General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsScott Bessent: "In a way, it is a backdoor for privatizing Social Security."
https://www.cnn.com/2025/07/30/politics/social-security-privatization-scott-bessentBessent was discussing the Trump accounts at a Breitbart policy panel. The federal government will contribute $1,000 into these new tax-deferred investment accounts for US citizen children born between 2025 and 2028, while parents and others can contribute up to $5,000 annually. The funds are intended to be used for higher education, buying a home or starting a small business.
The accounts can also be used to help Americans better understand investing and serve as a way to save for retirement, Bessent said. Then he threw out a comment that had Democrats immediately up in arms.
In a way, it is a backdoor for privatizing Social Security, he said. Social Security is a defined benefit plan paid out. To the extent that if, all of a sudden, these accounts grow and you have in the hundreds of thousands of dollars for your retirement, then thats a game changer, too.
Democrats have long accused Republicans of wanting to privatize Social Security a topic that sparks intense reactions from Americans who are suspicious of plans to harm the program after theyve paid into it for years and have resurfaced the issue during President Donald Trumps second term.
Donald Trumps Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent just said the quiet part out loud: The administration is scheming to privatize Social Security, Tim Hogan, the Democratic National Committees senior adviser for messaging, mobilization and strategy, said in a statement. Trump is now coming after American seniors with a backdoor scam to take away the benefits they earned.

calimary
(87,940 posts)Eliot Rosewater
(34,184 posts)We were assured theres no possible way they would do this because they would fear the pushback.
As usual people underestimate how horrible they are.
brush
(61,033 posts)and to hell with the rest of us.
Bettie
(18,912 posts)don't have 5k a year to add to a college fund for one kid, much less more than that.
But, these guys see it from the perspective of a wealthy person, who only has to budget if they are buying a private island or something.
Johonny
(24,791 posts)I don't understand the point of these new accounts other than some backdoor attempt
Swede
(37,432 posts)nt
LetMyPeopleVote
(170,428 posts)Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent just said the quiet part out loud: The administration is scheming to privatize Social Security, the DNC said.
Scott Bessent, Trumpâs Treasury secretary, said he sees part of the Republicansâ megabill as âa backdoor for privatizing Social Security.â
— Steve Benen (@stevebenen.com) 2025-07-30T20:06:03.549Z
It was interesting to see Democrats waste no time in offering âfive-alarm fireâ reactions. www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddo...
https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/trumps-treasury-secretary-says-sees-backdoor-privatizing-social-securi-rcna222062
As Politico reported, the White House Cabinet apparently likes them anyway:
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent on Wednesday framed the presidents new Trump accounts as a transformative tool for long-term wealth building and a backdoor for privatizing Social Security. Bessent said the new tax-deferred investment accounts, which were created by President Donald Trumps sweeping tax law earlier this month, could be a way to boost financial literacy and young voters engagement in the economy.
The logic of Bessents perspective was difficult to follow. According to his pitch at a Brietbart event in Washington, D.C., the treasury secretary believes young people will be less likely to want to bring down the system and vote for candidates such as Zohran Mamdani, the Democratic nominee in New York Citys mayoral race if theyre literally invested in the market.
https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:aunpu65mdrhwfie7ynymlzeh/post/3lv77cuzqn42c
Link to tweet
Bessent added, In a way, it is a backdoor for privatizing Social Security. If, all of a sudden, these accounts grow and you have in the hundreds of thousands of dollars for your retirement, thats a game-changer, too.
The Cabinet secretary didnt elaborate on why, exactly, he thinks this is a backdoor for privatizing Social Security, or why the Trump administration sees privatizing Social Security as a worthwhile policy goal though I'm certainly looking forward to his future comments on the subject. (The accounts included in the megabill wont have any direct impact on Social Security benefits.)....
Brandon Weathersby, a spokesperson for American Bridge 21st Century, a super PAC aligned with Democratic politics, pushed a similar line: Republicans think if they make the SSA inoperable by firing critical staffers and make it nearly impossible to get the help you need, they can deem it all beyond repair and privatize the entire program, so their billionaire friends can make a fortune off the backs of some of the most vulnerable Americans. ... Scott Bessent just admitted what Trump and Republicans have been hiding all along: Their plan was never to protect and strengthen Social Security; it was to dismantle it, take benefits away from seniors and the working-class, and turn the program into a cash cow for the ultra-rich.
I have a hunch the public hasnt heard the last of Bessents quote.