Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

TygrBright

(21,166 posts)
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 05:11 PM 9 hrs ago

Someone asked "Where is the American Outrage on Gaza"?

I can't speak for America, any more than a single Palestinian person can speak for everyone in Gaza, or a single Israeli can speak for everyone in Israel.

But I can speak for myself.

I do not have "outrage".

What I have is heartbreak.

My heart is broken that anyone who might want to discuss or support a realistic way to end this conflict is marginalized, silenced, derided or ignored by those who are certain that only one side is right and has justice and history with them.

My heart is broken by the exploitation of the agony of innocents and the claims that the horrors experienced by only one side matter and those experienced by the other side are trivial or false or, worst of all, justified.

My heart is broken by the lack of places where people who want to bypass the rage, ambition, and greed for power of leaders, can meet one another and talk about common human concerns and experiences.

My heart is broken by the roars of anger and pain and the calls for vengeance in the name of justice and genocide in the name of history.

My heart is broken by the sense that nothing I could do or say would change the trajectory of those bent on killing or displacing everyone they perceive as being in the wrong about Gaza.

My heart is broken by the weight of history that has soaked that stretch of land with blood for centuries in the name of group after group of claimants unwilling to extend tolerance and justice to others and/or exercise moderation and consideration in their own actions there.

My heart is broken by failure after failure of diplomacy and nation-building and aspiration subverted by politics, greed, fear, and hate.

My heart is broken by the awareness that my government is not only no longer interested in appearing as a humanitarian broker of peace, but is actively pursuing an agenda of escalating the misery and chaos. And by the awareness that nothing I can say or do will change that unless and until I have the opportunity again to vote for competent and humanitarian leadership in America.

I do not wish a plague on both their houses (for one thing "both" doesn't begin to encompass the number of interests and parties and groups and human beings whose welfare is at stake there.)

But wishing enlightenment on all their houses seems both futile and disingenuous, even if it is meant in utter heartfelt sincerity.

And so I carry my heartbreak in silence, knowing that it will meet with nothing but scorn, derision, and denial from everyone who "knows" what I "should" be doing or feeling or saying, and be ignored by the rest.

heartbrokenly,
Bright

27 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Someone asked "Where is the American Outrage on Gaza"? (Original Post) TygrBright 9 hrs ago OP
I consider religions to be the destroyers of humanity. They are the primary reason we are not better than this. walkingman 9 hrs ago #1
I think of religion as a parasitic subculture that Gaugamela 8 hrs ago #3
Fear of the unknown nowforever 7 hrs ago #13
I consider religion--made by man--both literally and figuratively--to be the greatest evil on earth. h2ebits 7 hrs ago #14
especially when co-opted and the religion distorted for retribution and just pure vengeance. Kinda like USA today Evolve Dammit 7 hrs ago #16
Religion is why we cant have nice things n/t gay texan 4 hrs ago #26
Thank you Bread and Circuses 8 hrs ago #2
💔You speak for me, Bright💔 Hekate 8 hrs ago #4
Beautiful! Thank you. TheRickles 8 hrs ago #5
Thank you for this eloquent statement that so powerfully expresses exactly how I feel. n/t. NNadir 8 hrs ago #6
All you stated. Thanks. The sadness hurts us but being there is beyond thinking. twodogsbarking 8 hrs ago #7
Finally, a post on this subject that I'm not afraid of and that I support 100%. Biophilic 8 hrs ago #8
Beautifully said Bright. Personally, I am outraged. flashman13 8 hrs ago #9
F Netanyahu. Gimpyknee 8 hrs ago #11
Let's bdamomma 6 hrs ago #22
Beautifully spoken. . . .I feel your thoughts in my heart and soul h2ebits 8 hrs ago #10
i just now posted this on fb barbtries 7 hrs ago #12
Very well said. Ping Tung 7 hrs ago #15
Well said. Innocents are suffering. surfered 7 hrs ago #17
Very well said, Bright. Buddyzbuddy 7 hrs ago #18
Our guilt Godot51 6 hrs ago #19
Agreed! perdita9 6 hrs ago #20
excellent post B.See 6 hrs ago #21
Very well said. TomSlick 6 hrs ago #23
I do feel outrage. NH Ethylene 6 hrs ago #24
Im sorry a bit myopic Samael13 4 hrs ago #25
Excellent posts by all Traildogbob 4 hrs ago #27

