General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDOJ flouting order to share information
by Rebecca Beitsch - 04/22/25 11:56 AM ET
... Xinis last week ordered four Trump administration officials to sit for depositions with Abrego Garcias attorneys as well as respond to written questions from their team in the wake of a Supreme Court decision ordering Trump attorneys to facilitate the Maryland mans return.
But Abrego Garcias attorneys said the government has resisted supplying needed information in discovery requests also mandated by Xinis.
On the eve of the first Court-ordered deposition concerning the Governments failure to comply with this Courts orders, the Government responded to Plaintiffs discovery requests by producing nothing of substance, they wrote in the filing, asking Xinis to set a hearing to review the matter.
The filing is the latest sign the Trump administration is digging in after initially telling Xinis it had no way to secure Abrego Garcias return once he was turned over to be imprisoned in El Salvador ...
https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/5260757-trump-administration-resists-court-orders/

struggle4progress
(122,819 posts)... Abrego Garcia's attorneys said the administration has claimed state secrets privilege and governmental privilege "without any foundation for doing so."
The attorneys also said they invited government officials to meet and confer several times, but the officials declined to meet until Monday evening, "on the eve of depositions."
Department of Homeland Security Acting General Counsel Joseph Mazzara was scheduled to be deposed Tuesday, according to the letter.
The government, in the same letter, said they have "put forward a good-faith effort to provide appropriate responses to both Plaintiffs' Interrogatories and Request for Production" ...
https://abcnews.go.com/US/abrego-garcias-attorneys-decry-administrations-failure-comply-court/story?id=121046788
Violet_Crumble
(36,209 posts)State secrets? The more classified and secret things are, the more likely it is that Hegseth will have a group chat set up with his family, friends, a journalist, and a few random drunk guys he met when he was on the booze.
LetMyPeopleVote
(161,908 posts)The judge is really pissed. The DOJ actually refused to answer an interrogatory about efforts taken to facilitate the return of Mr. Garcia by misreading the ruling of the SCOTUS
Link to tweet

I cannot imagine a lawyer making this argument in good faith
Link to tweet

As I predicted the judge was NOT amused
Link to tweet

The Judge actually called the DOJ for being in bad faith
Link to tweet

There evidently were no sanctions yet but I can see the DOJ appealing to the SCOTUS (the Fourth Circuit has already ruled on this and was clear on the DOJ's obligation to felicitate the release and return of Mr. Garcia
This judge is pissed
bucolic_frolic
(49,929 posts)Trump will ignore SCOTUS until he can corner them and take over the entire judicial system, same with the Fed. Anyone who thinks we're making progress is playing by the old rules where boundaries and legalities meant something. Meanwhile the beast rolls on.