Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
MaddowBlog-Why Trump's talk about sending out tariff rebate checks makes so little sense [View all]
As the president pushes “dividend” checks from tariffs, there’s an accounting maxim he still doesn’t understand: “You can’t spend the same dollar twice.”
Why Trump’s talk about sending out tariff rebate checks makes so little sense www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddo...
— @jimrissmiller.bsky.social 2025-11-11T20:09:58.056Z
https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/trumps-talk-sending-tariff-rebate-checks-makes-little-sense-rcna243292
As this week got underway, Donald Trump held an event in the Oval Office ostensibly about the swearing in of an ambassador, although the president took the opportunity to emphasize one of his priorities.
....A day earlier, by way of his social media platform, Trump touted his idea of rebate checks worth “at least” $2,000 per person, adding that they’ll be “paid to everyone” except high-income earners. As part of the pitch, the president added that he also intends to use the same tariff revenue to “begin paying down our ENORMOUS DEBT, $37 Trillion.” (Not to be picky, but the national debt recently topped $38 trillion.)....
But putting that aside, the fact that Trump vowed to use tariff revenue simultaneously for “dividend” checks and for debt reduction underscores a problem he doesn’t seem to understand. There’s an old accounting maxim, “You can’t spend the same dollar twice,” and it’s time for the president to familiarize himself with the idea.
As regular readers know, Trump’s tariffs are generating revenue. He’s wildly exaggerated how much revenue, pointing to “trillions” of dollars, despite the reality of far more modest sums, but the money does exist. That’s not exactly surprising: Tariffs are, for all intents and purposes, taxes — and taxes generate revenue......
In late September, during his radical remarks to U.S. generals and admirals, Trump said, “We’ve taken in trillions of dollars. We’re rich again.” If he were right and the U.S. had actually taken in trillions of dollars since he began implementing his tariff scheme, we might have a very different kind of conversation. But in reality, tariff revenue was roughly $195 billion in the fiscal year that ended in late September. (That’s “billion” with a b, not “trillion” with a t.)
And while $195 billion might sound like an enormous amount of money, in the context of federal expenditures, that’s not even close to being enough to pay for all of the things the president has talked about.
In late July, Trump boasted online, “our Country is doing very well and can afford just about anything.” It’d be nice if that were true.
Trump: "We're gonna issue a dividend to our middle income people and lower income people of about ,000, and we're gonna use the remaining tariffs to lower our debt."
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) 2025-11-10T20:58:47.036Z
....A day earlier, by way of his social media platform, Trump touted his idea of rebate checks worth “at least” $2,000 per person, adding that they’ll be “paid to everyone” except high-income earners. As part of the pitch, the president added that he also intends to use the same tariff revenue to “begin paying down our ENORMOUS DEBT, $37 Trillion.” (Not to be picky, but the national debt recently topped $38 trillion.)....
But putting that aside, the fact that Trump vowed to use tariff revenue simultaneously for “dividend” checks and for debt reduction underscores a problem he doesn’t seem to understand. There’s an old accounting maxim, “You can’t spend the same dollar twice,” and it’s time for the president to familiarize himself with the idea.
As regular readers know, Trump’s tariffs are generating revenue. He’s wildly exaggerated how much revenue, pointing to “trillions” of dollars, despite the reality of far more modest sums, but the money does exist. That’s not exactly surprising: Tariffs are, for all intents and purposes, taxes — and taxes generate revenue......
In late September, during his radical remarks to U.S. generals and admirals, Trump said, “We’ve taken in trillions of dollars. We’re rich again.” If he were right and the U.S. had actually taken in trillions of dollars since he began implementing his tariff scheme, we might have a very different kind of conversation. But in reality, tariff revenue was roughly $195 billion in the fiscal year that ended in late September. (That’s “billion” with a b, not “trillion” with a t.)
And while $195 billion might sound like an enormous amount of money, in the context of federal expenditures, that’s not even close to being enough to pay for all of the things the president has talked about.
In late July, Trump boasted online, “our Country is doing very well and can afford just about anything.” It’d be nice if that were true.
2 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
= new reply since forum marked as read