walkingman

(9,576 posts)
1. I consider religions to be the destroyers of humanity. They are the primary reason we are not better than this.
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 05:15 PM
9 hrs ago

Gaugamela

(2,893 posts)
3. I think of religion as a parasitic subculture that
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 05:35 PM
8 hrs ago

attaches itself to an otherwise well-organized and thriving society and tells everyone that they are the essential ingredient that makes it all work. They seek to expand until they can take over and kill the host and replace it with their twisted patriarchal ponzi scheme, kind of like Ridley Scott's Alien, or the Borg in Star Trek. Religion is a vicious alien invasion, in my book.

nowforever

(564 posts)
13. Fear of the unknown
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 06:25 PM
7 hrs ago

which is really the fear of death is the element in the human psyche that opens the door to the creation of God to alleviate the fear. Well crafted fiction used to manipulate and exploit others.

h2ebits

(912 posts)
14. I consider religion--made by man--both literally and figuratively--to be the greatest evil on earth.
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 06:27 PM
7 hrs ago

Evolve Dammit

(21,024 posts)
16. especially when co-opted and the religion distorted for retribution and just pure vengeance. Kinda like USA today
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 06:44 PM
7 hrs ago

Bread and Circuses

(923 posts)
2. Thank you
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 05:33 PM
8 hrs ago

I’ve been heartbroken and disgusted too. I have donated to a vetted charity. I also send intentions for peace. I saw a protest by young Israeli citizens . Not only is the World letting Netanyahu kill children daily. But,we are funding this with our taxes.

Republicans don’t care about people . They are madman who thrive on sadism, cruelty , and suffering.

The USA is now a fascist state. We protect, we send letters AND nothing.

Genocide is OK if you kill people that the oligarchs want eliminated.

Saudi, Qatar, Bahrain, UAE, etc. are RICH. They need to get involved in a peace plan. The US is no longer credible.

NNadir

(36,191 posts)
6. Thank you for this eloquent statement that so powerfully expresses exactly how I feel. n/t.
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 06:03 PM
8 hrs ago

Biophilic

(5,888 posts)
8. Finally, a post on this subject that I'm not afraid of and that I support 100%.
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 06:09 PM
8 hrs ago

Thank you so much for your time and thoughts needed to write something this clear and not designed to start another fight.
Your post makes me want to cry because it speaks to the heart of the tragedy instead of the intractable emotions.

barbtries

(30,598 posts)
12. i just now posted this on fb
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 06:23 PM
7 hrs ago

along with a link to WHO's press release.

The genocide in Gaza is no better than the Crimes Against Humanity right here in the USA.

It is tiresome to learn of atrocities, injustices, the murder of innocents, the destruction of families, the incessant cruelty and barbarity, day in and day out. But I think it's important to remember that they WANT us exhausted, emotionally bankrupt, in despair and terror, so they can control us. So they can continue their abominations unimpeded.

So it is important to stay informed. It's important to continue caring. Self care is also important, and after I hit post I'm gonna turn on the youtube, watch poker or true crime, and play games on my iPad until I pass out. Not that my dreams are always rosy these days

https://www.who.int/news/item/21-07-2025-who-operations-compromised-following-attacks-on-warehouse-and-facility-sheltering-staff-and-families-in-deir-al-balah

This news came to me today on the heels of the expose by the Guardian about atrocious conditions in Miami FL. The headline alone is just a portion of the crimes being committed in this hellhole; as my sign for last Thursday's Good Trouble stated, "in our name" "on our dime"

even the genocide in Gaza is financed by our tax dollars. It is heartbreaking true but I am also outraged. Righteously!

