dated Sept. 28, Michael D. Cavin, executive director of the Board of Educational Examiners, wrote:

Our office has received information that you no longer possess legal presence in the United States, therefore you not able to hold a license issued by the Iowa Board of Educational Examiners (Iowa Code 256, Iowa Administrative Code 282). The license issued by the Board of Educational Examiners is no longer valid and your authority to serve as superintendent is revoked.

Pursuant to Iowa Code 256.151, you may appeal the Executive Director's decision to the Board. If you choose to appeal the Executive Director's decision, you must provide a written letter of appeal. The request for hearing shall specify the factual or legal errors that the applicant contends were made by the executive director, must identify any factual disputes upon which the applicant desires an evidentiary hearing, and may provide additional written information or documents in support of licensure. You should include in the request for appeal a statement of the reason or reasons that you believe provide a basis for reversal of the decision to deny your license application. Address this request for appeal to the Chair, Board of Educational Examiners, 701 E. Court Avenue, Suite A, Des Moines, IA 50309. A written letter of appeal must be received in this office no later than October 28, 2025.

dalton99a

(90,444 posts)
21. +1. It was inevitable. He was a prominent public figure and an easy target for ICE
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 10:56 AM
Monday

He has no leg to stand on. Immigration judges don't order American citizens to be removed.



BannonsLiver

(19,685 posts)
22. This story is a great example of the need to get all the facts before commenting or forming an opinion.
Mon Sep 29, 2025, 12:00 PM
Monday
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Des Moines school superin...