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jul/21/migrants-miami-ice-jail-abuses

Buddyzbuddy

(1,195 posts)
18. Very well said, Bright.
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 07:06 PM
7 hrs ago

Since it would be futile on my part to express my self as well as you have, I hope you don't mind if I sign on to your statement, not as my own but in admiration of your eloquence which I lack, to express what I too think and feel.
Be well

Godot51

(558 posts)
19. Our guilt
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 07:31 PM
6 hrs ago

I was born after the war, a white, catholic boy. I grew up in the 50s and 60s believing in the right of Israel against the rights of the "Arabs".

I read Leon Uris' "Exodus" and James Michener's "The Source", and, later, Herman Wouk's "The Winds of War" and "War and Remembrance". I felt those books and their stories strongly.

Driven by the guilt over the United States' complacency during the early period of the Holocaust I rejoiced in Israel's triumph in the Six Day War of '67 and was relieved after the Yom Kipper War in '73 ended.

However, as early as the 80s, cracks in the images, the propaganda, and the narrative began to show. The continuing terrorist attacks justified Israel but the actual plight of the Palestine people did not.

Now I live in a quandary wishing the U.S. had some solution, some hope, and some actual influence. But "we the people" do not. The constant wars have bored us. We cannot focus, we don't want to hear about it, we want some "magical" event to come about.

What? The Rapture? Armageddon? A final solution? We don't know.

Today both sides are represented by a violent, aggressive, single minded minority with the majority trapped in the middle. The U.S. is dominated by a corrupt, venal, ignorant administration with no plans, no concepts, and no desired for any of this to end.

We are as helpless as the peoples of both Israel and Palestine.

perdita9

(1,279 posts)
20. Agreed!
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 07:36 PM
6 hrs ago

I tried to speak with local Gaza activists about this last year, but all they would do was blame Israel and the U.S. for what's going on. You would have thought Hamas didn't even exist.

Yes, I want peace for the entire region and I want the people of Gaza to rebuild their society--a society that includes rights for all residents and hope for a brighter future.

TomSlick

(12,600 posts)
23. Very well said.
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 07:46 PM
6 hrs ago

Reasoned discussion is difficult when there is wrong on both sides and both sides are convinced that they are right.

I too am left with only heartbreak.

NH Ethylene

(31,185 posts)
24. I do feel outrage.
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 08:21 PM
6 hrs ago

But at 70 years of age, I don't have the energy to sustain it or act on it in any useful way.

So I settle into heartbreak, for all the innocent men and women and children in Gaza who have been killed, for the medical workers who have been shot down, for the babies who are dying of starvation, and on and on.

There is no way to justify this carnage. I'd like to say it will be a haunting chapter of history like the Holocaust is, but I fear it won't ever be in the past, that it will never be resolved.

Samael13

(44 posts)
25. Im sorry a bit myopic
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 09:44 PM
4 hrs ago

But as bad as I feel for them unless we find a way to get this country back all the outrage in the world will amount to nothing. Plus alot of Palestinian supporters didnt exactly help them with protest votes and not voting. So again sorry I have to worry about us first before i can be worried about helping anyone else.

Traildogbob

(11,517 posts)
27. Excellent posts by all
Mon Jul 21, 2025, 09:58 PM
4 hrs ago

I feel among friends that Mirror all my emotions.
Religion has welcomed evil for power, of evil has sucked in religion, for power. Either way, Evil is in full control, and innocents die by the masses. Freakin little girls at Jesus camp. No God in sight to protect the followers that get killed as sacrificial casualties, as the cost of Freedom or profit.
And the Jesus Con people, are raking in trillions.
Count Moses Mike as the spokes person for Jesus Cons.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Someone asked "Where is t...